深入揭秘 Deel 前所未有的增长 | Meltem Kuran Berkowitz(增长负责人)
An inside look at Deel’s unprecedented growth | Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (Head of Growth)
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: … early days, it’s very important to just go back to the basics, build the skeleton before you put on the makeup. So the first question I would ask is, do you have a website? Is it fast? Do the search engine knows that it exists? Okay, great. The next step would be, can people find it? If they can’t find it, do you need to write content to make sure that people can find it? Only after all of those questions are answered, should you then consider, do I have money? Can I put it behind some paid ads to make sure people come to my website? You can’t run a successful paid ads program if you have a website that’s loading in four plus seconds. So really going back to the basics and starting from a good experience at the core and then expanding step-by-step from there.
Lenny: Welcome to Lenny’s Podcast where I interview world-class product leaders and growth experts to learn from their hard won experiences building and growing today’s most successful products. Today my guest is Meltem Kuran Berkowitz. Meltem is head of growth at Deel, which is arguably the fastest growing SaaS business of all time, possibly even faster than Ramp, which we delved into in a previous episode. They went from 300 million in revenue in three years, while also staying EBITDA positive.
Meltem has led their growth team from the early days. And today leads all their growth efforts, including paid ads, product marketing, content, community, brand and more. Before joining Deel, she was leading marketing efforts at Bench Accounting. In our conversation, Meltem shares how Deel kick started growth through low-cost growth channels like tapping into communities like Reddit and also content and SEO. She also talks about how she evolved her thinking on growth investments as the company grew. She shares a bunch of tactical advice for how to do SEO well, how to do paid ads well, and how to structure your early growth team and prioritize your early investments. She also shares her experience building a culture of speed and optimism and so much more. Enjoy this episode with Meltem Kuran Berkowitz after a short word from our sponsors.
Miro is a killer tool for brainstorming with your team, laying out your strategy, sharing user research findings, capturing ideas, giving feedback on wireframes, and generally just collaborating with your colleagues. I actually used Miro to collaborate with the Miro team on creating my own board, and it was super fun and super easy. Go check it out at miro.com/lenny. That’s M-I-R-O.com/lenny.
You can try LMNT totally risk-free. If you don’t like it, you can share it with a salty friend and they’ll give you your money back no questions asked. To give it a shot, go to drinklmnt.com/lenny and you’ll get a free sample pack with any purchase, which includes one packet of every flavor. My favorite is Watermelon Salt. You won’t find this offer publicly available, so you have to head to drinklmnt.com/lenny to take advantage of this offer. Stay salty.
Meltem, thank you so much for being here, welcome to the podcast.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Thank you for having me, I’m very excited to be here.
Lenny: I’m more excited that you’re here. So you’re head of growth at Deel. For people that aren’t familiar with Deel, can you just give us a sense of what does Deel do briefly? And then also can you just share some stats around the trajectory of Deel? It feels like it’s been this extraordinary journey, and I’m curious just to hear some of the stats of just how extraordinary.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah, so Deel is payroll, HR, and compliance platform for global teams. So essentially we help companies expand globally with tools like Deel HR, immigration, employer record hiring, independent contractor hiring, payroll, both global and US. So whether you’re trying to hire someone as a full-time employee in Japan or you’re trying to make sure your contractor in Germany has everything they need on day one, our platform allows you to take care of everything all in one place.
And when I joined Deel, actually that was around July, 2020, we were less than a million dollars in ARR. And then over time, within the first year on January, 2021, we were at 295 million in ARR. And what we’re particularly proud of is that we’ve been EBITDA positive. So that’s something that we are very, very proud of on top of the ARR growth.
Lenny: Amazing. And you said that you were super early at Deel. Can you give us a sense of just how early and what that was like?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I was the second hire to the marketing team, and I was I believe either employee 19 or 20 on the overall Deel team.
Lenny: We had the head of product from Ramp on this podcast, and it feels like there’s this little bit of which company grew faster early on in the trajectory of the two, but we don’t have to debate it. It feels like these are maybe the two fastest growing SaaS businesses in history. Does that sound about right?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: That’s true, yeah. So Ramp was the first one to be crowned the fastest growing, and then we took that crown from them. So I think we’re both right, in that at a certain point in time we’ve each been the fastest growing. But they’re amazing.
Lenny: What I want to start with is something that I heard about you, which is that you specialize in cheaper growth channels, and that’s actually the reason that Deel ended up hiring you, is they wanted to find ways to grow cheaply. And so a couple of questions. One is just, what did you find worked really well from that perspective at Deel? And then two, what are today’s maybe cheaper growth channels that you think people are under investing in? Whatever you’re willing to share there, I don’t know if you want to give away all your secrets.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I’m happy to give away all and everything. So I think before we dive into the list of cheap channels, which I will get to, it’s very important to notice, especially in the B2B world, most of the businesses are started because there’s an active problem. And so when you go out to the market and try to answer people’s questions, people don’t want to be sold to, they want their problem solved. So those cheaper channels are often places where people are just trying to get an answer to their question. So whether that be search engine optimization through the articles that you write for people, looking onto Reddit where people are asking these questions in communities, forming partnerships with other groups that are trying to answer these questions, existing communities where other business leaders are connecting with each other and looking at their peers to find answers to shared problems that they’re having, or places like Quora. That’s, when you think about cheap channels, that’s a really good place to start, is just add value to people, answer their questions.
And when you answer their questions and present your solution, if it’s a fit to what they’re looking for, that ends up being a cheap channel for you. You don’t necessarily have to advertise, when you go to Reddit and you set up those keywords to be tracking when people ask certain questions, you’re not paying any money to do that. You’re just seeing, oh, someone has this question, I have the answer to that, here you go. And connecting with them, it takes time. But early on, those were a lot of the things that we invested in.
And I think a lot of people jump that because they think, “Oh, it’s one person here, two people there.” But when you start helping people, that combined with word of mouth, and guess what, these are digital places, you provide one answer and your answer lives out there for other people to repeatedly refine. As long as we’re not talking about a closed Slack community, maybe a conversation happening in DMs. So when I think about cheap channels, I think about where are people asking the questions, that might be Google or that might be Reddit or any other channel, and providing them the answers, so they know that your solution exists.
Lenny: Okay, this is awesome. So this Reddit example is that, which you actually did, you set alerts for when people have questions about HR hiring internationally I imagine, and then had someone go in there and give them some advice?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes, exactly that’s what we did.
Lenny: Wow, I love that.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: It’s important to notice that if you’re looking at a subreddit of about a thousand people, recognize the upper size of this audience, you’re not going to win 5,000 businesses through that Reddit community, but you’re maybe going to win 10% of the people there that are having this problem. So it’s very important when investing in these cheap channels to focus on what’s the upper limit of the audience size.
And also I see a lot of people sometimes go blindly into SEO. They’re like, “We’re just going to write content,” which I’m a huge fan of SEO, happy to discuss that later, but if people aren’t asking this question to Google, you can write all the content you want, it doesn’t matter, nobody’s going to find it.
Lenny: I love this so much, because it connects with something I find again and again, is one of the more effective early growth channels is tapping into an existing community and piggybacking off of what they’ve already built. Airbnb is a little bit of an example where they went to Craigslist. Actually most people pull people off Craigslist, Uber pull people off Craigslist, Lyft, so many companies just piggybacked off Craigslist and built up their own company.
But what you said is so important, which is you can’t just go into a community and be like, “Hey, everyone, check out what I’ve got.” You need to add value to people and add value to the community, otherwise no one’s going to pay attention to you, they’re going to kick you out.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Exactly.
Lenny: And so I think that is a really important insight is if you’re trying to say piggyback off of a community, the most important thing is you need to add value to the community.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah, be someone people actually want to talk to.
Lenny: I love that. Is there a tool that you found for that Reddit strategy of just how to know if someone’s talking about hiring say internationally?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I did a very janky assistant setup, I’m not proud of it, but it works. Someone else out there built it and I just plugged in the keywords we were looking for into it.
Lenny: I know it wasn’t just Reddit, and I’m curious what else you found was worth your time, but how did you figure out that’s where your potential community and potential users were spending time?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Well, I think over time Reddit became the place that you go to when you want peer answers, whether that peer is someone right next to you or someone halfway across the world. So it was a very obvious place for me to go to understand, what’s top of mind for my audience? But also there are so many subreddits, whether it’s founders or HR managers, that people are just asking their community. Because oftentimes they have very specific questions. You can’t just ask that to Google because they have one thing that means that they might not be able to qualify for the exact solution that is what’s most used out there. So Reddit just became the place over the years for people to ask their specific questions semi-anonymously and get answers from their community, and multiple answers to be able to judge which works better versus didn’t. So it was one of the first places that myself and my team went to.
Lenny: And is this something that worked really well, mostly at the beginning to kickstart growth or how early was this? And then how much of your growth would you say came from this sort of strategy early on?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I believe I set up that little keyword tracking within the first day of me starting my role at Deel. So it was very, very early. And we still do this by the way. We still provide answers across Reddit, Quora communities. We’re still out there connecting with people. Over time, of course, it went from maybe being 15% of our funnel to less than 5% of our funnel because the rest of our funnel has grown a lot. But the next number of people that we get to share our solution with through those channels have continued to grow over time.
Lenny: Coming back to something I asked that I want to touch on is, in today’s world are there any cheaper growth channels that you are excited about? Or is it essentially the same idea? Look for where your potential users are and ideally asking questions that you could help answer? Is that roughly how you think about it still?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: That is still roughly how I think about it. I would add social channels to that as well. I think Twitter’s a great place, people ask questions oftentimes, so there are communities. And when someone has answered that question, other people piggyback off of that. But anywhere where someone is asking a question, I would consider to fall into this category of a cheap channel.
Lenny: What’s an example of answering a question in a value-add way versus a maybe less effective way in your experience?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I would say the least effective way would be, “Hey, we’ve solved that problem, check out our website.” Okay, cool, if you have five seconds, do that. But the value-add way would be explaining what the solution to that problem is. Because the reality is there are a lot of people out there who can probably solve this, and then providing your solution, but answer their question first, and then let them decide if they want to come with you or go with someone else. But the whole point of someone asking a question isn’t to be sold a solution. It’s like, “I just need an answer.” So genuinely treat this person like a friend of yours, answer their question, be like, “Yes, it’s doable. No, it’s not doable. Yes, you can do it, but you need to consider X, Y, Z. If you want to learn more about it, you can chat with us.”
Lenny: And these were people on the team or you answering these questions, it wasn’t some automated system?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: It was never automated. It still isn’t today. We would never automate our interactions with people. So early days, it was myself, the other people on my team, our co-founders, which to this day they still do by the way. So it’s a lot of people on the team. Every single person on the team has access to these. And whoever is the first person to jump in will flag it. And sometimes you’ll see on a Twitter, someone will write a question, there’s three people from Deel team has answered. We’re like, “Okay, I think enough of us have provided value here.”
Lenny: That’s amazing. And I’m spending a lot of time on this, but this is such an interesting and important tactic that clearly worked to help you all start and it’s cheap. And most, at least B2B, companies could probably leverage this. So when people are thinking about where to go, maybe do this, you mentioned Twitter, maybe Reddit, maybe Quora. Is there anything else, just like the sphere of potential places founders can go think about whether maybe people are asking questions they could answer there?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah, there are a lot of closed communities, so there are still … they could be Slack communities, Discord, places that founders choose to connect with other founders. Or we have partnerships with places like the Y Combinator, where once you go through a certain program or you qualify to be in the club, whatever that club may be, you get to get access to this community where you can talk to other people. So those are considered closed communities. It’s not as easy to gain access to. But if you can find a way to gain access to those communities, they’re also great places to be.
Lenny: And then step number one is add value, right?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes.
Lenny: You can’t just get in the community, “Hey, check out Deel everyone.”
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Otherwise you’ll just get kicked out. You can try not adding value, you’re not going to last very long.
Lenny: Yeah. If you think about the pie chart of how growth happened at Deel early on and then today, what would that roughly look like? What percentage of early growth came through this versus SEO or whatever else worked, and then today? Whatever you can share of where growth comes from.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Today, roughly about I would say 50% of our growth continues to come from what we would consider non-paid channels, through whether it be partnerships, SEO, these kinds of moderations. So early on that was more close to 80% to 90%. But that number has grown. Again, the net number has grown, but the percentage of the overall value has shrunk because other channels have also grown significantly.
Lenny: Awesome. Okay. So let’s talk about SEO. First of all, how important has that been to the success and growth of Deel? And then also just what have you learned about what is important to get SEO right?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah. So I would say for SEO, the biggest mistake people make is they will just shove keywords. They’re like, “Okay, these are the keywords people are searching for, I need to make sure I mention it five times.” Obviously do that, make sure that the content that you wrote answers the question. But the main thing to think about it is, is the Google search over? If someone reads your content, if they typed in something to Google, and then they read the article that you’ve published, are they going back to Google to continue reading more or is the Google search over? Because ultimately that’s what the search engines care about is, I want to make sure this person gets their answer quickest way possible.
So when you think from that perspective, it’s much easier to actually write things that people want to read, and you’re not just meandering and going on and on, shoving a bunch of keywords that people are just like, “I’m bored, I’m bouncing, I’m going somewhere else.”
So asking that question of, is the search over is a really good place to start, instead of just shoving keywords. And our content team is amazing. I would say they’re more of an operational team than they are a creative team. The way they run things, the way they publish the articles, there’s a very clear framework that is used to decide what gets published when and what doesn’t get published by the same token. So all of those things are very important to consider, instead of just being like, “Oh, this keyword has 10,000 monthly visitors, I’m just going to write a bunch of things about that.”
Lenny: What’s an example of a page that you wrote that ends people search and gives them what they need?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: A lot of people wonder what an EOR is because that’s an employer of record. They tend to be confused about exactly what that is. So we do very well in explaining to people what EOR is and isn’t and what its limitations are. Because the first question that you will have after the EOR question’s answered is, okay, what’s the downside? When do I need to not use it? So for us, that’s one of the content pieces that does very well.
Lenny: I’d love to spend more time on this operational element of the SEO team. Maybe one question is just what is that bar that tells you that it’s ready to publish and worth going out versus it’s not ready?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes. So I can’t take credit to this, this is all of our team’s work. But we have this framework that we call the traffic light system. Essentially we go, whenever the team is going to do a content series, they will go and find up to 700 keywords. These are keywords that are related to what we do. So they might be closely related, they might be distant related. And then those set of keywords get ranked by highest volume to the lowest volume. So then you have an Excel sheet, keywords on the left, volume on the right. And then you go one by one. This does take time. And then say, what is the intent of someone searching this keyword?
Is this a university student looking to write an article and they’re never going to become our customer? Or is this someone that is actually looking to solve their existing solution and they are going to become our customer? So with that, you get the green light ones, which is the intent is very high, this person wants our solution. The yellow light is intent, could be they are a 50:50, maybe they’re looking to buy our solution, maybe it’s not soon enough. And then the red is, this person is not looking to buy our solution, they’re just doing this search for any other reason. So when you do that, then you go from the greens, highest volume to the lowest volume, yellows, highest volume to the lowest volume, and oftentimes you never get to the reds.
Lenny: I love that. And then once you have say a keyword, say a green, I guess, it’s a green keyword where it’s high intent and high volume, what is the process to actually put together an article that works for SEO?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: So step one is understanding the search intent. Why is someone typing that? What are they trying to understand? And a part of that is going to Google and figuring out, what is Google servicing today? So one of the examples that I always give people of when you type EOR into Google, it doesn’t give you employer of record, it gives you enhanced oil recovery, because most of the people typing EOR to Google is looking for that solution.
Now, if my team blindly went in and said, “We’re going to rank for EOR,” we’re never going to rank for that because that’s not what Google gives people because that’s not what people have been looking for. So first is understanding, what are people looking for? And creating a content piece that answers those questions. Oftentimes the bottom part of Google where it says, the next questions that you should be asking is a really good place to go to understand, okay, after someone’s done with this search, what’s the next question that they ask? And the next one and the next one.
So figuring out what do people want to get out of this? And then there are a myriad of SEO solutions tools that you can use out there to ensure that the content you’ve written is in a simple enough language that someone with a fifth grade reading level can understand. That you actually did the right things, you put the right keywords in the right places. I almost think of keywords as like, that’s your address, that’s how you give Google, please send people my way. So you can use many tools.
We use Clearscope, we love it. So those are the tools that you use. And then it gets published. And oftentimes those tools will give you a score to say you’re an A plus or you’re a C minus, you need to make your language less sophisticated, currently it’s at university level and we need it to be at fourth grade reading level.
Lenny: What is the structure of the content team at this point, how many people is it, and what are their rough focuses?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Fun fact about our content team, the person that leads it was one of the earliest employees at Deel, I want to say number two or three. So the person there is just so special to our entire company. And so the structure of the content team for us is, it is led by our director of content. We have one person that is in charge of all of the operations. So that is working with our freelancers, making sure that the briefs are sent out, making sure that the fact checking is done on time, that the articles are published on the website, and tracking and everything, they run the machinery on the backend.
And then we have different people focused on different areas of content because you need to have expertise that you build over time to write properly. So we have one person looking after certain product lines, another person would be focusing on [inaudible 00:22:46] behind different product lines. And very recently we’ve set out a team for different types of content because content isn’t just written article, it’s also video, it’s also education. There’s a lot of different types of content that we want to tap into. So now there’s a team that is focused on those new mediums for us.
Lenny: Awesome. So how many people total full-time that run this operation?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Right now the team is about eight people total.
Lenny: And it’s like, I don’t know if it’s exactly 50% of it, something like half of your growth essentially is coming from this team?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes.
Lenny: Is there anything else you found that it’s really important or effective for thinking about making SEO work?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: The biggest mistake people make is SEO is one of those things that, you can try and automate it, you can do a lot of things that save you time, but it never stops being time-consuming. And to do it well, it is going to be time-consuming. So oftentimes people just get over it or they think it’s below them to be going over and doing keyword research and doing all of those things one by one. And that’s oftentimes where people lose out is they try to cut corners. And when you cut corners, you just don’t create a good quality resource. That’s what it comes down to. It’s like, is your resource good quality? Yes or no?
So when you try to just be like, I want to rank and cut all those corners, your content is not going to be great. Nobody’s going to want to read it. And your program is not going to go anywhere. So I think it’s one of those things that people as they become more senior think it’s below them. And I think that’s the biggest mistake.
Lenny: It’s interesting, and that’s exactly the same advice for writing a newsletter, the thing I do. Where if a newsletter isn’t working, it usually means the content isn’t valuable enough to people. It’s such a clear meritocracy of, if it’s useful, people will read it, subscribe, share. And if they’re not, they won’t subscribe. And then Google basically figures that out based on people’s behavior.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes, exactly.
Lenny: To give people a sense of the operation, how many articles are you putting out a month, a day, a week, whatever you can share there?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: We used to put out about 10 articles a week, that’s net new. Whereas now we are doing more of five new articles and five article updates. Because the type of content we write, regulations change, things change all the time, so we need to make sure that even if something was published two years ago, it’s up-to-date. So we have a team that is responsible for continuously fact checking. So we do about five article updates and five net new articles written. And of course we do it across many different languages. So what started off as English only operations is now in other languages as well. So there’s no shortage of work to go around.
Lenny: Something that I go back and forth on a bit is, if SEO is something every company should be doing and will work for them? And in my experience, there’s certain products that are really good for SEO, especially if there’s user generated content or there’s just a bunch of data like say Yelp or Glassdoor, where they can generate tons of pages in all these different ways. Do you have an opinion on what sort of business and company is best suited for SEO? Or is your feeling everyone should probably be doing SEO in some form? And even if it’s not a huge part of your growth strategy, it’ll help.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I don’t think everybody should be doing SEO. I think if you are in a space where people are looking for a solution, you should be doing SEO. But if you are a direct to consumer company selling people lipstick, which I’m a huge buyer of, you probably shouldn’t invest in SEO all that much because people don’t go to Google for that. They go to Instagram, they go to influencers. And even if someone types in the best lipstick of 2023, chances of your website ranking, because you’re not a third party objective comparing to other people, is very low. So it really depends on the solution. But if you are in a space which most B2B products tend to be, that you’re solving an active problem very specifically, then I would say SEO is a good idea. If you’re a consumer good, maybe a little bit less effort should be put towards it.
Lenny: Makes a lot of sense. Going back to the early days, you were hired as head of growth at Deel, there’s a lot of things you could do. I’m curious how you decided where to prioritize your resources and what to do in the early days? Versus what you started doing down the road and what you could almost not worry about early on? What have you learned about that early prioritization exercise?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes. So I would say early days, it’s very important to just go back to the basics, build the skeleton before you put on the makeup. So the first question I would ask is, do you have a website? Is it fast? Do the search engine knows that it exists? Okay, great. The next step would be, can people find it? If they can’t find it, you need to write content to make sure that people can find it.
Only after all of those questions are answered, should you then consider, do I have money? Can I put it behind some paid ads to make sure people come to my website? So going step-by-step. But you can’t run a successful paid ads program if you have a website that’s loading in four plus seconds. So really going back to the basics and starting from a good experience at the core. And then expanding step-by-step from there is how I would suggest everybody starts. And that’s what I would do if I was to get hired all over again.
Lenny: I love that. So what are some of the steps? So step one is, do you have a website? Step two is make sure the website performs and people can actually have a good time when they’re experiencing it. I imagine part of it is also, do people understand what you do, like tweaking maybe the pitch and the [inaudible 00:28:07]
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes, exactly. And speaking of the pitch, our copy team does an amazing job at this. In the B2B world, it’s very easy to come up with statements that could so easily be applied to another business and it would work just as well on their website. And it sounds good and you and your team feel really good about it. But then if your one-liner can also work for another business, please don’t let that be your one-liner. Make it so that people actually understand what you do. Because right now there’s a lot of statements out there like, ‘we do the complex things so you can focus on what you do best’, what does that mean? And you can give that to 90% of the B2B businesses out there and it would apply to them, which means it’s not good enough.
Lenny: Is there anything that you remember you changed in those early days in terms of the website or the positioning or anything along those lines that was a big improvement?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Our website was hard coded, so the first thing we did with the help of the dev team was to move it to a platform that it was easy for me to access and edit, so that we could continuously A/B test things. And outside of that, we worked really hard on testing a lot of value propositions to explain to people exactly what we do, explain problem first, solution first, and time savings, cost savings, putting a lot of those against each other and rapidly A/B testing.
Lenny: Once you got past that phase, where maybe you started doing some paid ads and other things, where did you find you could invest more resources?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Once we covered the basics of your big four or five ad platforms, we started looking into the long tail places. So those are the platforms that individually never contribute a significant enough chunk for you to individually care about it. But if you add them up, it diversifies your lead flow such that it ends up being about 30% of your overall lead flow that’s coming in. Those could be things like review sites or much smaller outlets that could also run ads, newsletter ads, podcast ads, all of those things.
When you run an individual podcast ad, yeah, you’re probably not going to get 2000 customers from one podcast. But you run 10 of those and then it starts adding up. So really long tail is where we focused on. And we started going very niche with websites that have maybe 50,000, a hundred thousand visitors a month, which isn’t all that much when you’re thinking about your paid ad strategy. But all of those places add up and they’re oftentimes overlooked because they’re not as easy, you have to take the time to set up from scratch to run it on everything. Our paid ads team, they spent just as much time running Facebook and Google ads as they do running those third party, much smaller platform ads. It takes the same effort, but you need to have a diversified source of your leads.
Lenny: Huge fan of podcast ads over here, and maybe this would be a good time to cue the mid-roll ad, maybe, I don’t know, it happens.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Sounds perfect.
Lenny:
All of AssemblyAI’s models, which are accessed through their API, are production ready. So many PMs I know are considering or already building with AI and AssemblyAI is the fastest way to build with AI for audio use cases. Now is the time to check out AssemblyAI, which makes it easy to bring the highest accuracy transcription plus valuable insights to your customers, just like Spotify, CallRail and Writer do for theirs. Visit assemblyai.com/lenny to try their API for free and start testing their models with their no-code playground. That’s assemblyai.com/lenny.
And welcome back. Speaking of podcast ads, something that I find is with that sort of advertising, there’s a direct response component of like, we will drive leads as running an ad like this, and there’s also a awareness, brand building component. I know you’re not a big fan of awareness campaigns and marketing campaigns, especially early on, and so I’d love to get your perspective on why that is and how you think about that sort of investment?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I’m not a huge fan of early awareness campaigns for B2B businesses specifically. So if you are a consumer goods founder, you can skip this part. But the reason I don’t like awareness early on is because to do a proper awareness campaign, it takes time. You need to have teams that are doing the strategy, doing the creative work, and they don’t always hit. You don’t know if they’re always going to resonate or not. And then you look back, and you’ve worked on this thing for a whole month and it hasn’t resonated and you’ve wasted a full month.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Because B2B businesses uniquely are started because there’s a very real need and there’s a lot of people that are ready to convert, first tap into the bottom of the funnel, and then go out and start speaking to the masses. But I promise you it’ll probably take you six to eight months minimum to tap into that bottom of the funnel of people that are ready to convert today before you have to start doing awareness ads out there. That’s not to say never do awareness ads, but it’s oftentimes the shiny, cool thing that you want to do and it just ends up being a waste of time early on. Because people don’t really even understand what you’re doing, you haven’t really even figured out what’s the messaging that resonates, but you’ve done this creative campaign and people are like, “This looks cool, but I’m just going to go ahead and continue looking for a solution for my problem.”
Lenny: Is there an example of a marketing campaign or an awareness campaign that comes to mind that you thought was like, “Okay, this is … if you do it this way, maybe it’s worth doing”?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I’ve seen Notion do a great job with their out-of-home ads. They didn’t do it early on, they started doing it much later in their journey by the time when everybody that was working in tech knew what it was, and it was really to drive home the message continuously rather than to introduce themselves to the world. So by then when you saw that layout on a billboard, it made sense, you’re like, “Oh, I know what they’re talking about.”
Lenny: So what is it about Notion that you think was great, it was timing and then also the actual ad itself you thought was great?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah, the ads that I’m recalling right now were showcasing their product interface. So they needed enough time, and this is my obviously hypothesis, if someone from Notion wants to jump in and say that wasn’t the reason why we did this, go ahead, but I think they needed enough time for people to get familiar with the interface. Because Notion has a very specific interface that when you see it, you recognize it, it’s not like any other product. So unless people built that awareness and recognition, doing an out-of-home ad with that layout wouldn’t have made much sense because just with that layout they were able to communicate what product they’re talking about. If they did that day one, people would be like, “What is this thing that I’m looking at?”
Lenny: So we’ve been working through all the ways that Deel has grown, we’ve talked about SEO, community, you mentioned partnerships. Is there anything interesting there to mention around just what partnerships have done?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah, I would say it is very important to know who you should partner with. So there’s two groups of partners. People oftentimes end up partnering with any company that has a shared audience. Decent place to start. But just because you share an audience doesn’t mean your audience goes to your partner for guidance when they have this problem.
So in our case, venture capital partners was a huge one because when you get money from a new VC, they ask, they’re like, “Okay, thank you for giving us this money, now we want to expand our team with the money you gave us. What are your other portfolio companies using? What is a platform that you trust that you would recommend?” So people go to their VCs for that kind of question. But there might be another tech company out there that is tapping into the exact audience that we are, but people never go to them to ask that question. So our partnership with them will likely not work just as well. So it’s important to not only recognize the importance of an audience overlap as well as whether or not those people are seen as a trusted resource for the solution you are putting out there.
Lenny: I really love this idea you keep coming back to, which is where are people asking this question that you can help them answer. And to make that even more concrete for people, what are some other examples maybe of questions people ask that Deel can help them with? So that it could help people think about, okay, maybe our product can help them answer these other sorts of questions
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Since the early days, and it continues to happen, compliance is a huge question that gets asked. So when you are an HR leader or a finance leader or a legal leader in a company that works let’s say in America, but you want to hire someone in another country, you don’t know what you don’t know. So it’s very important to have people that know what they’re talking about in context of your country of origin as well as the country that you’re trying to hire from. So compliance has always been a huge part of what we did and what we’ve always answered for people. That’s why we have in-house experts that answer those questions, that constantly provide updates if the answer to that question has changed over time, which regulations constantly change. An answer we provided a week ago may change, and you need to be very proactive in communicating that.
Taxes is another one, especially in the space that we’re in, payroll, hiring. Taxes change from country to country. You need to know when you need to pay what taxes, when you need to not pay them, and what types of work people do. So those are some of the types of questions that get asked.
So for us, they’re very nitty-gritty and use case specific. The taxes you need to pay for someone who is an engineer that’s a full-time employee might be very different than who is a designer who is a contractor. So those are the kinds of specifics that we get into with people.
Lenny: Got it. So it’s like, how do I pay taxes for an engineer I’m hiring in Turkey? And then you give them, “Here’s the answer,” and then it’s like, “If you just want us to take care of it for you, then go check out Deel.”
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Exactly. Rarely the question is what’s the best payroll solution? It’s like, okay, that’s good to make sure what you’re leaning towards isn’t shit and that other people agree with you. But ultimately it was like you need the best payroll solution because you need to make sure that things aren’t going to go wrong.
Lenny: Speaking of answering questions in content, something that you told me is that you wrote a blog post that the IRS ended up linking to as the definitive answer to a question. And I don’t think this was at Deel, but can you share that story?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes, actually it was at my previous role. And the person who wrote that article is today at Deel. So he came over to join us there too. But yes, it was right around when Covid happened and the US government rolled out the PPP program. And there was a lot of questions about, do I qualify? If I qualify, how do I apply for this?
And at the time the company that I was working for had a lot of customers that were like, “What do I do? I need to gain access to this, but I don’t know what to do.” So the team there took the time to truly understand how the system works, whether you qualify, what to do. And created this resource for our own customers because we just wanted to help them. And then it ended up being such a good resource that it was linked from the IRS’s website being like, “If you have questions, check out this article,” which was a great moment of pride. And it just went to show that when you do your best to answer questions and other people don’t have the time to do it, no matter who it is, they’re going to send people back your way. And it was at the time, it happened to be a big moment of growth.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: It was a very unfortunate instance, we wish we never had to write that, that it never happened. But yeah, that was the story around IRS linking to the company’s resource.
Lenny: That’s the ultimate sign of the question is answered and you’re done with it, the IRS decides to link to it. So you’re saying that was actually a big driver of growth, IRS traffic. I’m curious how many people actually go read that?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: So that was huge for that short duration of a few week time when people were trying to apply for PPP. And then it died out, as did PPP.
Lenny: Makes sense. One last question around paid, and then I want to move on to a different topic. Is there anything you’ve learned about what it takes to be successful at paid growth from your experience at Deel?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah, so a few things. Our paid team spends a lot of time on both the messaging aspect of things as well as the optimization. So optimization is the technical way in which you set your bids, make sure that you don’t go over budget, whether or not you can afford that.
And then messaging is making sure that if someone sees your ad, whether it’s on Instagram, Twitter, Google, that it makes sense for them. So creative fatigue is a real thing. When you put an ad out there that works for three weeks, people get tired of seeing that, you need to constantly update that. So our paid team is actually updating the ads we put out there on a monthly basis with the exception of a few Google ads, which need to be straight to the point. So staying ahead of creative fatigue. Making sure that your messaging also keeps up with your product, even if the ad is working really well, you need to make sure that as your product has evolved, so has the messaging alongside that.
And also recognizing, not just looking at the amount of leads that you generated from a campaign, but how many of them actually became a client, and how much money did you actually make from those clients to understand things around payback. Because oftentimes marketers just tend to think about, “Oh, this is a great lead channel and I get so many leads from it.” But then you ask that question to sales teams and they’re like, “Yeah, I’m busy, but none of these are converting.” So it’s really important to look at not just the volume that you bring in, but what is the journey of that volume with your business one year out. How much money do you actually make from them to be able to properly decide how much can I spend to win this customer?
And the way that we’ve done it is we’ve worked with our data team to set up a dashboard that tracks that in real time. We know an average customer that comes from a Facebook ad, at what rate do they converge from a lead to a qualified opportunity to a closed on.? And then on average, how much money do we make from that customer one year out. So that we can decide, is this a worthy channel for us, do we not want to invest there or are we reaching that peak and we can’t continue to invest there.
Lenny: Something that I should mention as we talk through this is we’re talking about all these ways to grow the product, but at the core is a great product that people actually find valuable and want to keep using. And maybe a question there is just how that plays into this whole growth strategy, actually making the product something people want versus all these acquisition channels?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Acquisition channels just straight up don’t work if you have a product that doesn’t live up to the expectation. I think I personally have been very spoiled and lucky because from the day I joined Deel, the product was top-notch. As I was joining an early stage company, I joined right after series A, I was expecting certain things to be duct taped in the back, it happens. And I was like, “Oh no, the engineers and the product team are, if they say a product can do something, it can do that and more.”
So early days of my team pitching Deel was people were like, “I don’t think you guys can do all of that. I don’t believe you.” And it was almost like we had to tamper down our messaging so that people would believe us. But you can be the best marketer in the world, if when people come to your product, even if your sales team does a good job at convincing them to become a customer, because you can do that, if the product doesn’t live up to the expectations, especially in the B2B world where people aren’t going to put up with crappy products, they’re going to leave. That’s going to get out and people are going to know it’s not a worthy product. So that really sits at the core of everything that we do.
I think it’s very easy to take it for granted when you’re at a company that has an awesome product, you’re like, “It is like this all the time.” But one of the things I would encourage anybody looking to join a young company is, ask them what their team breakdown looks like. When I joined Deel, most of the team was product and engineers. So that told me that the core of this business was going to be solid. And then we built out those supporting things like marketing, like sales, like data to surround the product. But if you are talking to an early stage company that’s a B2B product and they have six salespeople and two engineers, their product probably isn’t going to be great for that much longer.
Lenny: Especially if it’s an outsourced dev shop doing the product, they’re like, “Oh, they’ll take care of the product, we’ll just sell it.” Something else that I think is important to talk about is Covid was an important element of your growth. And so I guess, one, is that true? And then two, just what did you lean into and lean out of in terms of growth during Covid to help people discover Deel when they needed it most, which is basically people going remote in a lot of ways in a lot of companies?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: So Covid, actually a lot of people think Deel was started as a response to the pandemic, we actually got started before the pandemic and then the pandemic happened. So as sad as it was, it did force people into a pilot program of the vision that we had for the world. It forced people to work remotely, whether that means you’re working remotely from someone who lives a block away from you or you are working remotely from someone in Germany. So we did benefit from the fact that everybody was at least forced to test out this hypothesis of, does it work to not be in the same room as the people that you’re working with?
And one of the questions that we were getting early on as the Covid was coming to an end was, “Are you worried, Covid is coming to an end, that people aren’t going to use Deel anymore?” And our response to that has always been, we are not a remote work platform, we’re a global work platform. So a lot of these businesses have gone back into offices. We have a lot of customers that asked people to go back to their offices, but now they have offices in Germany and in Canada and in the US and in France. So we were never a remote work company, we were just a global work company.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: And remote work, because there was a lot of news coverage happening around it, we just became synonymous with that. So I do think early on we did benefit from being able to provide that solution. And a lot of people saw the reality of like, “Hey, I work just as well with this person as I did when I was in an office with them. Well, the best person that I’m looking for, the job may not be within my region, so let me go ahead and hire them regardless of where they are.” People got comfortable with that and more and more companies started moving in that direction.
Lenny: And is there anything that ended up being really important in terms of helping Deel grow through that? Like a channel that’s just like, “Let’s go big on this channel because it seems to be working really well”? Or is it just word of mouth basically and people are just like, “Oh shit, I really need to solve this problem, my hair’s on fire, what’s out there? Let me go find an answer”?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I wouldn’t say it was word of mouth, maybe very, very early on it was word of mouth, but within the first few months of our operation that stopped being true. Or at least the word of mouth stopped being a smaller percentage of the way in which people discover us. But it’s always that people needed a payroll solution, they needed a way to hire independent contractors overseas, and we just were the answer to that. So we consistently put ourselves in front of them and said, “Hey, if you’re trying to do this, or if you’re already doing it and you’re not doing it legally, we can help you do that legally.”
Lenny: I want to chat about team building, something that I’ve heard you’re exceptional at. And my first question is, early on when you were building the team, the growth team specifically, at Deel, what skills did you find were most important to look for? And what skills and experiences did you find wasn’t as important early on that you could sacrifice and wait until later to get?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Early on one of the first questions I would ask people is, what are the KPIs that you’re willing to commit to? So if someone’s only willing to commit to lead numbers, that’s not good enough. They need to be able to commit to closed one revenue KPRs to really show that they care about the business’s bottom line. So it was those people that were willing to commit to the full funnel.
And also oftentimes people tend to hire from the big companies that they want to become like because the brand name is appealing. But if you’re a team of 35 people, and you’re trying to hire the director of whatever from a huge company, you need to ask the question of, when did this person join that huge company? Did they join when the company was already 5,000 people and from day one they had all the resources at their disposal? Or were they actually one of the earlier employees who helped that growth? Because oftentimes the mistake I see people make is they’ll hire someone from an amazing company that have accomplished amazing things, but they’re not used to operating with 10% of the resources that they had. So they’re not willing to get down and do the dirty work.
And at Deel we have this concept called ‘little hands’. I think it’s loosely translated from French, someone can correct me on that. But it basically means that no matter who you are, where you sit within the organization, you need to be willing to get into the little things and do the nitty-gritty work and not shy away from it. And it’s very important too, whoever we hire at any level, it’s like, “Are you willing to do the tiniest of jobs?” And if the answer is yes, that’s great. And some people are like, “I would build a team for that.” And of course in the future, maybe you should, but that shouldn’t be your first answer. Your first answer should be, “Yes, of course I’ll do that.” And if someone’s not excited about that, then they’re not a good fit for at least a company at our stage right now.
Lenny: That is an amazing expression, little hands. You talked about how you check that people are willing to commit to revenue goals. Is that in the interview or is that … how do you … because won’t everyone just say, “Yeah, yeah, I can commit to anything you need me to commit to, I’m going to go make this work”? How do you get a sense if they’re the kind of person that would do that?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: It happens within the interview process. So one ways to find out is what are the KPIs that they have committed to in the past in their roles. So if they’ve never committed to a revenue goal or a bottom funnel goal and they’re saying they’re willing to commit to it, that’s probably not correct. And I always say, if they haven’t, I say, “What are the KPIs that you have today and what are the KPIs that you think you should have?” Because sometimes they’re just not given those, but they still think they should have been given the more bottom funnel. So that’s something that I would look for in the interview process.
And a really good way to also test for that is, this is more on the case study process, but asking someone to come up with a strategy with 10,000 and maybe a hundred thousand dollars to see if they’re going to be able to scale with you. And to see how are they thinking about with different levels of spend and what are they willing to commit to at different levels of spend. Because if someone’s throwing up their hands and saying, “At $0, I can only do social media monitoring, we’re not going to get much because that’s what makes sense.” Well, you probably know that they’re not going to be comfortable committing to those bottom of funnel metrics until you give them all the resources that they need.
Lenny: And it sounds like the way you goal teams within Deel also is revenue, growth teams basically have revenue goals. It’s not, like you said, leads or traffic or anything like that.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes. That’s why we’re called growth instead of marketing, we care about the revenue growth. And of course we track leads and SQLs. Those are leading indicators to know whether or not we’re going to hit the ultimate number that we all care about. But at the end of the day, that’s not what we consider success.
Lenny: In terms of team structure, how you thought about structuring the early growth team, what did that look like and what was the reporting lines and buckets of investment?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah, so very early on, we always seek to bring in one leader to manage a part of the organization and then let them grow their teams. We don’t love the idea of hiring people based off of a hypothesis that something is going to work. That’s a really good way to have to do layoffs because the plans you thought were going to work didn’t work. So we always hired one person, prove out a theory, and then let them grow their team.
So the first hire we made to the team was actually a product marketing person. To this day they lead our product marketing team, and they were the ones who sit between the product team and the go-to-market teams and really set the messaging. And quickly we realized this person needs more help in setting the messaging, the tone. So then the second person we hired was a very talented copywriter. And that person today leads our creative teams.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: And then the third person we actually hired onto the growth team was a data analyst because the sentiment was we’re not willing to spend a dollar if we don’t know where that money’s going and what it’s doing for us. Which a lot of people would assume that’s a very early hire for … data is too early to hire as number three. But I still think that we did the right thing there. Now we have a whole data team, but back then we didn’t.
So those were the three teams that we started with on top. And then the content person was already at Deel by the time that I joined, so that was the person I mentioned that was early employee. So that’s how we originally set it.
Now the teams have changed. So now we have a different structure, slightly different structure, which is we have regional teams and functional teams. The functional teams are basically subject matter experts. They’re good at what they do and we don’t care where they are based in the world. So those are teams like product marketing, content, community, events, paid advertisements, brand. If we are looking for the best graphic designer in the world, I don’t care where they are, they can sit wherever in the world. They are basically functional teams.
And then we have regional teams. Because we are selling into a lot of different regions, we need to make sure that we have local expertise as well. So we have marketing managers for different key regions for us that then work with our functional teams to bring the strategy to life. So that’s how we’ve set it.
I’ve seen businesses who build out a regional team that has their own paid ads team and their own content team. But what we have found is when you take people away from their group of expertise, so if you take a paid ads person, and if you have a team of paid ads people and you separate those five people and give them to different regions, instead of letting them sit together and be a tight team, the best practice is learning and the leveling up of the skills doesn’t happen as fast as they would if all of the technical roles are sitting together. So we are continuing down the road of functional and regional setup.
Lenny: So say someone in Turkey wants to run paid ads, they convince the paid growth team to invest in resources in growing Turkey?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Exactly. So they would work with our central paid ads team to say I would like to run paid ads in Turkey, this is the audience I want to go after. And then they work together to execute on that strategy.
Lenny: How does that team decide who’s going to get their time, is there a rough approach to that?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: So it depends on the total addressable market in a region, what are the opportunities we’re seeing, what’s the competitive landscape like. So chances are if a market is what we consider to be tier one, and it’s a place that we have seen good growth, we will invest our resources into it. And then along the way we learn and we decide if we’re going to double down or pull back a little bit.
Lenny: Awesome. I want to chat a bit about culture, culture at Deel. We had Jeff from Ramp on, and their culture is described by one word, velocity. Also one of you being the fastest growing business of all time, I’m curious how you’d contrast your culture and broadly how you think about culture at a startup and how you help create the culture at Deel?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah, so I would say culture is made up of two components. One is, what do you bring to the company as a team member, and what does the company give back to you? So what we expect the team members to bring to us is, our version of velocity is something that we call ‘Deel speed’, is that we want to make sure that we act with urgency. It doesn’t matter how big the team has grown, we want to act with urgency on behalf of our customers. If a customer has a problem, they’re not going to wait two weeks to get an answer for that. They’re going to get that answer within 24 hours. If we need to build out a product because many customers are asking for it, that product is going to get built in one-tenth the time that any of our competitors will likely build it in.
So ‘Deel speed’ is very, very important for us. And that’s something we expect from our team members who are committing to it. To say, what’s the quickest way I can solve this problem properly? And to repeatedly push themselves to act with urgency.
We also care that we remain positive. We have default optimism because we are in a new space, so if someone’s going to come into Deel and they’re going to be pessimistic and they’re like, “I don’t think that’s going to work for X, Y, Z reasons,” they’re going to just slow things down. We need people to ask the question of, “I think it’s going to work for these four reasons, now let’s see what are the risks associated with it and let’s seek to solve those risks.” That’s again something we expect from our team members.
And then the last one, well, not the last one, but one of the third important ones is, fully giving a shit about your customer. At the end of the day, the product that we have, we are dealing with humans, we’re dealing with their livelihood, the way they get paid, we’re dealing with the way companies hire. It’s so incredibly personal if someone doesn’t get their paycheck on time or if someone gets into legal trouble because their contract wasn’t set up the proper way.
So recognizing that it’s not a software and a platform that we’re trying to make it the best, but it’s like, no, it’s a business trying to pay a human so they can live their lives and the business can continue growing. So that care is something that we need people to bring to the table.
Now in return of those things coming, what we give back as a company is, outside of obviously your pay, your benefits package, et cetera, is we offer people the flexibility to choose how and when they do their job, they get to decide on where they work from, what hours they work. So we basically give people all the freedom to set up their life how they want to as long as they come to the table giving us what they need. So I would say we do have an intense culture, and that’s expected, we share that openly with people. But at the end of the day, that’s also what sets us apart.
Lenny: I love this ‘Deel speed’. Are these core values basically within Deel, these are values that you come back to?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes, exactly. And these are values that we publicly share as well.
Lenny: How early in the lifecycle of the company did you all come up with these values? That’s something that a lot of startups think about is, when should we actually crystallize these values?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: So we came up with them, I believe it was about a year in, but we didn’t sit around the table and say, “What should we call our values?” ‘Deel speed’ was something that our CEO would tell people. He’d be like, “Okay, I want you to do this, but I want you to do it at ‘Deel speed’.” And one of the early jokes was, let’s have company swag that’s Deel speedo and things like that. It’s just like, it was already used so frequently with people that we were just like, “Okay, we keep saying this, let’s also define what it actually is for us and set it in stone and share it with people.” So we did go through that exercise probably about a year in into the company existing, but the culture happened well before we established that.
Lenny: Reminds me, at Airbnb, there was a team that came up with the core values, I think it was four years in probably, and there were six of them. And then a few years later they realized two of them aren’t actually true, they were aspirational. And there was this recognition that values should be who you are not who you hope to be because it just doesn’t click. And so they actually cut those values and they ended up having just four values. And maybe one day they’ll bring them back. And so I think that’s a really good lesson is you want to see who you already are and then just represent them in a really interesting, creative way.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yes, exactly.
Lenny: There’s a version of, what did you call it, default optimism. Airbnb’s version of that was ‘embrace the adventure’, which is just like, this is going to be crazy, just go for it, embrace it, this is what it’s going to be like.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Exactly. And try and see how can I solve this, how can this be done instead of why it won’t work.
Lenny: Yeah, I love that. And this urgency piece comes up again and again in these interviews I’m doing. What I think of is Frank Slootman, I think is his name, the founder of Snowflake, has this book called Amp It Up. All about just how they made Snowflake work. And something he comes back to is just you need to constantly have a sense of urgency because when you don’t, people get bored and they actually end up liking their job less because it’s just like, I don’t really know what I’m doing, things are moving along. And there’s actually a lot of value in moving fast. Jeff talked about this as just like, you have less burnout when people feel like things are getting done and out the door.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah, it’s incredibly fulfilling. I look back and sometimes things when, for example, when the SVB was going through the issues they were going through, the entire team had to work on a Sunday to communicate with our customers of like, “No, we’re good, don’t worry about it.” But I remember that Sunday I had to miss out on a theater I was so excited to see, but it just felt like, oh my God, we’re in this, it was like a war room, we’re doing it. And that felt good. I didn’t necessarily show up on Monday feeling already burned out, but it was more like, yes, I felt alive. And I think the right people will feel that way.
Lenny: Yeah, and as long as it’s not constantly for years just endless late nights and weekends.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: It can’t always be war time.
Lenny: I find that those end up being the most memorable, meaningful moments is when you’re working really, really hard on something that you’re excited about. And it has to be something you’re excited about and are proud of.
Last question. I saw on Twitter, you shared this photo of your home office, and it was this incredible view out the window, and then you took a photo facing your desk and it was an ironing board. And two questions there. One is just how did that all happen? And then two, I think you mentioned somewhere that you didn’t even meet a lot of your coworkers for a year and a half after joining Deel, it was very remote forward. So, I’m curious also just how you made remote work work for you in that environment?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Yeah, so I’ll explain the ironing board first. So that was because I was actually visiting my family in Istanbul, and in the setup that we have, there’s one desk. So my husband and I go rock, paper, scissors, and we’ll see who gets the desk and who gets to come up with a secondary solution. And he won the desk, so I had to come up with a creative solution. And because the view behind me was stunning, of the Bosporus, every meeting I joined, people were like, “Wow, I love your view, this is amazing.” And I was like, “Oh, no, no, you guys, I’m sitting on an ironing board right now.” And to me that was both funny, and I wanted to do a reality check with people to be like, “Come on, this is not as glorious as it looks.” But at the same time, it really in that moment I was like, “This is awesome, I work at Deel.”
Previously when I wanted to go visit my family in Istanbul, and I live in Canada, I would have to use my days off to go. And for me it just meant a lot to be able to do my work regardless of where I am. I had a full day of work and meetings and everything. And my work just continued and I was also be able to be with my family. So it was a moment of Deel’s promise coming true in a very real way in my life. And I thought it was hilarious. My dad thought it was so unprofessional that I shared that with the public then. He hasn’t fully wrapped his head around the startup world. So it was just one of those moments of sharing that, yeah, work can be remote and it can be whatever you want it to be. So that’s the the story behind it. In this moment as we’re recording this, I am in a proper home office with a desk and a back supported chair. It changes all the time.
And in terms of, going back to your second question of, early days not meeting the team members. As I said, I joined Deel in July, 2020, pandemic was at its peak, me being based in Canada, Canada had very strict restrictions of, you can’t leave the country, we won’t let you back in. So I had to stay put. And I worked for a year and a half at Deel before for the first time where I met our team members was at a conference in Lisbon. And I showed up and it was this surreal moment because I’ve worked with them for a year and a half, we’d accomplished so much. Our revenue was already way past $50 million and I was seeing these people for the first time. So that was very funny.
But if I look at the early days of Deel, there’s a lot of little stories like that, where we forgot to create swag until we reached a billion dollars. And it was actually when our photo was going to be on the NASDAQ and we wanted to take a team picture that we were like, “Guys, we need to have t-shirts. Can someone please run to a store in New York and print our logo on something?” So a lot of those things just by the nature of being a pandemic business came a little bit later.
But the thing that allowed I think for me in Deel to build the culture early on was, because we all work from home, we’ve been like that from day one. We have the option to go into WeWorks and co-working spaces if that’s something that you choose. But we all get to show up as our very authentic selves. So people have met my pets and my partner well before they would have if I was showing up to an office. So there’s that sincerity that comes with being in someone’s home that we really relied on early on.
And as a company, I never felt the pressure to show up in a certain way or dress up for meetings or anything. So just being able to show up as yourself, and whether you’re an introverted person who never likes to turn on their camera or you’re someone who’s going to be like, “Here, meet my dog.” That just naturally built a team culture and comradery well before we could be together in person.
Lenny: Clearly it has worked out. Meltem, is there anything else that you want to share before we get to our very exciting lightning round?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: We had a really good conversation. The one thing I would tell people is, most of growth, people assume is very difficult. I’m not necessarily saying it’s easy, but it’s relatively straightforward when you go back to the first principles of just figuring out where are the people at? How can I add value? As long as your product is there to actually bring them value. So I would say people should just recognize that it’s much simpler than they think it is, it just takes a lot of discipline to execute on it, it’s not rocket science.
Lenny: Quite an empowering statement, I love it. With that, we’ve reached our very exciting lightning round. Are you ready?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I am ready, let’s do this.
Lenny: What are two or three books that you’ve recommended most to other people?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: From the nonfiction world, How Will You Measure Your Life by Clay Christensen, that’s one I recommend. He takes the business learnings that he’s had and applies it to your life. It’s a very short and easy to get through book. Outside of that, I constantly recommend fiction. I think at one point it became uncool to read fiction that every moment you have needs to be productive and you need to learn something. I don’t care what fiction it is you read, you can read Judy Blume for all I care, but just read fiction, be creative, do something with your brain other than reading nonfiction and learning things all the time.
Lenny: I’ve had to make that shift myself, and it’s been great, but I still get drawn to nonfiction. But good reminder. What are some favorite recent movie or TV shows you’ve loved?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Favorite recent movie, I think along with everybody else, was Oppenheimer. I thought it was great. I do wish they explored a little bit more of why he was the person that drove everybody to excellence. But overall loved the movie. Did not think I could sit through three hours without peeing, but I did. And favorite recent TV show was The Summer I Turned Pretty. I absolutely love it. I don’t care that it’s actually designed for teenagers, I enjoyed every second of it.
Lenny: What is a favorite interview question that you like to ask candidates when you’re interviewing them?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: What would your siblings say about you? It’s very telling. If they have siblings, if they don’t, I will say, what will your parents say about you? But it’s very telling what you think other people think of you.
Lenny: What do you look for in their answer that gives you a sign that they’re a good candidate or not?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: I look for sincerity and self-awareness. Your siblings are never … I mean, I love my sister, but she’ll probably shit talk me a lot. And being aware of that is very important. If someone was like, “My siblings will say I’m very organized and that I’m the one that brings our family together.” That’s probably a bullshit answer. But if they’re like, “Oh yeah, they’ll say these weird things about me,” that shows a little bit of self-awareness and humbleness that I want to see in a person.
Lenny: What is a favorite product you’ve recently discovered that you really like?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Oh, this is a dangerous one. So two, one was NuStrips, they’re caffeine strips. I find caffeine pills and everything or when I drink coffee is like, accidentally I’ll have 300 milligrams and then I’m buzzing. But these are 50 milligrams each, so it’s very easy to stop yourself. And they don’t taste bad. So those I like for when I just need a little boost.
Lenny: So they’re just strips that you put in your mouth and they give you caffeine?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Like LISTERINE strips.
Lenny: What?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: And you put it on your tongue and then it also doesn’t give you the jitters and it’s just 50 milligrams, which is a very mild cup of coffee.
Lenny: Microdosing caffeine.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Exactly.
Lenny: Beautiful.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: And the second one is, I recently was gifted a personalized library stamp, which I love. Because I love to give books away, so I stamp them with my library stamp. And I like to think that one day in a secondhand bookshop I’m going to run into it.
Lenny: That’s amazing. There’s a camp at Burning Man that’s a library, and you can borrow books and you have to return it in a year, the next year when you come back to Burning Man. Which is amazing. And then there’s a guy that has a megaphone, he is just like, “A book has been returned.” Makes a whole scene about it. What is a favorite life motto that you often come back to or share with other people, either at work or in life?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: The world is run by insecure overachievers. I used to think my insecurity was a downfall and I would just hide it and try to pretend it’s not there. And then someone that I really look up to told that to. I’m like, “Okay, so I’m not the only one.” And it’s just, I do think world is run by a bunch of people that have something to prove for a good reason or not, but it’s better to embrace it than to pretend you’re all confident and you’re just doing this because you’re brilliant.
Lenny: Oh my God, so good. Final question, what is your favorite Canadian food? You live in Canada and thus the question.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Okay, it’s not particularly food, but Caesars, they’re basically Bloody Mary’s with clam juice.
Lenny: Oh, Bloody Caesar, is that what they’re called? Or just Caesar?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: They’re called Caesars.
Lenny: Just Caesar.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: But the American equivalent would be a Bloody Mary. It’s so much better than a Bloody Mary. It’s not vegan. And then the reason I qualify it as food is when you order it in Canada, it comes with pepperoni strips and pickled asparagus, and they’ll shove a whole meal in there. And it’s just amazing and something that America should definitely adapt too.
Lenny: I think I’ve had one, I think I prefer Bloody Marys, but a good pitch for the Caesars. Meltem, thank you so much for being here. We talked about growth strategy, team building, ‘Deel speed’, default optimism, so many things. Really appreciate you making the time. Two final questions, where can folks find you online if they want to reach out? And how can listeners be useful to you?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: So they can reach out to me on Twitter at MeltemK, I’m the fastest to respond there. Please don’t reach out to me on LinkedIn, I never respond there. And the way readers can be useful to me is if they, one, we’re always looking for feedback on Deel. If you see something out there that you think could be better, let me know, and I’ll make sure to communicate it to the team, whatever that may be. And also, if anybody has tips that they think I would benefit from or any good fiction book recommendations, I’m always open to them.
Lenny: Amazing. Meltem, thank you again so much for being here.
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz: Thank you so much for having me.
Lenny: Bye everyone. Thank you so much for listening. If you found this valuable, you can subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast app. Also please consider giving us a rating or leaving a review as that really helps other listeners find the podcast. You can find all past episodes or learn more about the show at lennyspodcast.com. See you in the next episode.
Glossary
| English | 中文 |
|---|---|
| A/B test | A/B 测试 |
| ARR | ARR(年度经常性收入,Annual Recurring Revenue) |
| awareness campaign | 品牌认知活动 |
| Bench Accounting | Bench Accounting(在线记账服务平台) |
| bottom of the funnel | 漏斗底部 |
| brief | 需求简报 |
| Burning Man | Burning Man(内华达州年度艺术节) |
| Clearscope | Clearscope(SEO 内容优化工具) |
| closed won | 成交 |
| comradery | 同袍情谊(comradery) |
| contractor | 独立承包商 |
| copywriter | 文案 |
| creative | 创意 |
| Deel | Deel(跨境用工与薪酬平台) |
| Deel speed | Deel speed(Deel 公司文化中的核心概念,指以紧迫感行事的工作节奏) |
| default optimism | 默认乐观(default optimism) |
| direct response | 直接转化 |
| duct taped | 用胶带粘起来的(指临时拼凑的解决方案) |
| EBITDA | EBITDA(息税折旧摊销前利润) |
| Employer of Record | 名义雇主(Employer of Record) |
| enhanced oil recovery | 强化采油(enhanced oil recovery) |
| fact checking | 事实核查 |
| first principles | 第一性原理 |
| freelancer | 自由撰稿人 |
| go-to-market | 上市 |
| Head of Growth | 增长负责人 |
| influencer | influencer(意见领袖/网红) |
| KPI | KPI(关键绩效指标,Key Performance Indicator) |
| lead flow | 线索来源 |
| Lenny’s Podcast | Lenny’s Podcast(播客名称) |
| lightning round | 闪电问答(lightning round) |
| little hands | 小手(little hands,源自法语,指不拒细务的工作态度) |
| LMNT | LMNT(电解质冲饮品牌) |
| long tail | 长尾(渠道) |
| meritocracy | meritocracy(优胜劣汰/以能力为衡量标准) |
| Miro | Miro(在线协作白板工具) |
| Miro-verse | Miro-verse(Miro 模板社区) |
| Navy SEAL | 海豹突击队(Navy SEAL) |
| net new | 净新增 |
| newsletter | newsletter(电子邮件通讯) |
| one-liner | 一句话介绍(one-liner) |
| out-of-home ads | 户外广告 |
| payback | 回本周期 |
| portfolio companies | 被投企业 |
| PPP program | PPP 项目(Paycheck Protection Program,薪资保护计划) |
| product marketing | 产品营销 |
| qualified opportunity | 合格商机 |
| Ramp | Ramp(企业支出管理平台) |
| rocket science | 火箭科学(比喻极其复杂的事物) |
| SaaS | SaaS(软件即服务) |
| SEO | SEO(搜索引擎优化) |
| SQL | SQL(销售合格线索,Sales Qualified Lead) |
| swag | 公司周边(swag) |
| Team USA Weightlifting | Team USA Weightlifting(美国举重队) |
| tier one | 一级行场(tier one) |
| total addressable market | 总可触达市场规模(total addressable market) |
| value proposition | 价值主张 |
| war room | 作战室(war room) |
| Watermelon Salt | Watermelon Salt(西瓜盐味) |
Reformatted by reformat_english.py
深入揭秘 Deel 前所未有的增长 | Meltem Kuran Berkowitz(增长负责人)
文字记录
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:00:00): ……早期阶段,回归基础非常重要——先搭好骨架,再上妆。所以我会问的第一个问题是:你有网站吗?加载快吗?搜索引擎知道它的存在吗?好,下一步是——人们能找到它吗?如果找不到,你是不是需要写些内容来确保人们能找到你?只有在这些问题都解决之后,你才应该考虑:我有预算吗?能不能投一些付费广告,确保人们来到我的网站?如果你的网站加载时间超过四秒,你不可能跑好一个付费广告项目。所以一定要回归基础,从核心的良好体验出发,然后一步步向外扩展。
Lenny (00:00:47): 欢迎收听 Lenny’s Podcast,我在这里采访世界级的产品负责人和增长专家,从他们打造和增长当今最成功产品的宝贵实战经验中学习。今天的嘉宾是 Meltem Kuran Berkowitz。Meltem 是 Deel 的增长负责人,Deel 可以说是有史以来增长最快的 SaaS 企业,甚至可能比 Ramp 还快——我们在之前一期节目中深入探讨过 Ramp。他们在三年内从零收入增长到了令人难以置信的三亿美元收入,同时还保持了 EBITDA 为正。
Lenny (00:01:15): Meltem 从早期就开始领导 Deel 的增长团队,如今负责所有增长工作,包括付费广告、产品营销、内容、社区、品牌等。在加入 Deel 之前,她在 Bench Accounting 负责营销工作。在这次对话中,Meltem 分享了 Deel 如何通过低成本增长渠道来启动增长——比如深入 Reddit 等社区,以及内容和 SEO。她还谈到了随着公司发展,自己对增长投资思路的演变。她分享了大量关于如何做好 SEO、如何做好付费广告、如何搭建早期增长团队以及如何优先安排早期投资的实操建议。她还分享了自己打造速度与乐观文化的经历,以及更多精彩内容。在短暂的赞助商广告之后,请欣赏本期与 Meltem Kuran Berkowitz 的对话。
赞助商:Miro
Lenny (00:02:01): 本期节目由 Miro 带来。Miro 是一款在线协作白板,专为像你这样的团队设计。了解 Miro 是什么以及它如何帮助你的团队更好地协作的最好方式,不是听我介绍,而是自己去体验一下,请访问 miro.com/lenny。在 Miro 团队的帮助下,我创建了一个超酷的 Miro 看板,里面有我自己最喜欢的两个模板——我的「一页纸模板」和「向上管理模板」,你可以即插即用,立即和团队一起使用。我还嵌入了其他人在 Miro-verse 中发布的几个我喜欢的模板。当你打开这个看板时,你还可以为播客留言建议,回答我提出的问题,总体上随意玩一玩,感受一下它是如何运作的。
Lenny (00:02:44): Miro 是一款非常棒的团队头脑风暴、策略规划、分享用户调研成果、收集创意、对线框图提供反馈,以及与同事协作的工具。实际上我就是用 Miro 与 Miro 团队协作创建了我自己的看板,过程超级有趣,也非常简单。请访问 miro.com/lenny 一探究竟。那就是 M-I-R-O.com/lenny。
赞助商:LMNT
Lenny (00:03:10): 本期节目由 LMNT 带来。我其实是不久前从另一个播客发现了这个产品,它真是甜咸兼备的美味。LMNT 是一款美味的电解质冲饮,拥有科学配比的电解质配方。与大多数电解质饮料不同,它不含糖、色素、人工成分、面筋或任何乱七八糟的东西。摄入充足的电解质有助于预防和缓解头痛、肌肉抽筋、疲劳、失眠等电解质缺乏的常见症状。LMNT 是 Team USA Weightlifting(美国举重队)以及许多其他奥运选手的独家水合合作伙伴。此外,数十支 NBA 和 NFL 球队和球员、海豹突击队、FBI 狙击手团队和海军陆战队都依靠 LMNT 来保持水分补充。
Lenny (00:03:52): 你可以完全无风险地尝试 LMNT。如果你不喜欢,可以分享给你身边喜欢咸味的朋友,他们会把钱退给你,绝不追问。想要试试,请访问 drinklmnt.com/lenny,你将在任意购买中获得免费试吃装,包含每种口味各一包。我最喜欢的是 Watermelon Salt(西瓜盐味)。这个优惠不会公开提供,所以你必须前往 drinklmnt.com/lenny 才能享受。保持咸味。
正式对话开始
Lenny (00:04:22): Meltem,非常感谢你能来,欢迎做客播客。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:04:26): 谢谢你的邀请,我非常激动能来这里。
Lenny (00:04:28): 你来了我更激动。你是 Deel 的增长负责人。对于不太了解 Deel 的人,能不能简单说一下 Deel 是做什么的?另外,能不能分享一些关于 Deel 发展轨迹的数据?感觉这是一段非凡的旅程,我很好奇想听听这些数据到底有多非凡。
Deel 的业务与增长轨迹
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:04:46): 好的,Deel 是一个面向全球团队的薪酬、HR 和合规平台。基本上,我们帮助企业通过 Deel HR、移民、名义雇主(Employer of Record)雇佣、独立承包商雇佣、全球及美国薪酬等工具进行全球扩张。所以,无论你是想在日本以全职员工身份雇佣一个人,还是想确保你在德国的承包商在第一天就拥有所需的一切,我们的平台都能让你在一个地方搞定所有事情。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:05:13): 我加入 Deel 的时候,大约是 2020 年 7 月,我们的 ARR 不到一百万美元。之后,在第一年内的 2021 年 1 月,我们的 ARR 达到了四百万。2021 年结束时是五千七百万。2022 年 4 月,我们达到了一亿。然后今年年初我们的 ARR 是两亿九千五百万。我们特别自豪的是,我们一直保持 EBITDA 为正。所以在 ARR 增长之外,这是让我们非常非常自豪的一点。
Lenny (00:05:48): 太厉害了。你说过你在 Deel 特别早期就加入了,能不能说说到底有多早,当时是什么样的?
Meltem 的早期加入
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:05:54): 我是营销团队的第二号员工,在整个 Deel 团队中,我记得是第 19 或第 20 号员工。
与 Ramp 的增长之争
Lenny (00:06:02): 我们之前在这档播客上请过 Ramp 的产品负责人,感觉现在有一点小小的争论——这两家公司谁早期增长更快,不过我们不必深究这个问题。感觉它们可能是有史以来增长最快的两家 SaaS 企业。这样说大致对吗?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:06:16): 没错。Ramp 是第一个被冠以「增长最快」头衔的,然后我们从他们手中夺走了这个头衔。所以我觉得我们都没说错——在某个时间点上,我们都曾是最快增长的。但他们确实很棒。
低成本增长渠道
Lenny (00:06:34): 我想从一个关于你的传闻开始聊起——听说你专攻低成本增长渠道,而这实际上也是 Deel 最终雇用你的原因,他们想找到低成本增长的方法。所以有两个问题:第一,在 Deel 从这个角度来看,哪些方法效果特别好?第二,当今有哪些低成本增长渠道是人们投入不足的?你愿意分享多少都行,不知道你是不是愿意把所有秘诀都抖出来。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:06:56): 我很乐意把所有东西都分享出来。在深入列举低成本渠道之前——我后面会说到——有一点非常重要,尤其是在 B2B 领域,大多数企业的诞生是因为存在一个亟待解决的问题。所以当你走向市场、试图回答人们的问题时,人们不想被推销,他们想要自己的问题被解决。因此,那些低成本渠道往往是人们只是在寻找问题答案的地方。无论你通过自己写的文章做 SEO(搜索引擎优化),还是到 Reddit 上人们正在社区里提问的地方,或者与同样试图回答这些问题的其他团队建立合作关系,抑或是那些已有的、其他企业领导者相互交流、向同行寻求共性问题答案的社区,还有 Quora 之类的平台——当你思考低成本渠道时,这些都是非常好的切入点:就是为人们提供价值,回答他们的问题。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:07:54): 当你回答了他们的问题,同时展示了你的解决方案,如果恰好符合他们的需求,那对你来说就成了一个低成本渠道。你未必需要投放广告——你去 Reddit 设置关键词追踪,等人们提出特定问题时,你不需要为此付任何钱。你只是在看:哦,有人提了这个问题,我有答案,给你。然后跟他们建立联系。这需要时间。但在早期,我们大量投入的就是这类事情。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:08:21): 我觉得很多人跳过了这一步,因为他们觉得,“哦,这里一个人,那里两个人。“但当你开始帮助别人,再加上口碑传播,而且要知道,这些都是数字化的场所——你提供一个回答,你的回答就留存在那里,别人可以反复地加以利用。当然前提是我们讨论的不是封闭的 Slack 社区——那可能只是私信里发生的对话。所以当我思考低成本渠道时,我想的是:人们在哪里提问?可能是 Google,也可能是 Reddit 或其他任何渠道——然后去为他们提供答案,让他们知道你的解决方案的存在。
Lenny (00:08:59): 好的,这太棒了。所以你刚才说的 Reddit 例子——你们确实这么做了对吧,你设置了提醒,当有人提出关于 HR 跨国招聘的问题时,然后派人进去给出建议?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:09:10): 对,我们做的就是这件事。
Lenny (00:09:12): 哇,我很喜欢这个做法。
社区规模的天花板
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:09:12): 有一点很重要需要注意——如果你面对的是一个大约一千人的 subreddit,你要认识到这个受众群体的规模上限。你不可能通过那个 Reddit 社区赢得 5,000 家企业客户,但你可能赢得其中有同样问题的那 10% 的人。所以在投入这些低成本渠道时,聚焦于受众规模的上限是多少,这一点非常重要。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:09:36): 另外我也看到很多人有时候盲目地去做 SEO。他们说,“我们就写内容吧。“我是 SEO 的超级拥趸,很乐意稍后细聊,但如果人们根本没有在向 Google 提这个问题,你可以写再多的内容,也没用——没人会找到它。
借力现有社区
Lenny (00:09:52): 我太喜欢这个观点了,因为它和我反复发现的一个规律相吻合:最有效的早期增长渠道之一就是切入一个已有的社区,借力他们已经建好的东西。Airbnb 有点像是一个例子,他们去 Craigslist 上找人。实际上大多数人都是从 Craigslist 上拉人——Uber 从 Craigslist 上拉人,Lyft 也是——很多公司都是借助 Craigslist 起步,然后建立起自己的公司。
Lenny (00:10:13): 但你说的有一点非常关键:你不能直接冲进一个社区就说,“嘿大家,来看看我这好东西。“你需要为人们提供价值,为社区提供价值,否则没人会理你,他们会把你踢出去。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:10:25): 没错。
Lenny (00:10:25): 所以我认为这是一个非常重要的洞察——如果你想借力一个社区,最重要的事情是你需要为社区提供价值。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:10:34): 对,做一个别人真的愿意跟你交谈的人。
Lenny (00:10:37): 说得太好了。在那个 Reddit 策略上,你有没有找到什么工具,比如怎么能知道有人在讨论比如跨国招聘之类的话题?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:10:45): 我做了一个非常简陋的助手设置,说出来不太好意思,但它能用。是其他人做的工具,我只是把我们想追踪的关键词输进去而已。
Lenny (00:10:57): 我知道不仅仅只有 Reddit,我也很好奇你还发现哪些地方值得投入时间,但你是怎么判断出你的潜在社区和潜在用户在哪些地方活跃的?
Reddit 为何成为首选
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:11:06): 我觉得,Reddit 逐渐成为了人们寻求同行回答的首选之地——不管那个同行就在你身边,还是在地球另一端。所以对我来说,去 Reddit 了解我的受众最关心什么,是一个非常自然而然的选择。而且 Reddit 上有太多的 subreddit 了,无论是创始人还是 HR 经理的社区,人们都在向自己的社区提问。因为他们往往有非常具体的问题。你不能直接去问 Google,因为他们的情况中某个细节可能使他们无法适配市面上最主流的那个解决方案。所以 Reddit 这些年就成了人们半匿名地提出自己具体问题、从社区获得回答的地方,而且能获得多个答案,可以对比判断哪个更好、哪个不行。所以这是我和我的团队最先去的地方之一。
Lenny (00:11:58): 这个策略是非常早期用来启动增长的,还是说在什么阶段开始的?在早期,你们的增长大概有多大比例来自这类策略?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:12:07): 我记得我在 Deel 上任的第一天就设置好了那个小小的关键词追踪。所以非常、非常早期。顺便说一下,我们现在仍然在做这件事。我们仍然在 Reddit、Quora 等各种社区提供回答。我们仍然在外面跟人建立联系。当然,随着时间推移,它从可能占我们渠道的 15% 降到了不到 5%,因为我们其他渠道已经大幅增长。但通过这些渠道接触到的新增人数,其实一直在持续增长。
当前值得关注的低成本渠道
Lenny (00:12:43): 回到我之前问过的一个问题,我想再展开聊聊:在今天的环境下,有没有哪些低成本增长渠道让你感到兴奋?还是说本质上还是同一个思路——去找到你的潜在用户聚集的地方,最好是他们在提问、而你能帮忙回答的地方?你现在大致还是这么想的吗?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:12:58): 我大致还是这么想的。我会把社交渠道也加进去。我觉得 Twitter 是一个很好的地方,人们经常在上面提问,所以上面也有各种社区。当有人回答了某个问题,其他人也会跟着借力。但只要是有人在提问的地方,我就会把它归入低成本渠道这个类别。
Lenny (00:13:17): 能不能举个例子,在你看来,什么样的方式算是以提供价值的方式回答问题,什么样的方式效果不太好?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:13:25): 我觉得最没效果的方式就是:“嘿,我们已经解决了这个问题,去看看我们的网站吧。“好吧,如果你只有五秒钟,可以这么做。但真正有价值的方式是把解决方案解释清楚。因为现实是,市场上有很多公司可能都能解决这个问题——所以你应该先回答他们的问题,然后给出你的方案,让他们自己决定是选择你还是别人。但一个人提问的初衷不是被推销解决方案,而是”我只是需要一个答案”。所以要真心把这些提问者当成朋友来对待,回答他们的问题,比如说:“是的,这可以实现。不,这实现不了。是的,你可以做,但需要考虑 X、Y、Z。如果你想了解更多,可以和我们聊聊。“
是团队亲自回答,而非自动化
Lenny (00:14:04): 这些回答问题的人都是团队成员或者你自己,不是什么自动化系统?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:14:09): 从来都不是自动化的,现在也不是。我们绝对不会把与用户的互动自动化。早期的时候,是我自己、团队里其他同事、以及我们的联合创始人在回答——顺便说一下,他们到现在还在做这件事。所以团队里很多人都在参与。每个团队成员都能看到这些提问,谁先看到就会先标记。有时候你在 Twitter 上会看到有人提了一个问题,Deel 团队有三个人都回答了。我们就说:“好吧,我们提供的信息够多了。“
低成本渠道的其他可能
Lenny (00:14:41): 太棒了。我在这个话题上花了比较多的时间,但这是一个非常有趣且重要的策略,很明显它帮助你们起步了,而且成本很低。大多数——至少是 B2B 公司——应该都能用这个方法。所以当创业者在考虑该去哪里找用户时,也许可以试试这个。你提到了 Twitter,也许还有 Reddit、Quora。除此之外还有别的地方吗?就是说,在创业者可以去探索的范围内,还有没有其他地方,人们在提问、而你可以去回答?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:15:06): 有,还有很多封闭社区。比如 Slack 社区、Discord,以及创业者们选择与其他创业者建立联系的各种地方。或者我们与 Y Combinator 这样的机构有合作——当你完成某个项目或获得了加入某个”俱乐部”的资格后(不管那个俱乐部是什么),你就可以进入这个社区,和其他人交流。这些都属于封闭社区,获取访问权限没那么容易。但如果你能找到办法进入这些社区,它们也是很不错的地方。
Lenny (00:15:37): 所以第一步就是提供价值,对吧?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:15:40): 对。
Lenny (00:15:40): 你不能一进去就说:“嘿,大家都来看看 Deel。”
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:15:42): 否则你只会被踢出去。你可以试试不提供价值,但你在那里待不了多久。
Deel 早期与如今的增长来源
Lenny (00:15:47): 是的。如果要你画一个饼图,描述 Deel 早期和现在的增长分别是怎么来的,大概会是什么样子?早期增长中有多少来自这种社区问答方式,有多少来自 SEO 或其他渠道?现在呢?关于增长来源,你能分享多少就分享多少。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:16:03): 到现在,我们大概有 50% 的增长仍然来自非付费渠道,包括合作伙伴、SEO、社区互动等方式。早期这个比例接近 80% 到 90%。当然,非付费渠道的绝对数字在增长,但在总量中的占比下降了,因为其他渠道也大幅增长了。
SEO 策略:让搜索结束于你的内容
Lenny (00:16:29): 太好了。好,我们来聊聊 SEO。首先,SEO 对 Deel 的成功和增长有多重要?另外,关于做好 SEO 你学到了什么关键的东西?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:16:40): 好。我觉得 SEO 方面人们最大的误区就是堆砌关键词。他们会说:“好,这些是人们在搜的关键词,我得确保提到五次。“当然,这件事要做,确保你写的内容确实回答了问题。但最关键的一点是:这场 Google 搜索结束了吗?如果有人读了你的内容——他们因为在 Google 上搜了点什么而点进了你发布的文章——读完之后,他们是会回到 Google 继续搜索,还是搜索到此为止了?因为归根结底,搜索引擎关心的就是一件事:让用户以最快的方式找到答案。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:17:16): 从这个角度去思考,写人们真正想读的内容就容易多了,你不会在那里漫无目的地啰里啰嗦、堆砌一堆关键词,把读者看得无聊到直接跳走。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:17:30): 所以,先问自己”搜索结束了吗”是一个很好的出发点,而不是一上来就堆关键词。我们的内容团队非常出色。我觉得与其说他们是一个创意团队,不如说更像一个运营团队。他们的工作流程、文章发布节奏,都有一套非常清晰的框架来决定什么内容什么时候发、什么内容不发。这些都很重要,而不是看到”这个关键词每月有一万搜索量”就开始围绕它写一堆东西。
Lenny (00:18:02): 能不能举个具体的例子,某篇你们写的页面,能让用户的搜索到此为止,满足了他们的需求?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:18:07): 很多人想知道 EOR 是什么,因为 EOR 就是 Employer of Record(名义雇主)。大家对它到底是什么经常感到困惑。所以我们在解释 EOR 是什么、不是什么、以及它的局限性方面做得很好。因为当你回答了 EOR 是什么之后,人们紧接着会问的下一个问题就是:好吧,那它的缺点是什么?什么时候我不应该用它?所以对我们来说,这篇内容的表现非常好。
SEO 内容团队的运营框架
Lenny (00:18:32): 我很想再深入聊聊 SEO 团队的这个运营层面。也许可以先问一个问题:你们用什么标准来判断一篇文章已经准备好可以发布了、值得推出去,还是还没准备好?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:18:42): 好。这一点我不能居功,全是我们团队的工作成果。我们有一套框架,叫做交通灯系统(traffic light system)。简单来说,每当团队要做一个内容系列时,他们会去找多达 700 个关键词。这些关键词都与我们业务相关——有的是紧密相关的,有的是相对远一点的。然后这些关键词会按搜索量从高到低排序。这样你就有一张 Excel 表,左边是关键词,右边是搜索量。然后你一个一个去看——这确实需要时间——然后问:搜索这个关键词的人,意图是什么?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:19:22): 是一个大学生在写论文、永远不会成为我们的客户?还是一个人确实在寻找解决方案、有可能成为我们的客户?这样分完之后,你会得到绿灯关键词——意图非常明确,这个人想要我们的解决方案;黄灯关键词——意图不太确定,可能是五五开,也许他们在考虑购买,也许还不到时候;红灯关键词——这个人不是在找我们的解决方案,搜索的原因完全是别的。分好之后,你就从绿灯中搜索量最高的开始往下做,然后是黄灯中搜索量最高的往下做,而红灯通常你根本排不到。
Lenny (00:20:03): 我很喜欢这个做法。那接下来,假设你选定了一个关键词,比如一个绿灯关键词——高意图、高搜索量——实际撰写一篇能做好 SEO 的文章,流程是怎样的?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:20:16): 第一步是理解搜索意图。为什么有人会输入这个关键词?他们想了解什么?其中一部分工作是去 Google 上看看,Google 目前在返回什么结果。我经常举的一个例子是:当你在 Google 里输入 EOR,它给你的不是名义雇主(Employer of Record),而是 enhanced oil recovery(强化采油),因为在 Google 上输入 EOR 的人,大多数都是在找那个东西。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:20:43): 如果我的团队盲目地说”我们要为 EOR 排名”,那永远排不上去,因为 Google 给人们的结果不是这个,人们搜索的也不是这个。所以首先要搞清楚:人们在找什么?然后创作一篇内容来回答这些问题。Google 页面底部有一块”接下来你可能会问的问题”,那是一个非常好的地方,可以帮助你理解——一个人完成这次搜索之后,下一个问题是什么?再下一个又是什么?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:21:11): 所以要弄清楚人们想从这次搜索中获得什么。然后市面上有大量的 SEO 工具可以帮助你确保你写的内容语言足够简单,五年级阅读水平的人也能看懂;确保你做了正确的事情,把关键词放在了正确的位置。我几乎把关键词理解为——那就是你的地址,是你告诉 Google”请把人送到我这儿来”的方式。所以你可以用很多工具。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:21:38): 我们用的是 Clearscope,非常好用。这些就是你所使用的工具。然后文章发布。通常这些工具会给你打分,说你拿了 A+,或者你是 C-,需要把语言降下来——目前写到了大学水平,而我们需要降到四年级阅读水平。
Lenny (00:21:55): 目前内容团队的结构是怎样的?有多少人?大致的分工是什么?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:22:00): 关于我们的内容团队,有一个很有意思的事实:带领这个团队的人是 Deel 最早的员工之一,我记得大概是第二或第三号员工。所以这个人对我们整个公司来说非常特别。我们内容团队的结构是这样的:由我们的内容总监领导。我们有一位同事负责全部运营工作——与自由撰稿人对接,确保需求简报发出去了,确保事实核查按时完成,文章在网站上发布,以及各项追踪工作,她在后台把整个机器运转起来。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:22:33): 然后我们有不同的人专注于不同的内容领域,因为你需要积累专业能力才能写好。所以有一个人负责某些产品线,另一个人专注于不同产品线背后的相关主题。最近我们还组建了一个团队专门做不同类型的内容,因为内容不仅仅是文字文章,还包括视频、教育内容。还有很多不同类型的内容我们想要尝试。所以现在有一个团队专门负责这些对我们来说比较新的媒介形式。
Lenny (00:23:04): 很好。那全职运营这个团队的总共有多少人?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:23:08): 目前团队大约总共八个人。
Lenny (00:23:11): 大概是——我不确定是不是正好 50%——差不多你们增长的一半基本上是来自这个团队的?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:23:17): 是的。
Lenny (00:23:18): 关于如何让 SEO 真正发挥作用,你还有什么觉得特别重要或者特别有效的发现吗?
SEO 的最大误区
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:23:23): 人们犯的最大错误是——SEO 这件事,你可以试图自动化它,可以做很多省时间的操作,但它永远不会不再耗时。要做好 SEO,就是要花时间的。所以很多人做做就烦了,或者觉得做关键词研究、一个一个地去分析这些事情配不上自己的级别。而这恰恰是人们输掉的地方——他们试图走捷径。一旦走捷径,你就创造不出高质量的资源。归根结底就是:你的资源质量好不好?是还是不是?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:23:55): 所以当你想着”我要排名”,然后把那些步骤全跳过去,内容就不会好。没人愿意读,你的项目也不会有什么成果。所以我觉得这是人们随着职级提升后常犯的最大错误——觉得这些事情配不上自己。
Lenny (00:24:11): 这很有意思,这和我做 newsletter 得到的建议完全一样。Newsletter 如果不奏效,通常意味着内容对人们来说不够有价值。这是一种非常清晰的 meritocracy(优胜劣汰)——如果有用,人们就会读、会订阅、会分享;如果没用,他们就不会订阅。而 Google 本质上就是根据人们的行为判断出这一点的。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:24:30): 对,完全正确。
内容产出规模
Lenny (00:24:31): 为了让大家对运营规模有个概念,你们一个月、一周大概产出多少篇文章?或者你能分享的任何数据?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:24:38): 我们以前大约每周产出 10 篇文章,都是全新的。而现在我们更多是每周 5 篇新文章加 5 篇文章更新。因为我们写的那种内容,法规会变,各种情况一直在变,所以即使某篇文章两年前就发布了,我们也得确保它是最新的。所以我们有一个团队专门负责持续的事实核查。我们大约每周做 5 篇文章更新和 5 篇全新文章。当然,我们还覆盖多种语言。最初只做英文,现在已经扩展到其他语言。所以工作永远做不完。
什么样的公司适合做 SEO
Lenny (00:25:15): 有一个问题我一直在反复思考:是不是每家公司都应该做 SEO,SEO 对每家公司都会有效?根据我的经验,某些产品特别适合做 SEO,尤其是那些有用户生成内容或者有大量数据的,比如 Yelp 或 Glassdoor,它们可以用各种方式生成大量页面。你对什么样的企业、什么样的公司最适合做 SEO 有什么看法?还是你觉得大家都应该在某种程度上做 SEO,即使它不是增长策略的主要部分,也会有帮助?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:25:47): 我不认为所有人都应该做 SEO。如果你所在的领域,人们会去搜索解决方案,那你应该做 SEO。但如果你是一家直销消费者的口红公司——我自己可是口红大户——你大概不应该在 SEO 上投入太多,因为人们不会为了这个去 Google。她们去 Instagram,去关注 influencer。即使有人搜”2023 年最佳口红”,你的网站排名上去的概率也很低,因为你不是一个第三方、客观地去做比较的平台。所以这真的取决于你的产品是什么。但如果你所在的领域——大多数 B2B 产品都属于这种情况——你在具体解决一个真实存在的问题,那我认为 SEO 是一个好选择。如果你是消费品,也许就不需要投入那么多了。
Lenny (00:26:39): 非常有道理。回到早期阶段,你当初是被聘为 Deel 的增长负责人的,能做的事情很多。我很好奇,你是怎么决定在早期把资源优先投入到哪里的?哪些是早期做的事,哪些是后来才开始做的,又有哪些在早期几乎完全不用操心?关于这种早期优先级排序的实践,你有什么经验?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:26:59): 好的。我觉得在早期,回到基础非常重要——先搭好骨架,再化妆。我会问的第一个问题是:你有网站吗?速度快吗?搜索引擎知道它的存在吗?好,很好。下一步是:人们能找到它吗?如果找不到,你就需要写内容,确保人们能找到你。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:27:24): 只有在这些问题都解决之后,你才应该考虑:我有钱吗?能不能投一些付费广告,确保人们来到我的网站?所以要一步一步来。但如果你网站加载时间超过四秒,你不可能跑好一个付费广告项目。所以真的要回到基础,从核心的良好体验出发,然后一步一步扩展。这是我会建议所有人在起步时采用的方式。如果让我重新被雇佣一遍,我也会这样做。
Lenny (00:27:54): 我很喜欢这个思路。那具体是哪些步骤呢?第一步是,你有网站吗?第二步是确保网站性能良好,用户访问时能有一个好的体验。我猜其中一部分也包括,人们是否理解你们做什么——比如调整话术和——[听不清 00:28:07]
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:28:06): 对,没错。说到话术,我们的文案团队在这方面做得非常出色。在 B2B 领域,很容易想出一些声明,换个公司放在他们的网站上同样适用,听起来很棒,你和你的团队也觉得很满意。但如果你的 one-liner(一句话介绍)也能套用在别的公司身上,那就请不要把它作为你的 one-liner。要让人们真正理解你们是做什么的。因为现在外面有太多这样的说法——“我们把复杂的事情做了,好让你专注于你最擅长的事”——这到底是什么意思?你把这句话给 90% 的 B2B 公司都能用,那就说明它还不够好。
从硬编码网站到快速迭代
Lenny (00:28:51): 你还记得在早期,网站也好、定位也好,有没有改过什么带来了显著提升的事情?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:28:57): 我们的网站当时是硬编码的,所以在开发团队的帮助下,我们做的第一件事就是把它迁移到一个我可以方便访问和编辑的平台上,这样我们就能持续做 A/B 测试。除此之外,我们在价值主张上也花了很多精力去测试——向人们解释我们到底做什么,先讲问题、先讲解决方案,以及节省时间、节省成本——把这些放在一起做快速 A/B 测试。
长尾渠道的策略
Lenny (00:29:24): 过了那个阶段之后——也许你开始做一些付费广告和其他事情——你发现可以把更多资源投入到哪里?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:29:32): 在我们覆盖了主流的四五个广告平台之后,就开始关注长尾渠道。所谓长尾渠道,就是那些单独来看从来不贡献足够大的份额、你不会单独为它操心的平台。但如果你把它们加在一起,它能让你的线索来源多样化,最终大约占到总线索量的 30%。这些可能是评论类网站,或者规模小得多、但也能投放广告的渠道,包括 newsletter 广告、播客广告等等。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:30:06): 你跑一条单独的播客广告,确实不太可能从一个播客获得 2000 个客户。但如果你跑 10 条,它就开始累积起来了。所以我们真正专注的就是长尾。我们开始切入非常细分的网站,它们每个月可能只有五万、十万访客——在你考虑付费广告策略时,这其实不算多。但所有这些渠道加在一起就很可观了,而且它们往往被忽视,因为操作起来不那么方便,你得花时间从零开始设置,在每个渠道上都跑起来。我们的付费广告团队,花在跑 Facebook 和 Google 广告上的时间,跟花在那些第三方、小得多平台上的广告时间是差不多的。付出的精力一样,但你需要有一个多元化的线索来源。
Lenny (00:30:54): 播客广告的铁粉在此。也许这正是插入中插广告的好时机——也许吧,谁知道呢,也许该来的总会来。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:30:59): 听起来很完美。
Lenny (00:31:01): 来了。今天的节目由 AssemblyAI 赞助播出。如果你正在音频和视频产品中构建 AI 驱动的功能,那你需要了解 AssemblyAI——它让你能够大规模地转录和理解语音。我喜欢 AssemblyAI 的地方在于,你可以通过它们简洁的 API,访问来自顶级研究实验室的最新 AI 突破。产品团队、初创公司和企业正在使用 AssemblyAI 来自动转录和总结电话和虚拟会议、检测播客中的话题、精确定位敏感内容被说出的时刻,还有很多其他功能。
Lenny (00:31:36): AssemblyAI 的所有模型都通过 API 访问,且已达到生产就绪状态。我认识的很多产品经理正在考虑或者已经在用 AI 进行开发,而 AssemblyAI 是面向音频场景用 AI 构建产品的最快方式。现在是时候了解一下 AssemblyAI 了——它让你能轻松地将最高准确度的转录加上有价值的洞察带给你的客户,就像 Spotify、CallRail 和 Writer 所做的那样。访问 assemblyai.com/lenny 免费试用它们的 API,并使用无代码 playground 开始测试模型。网址是 assemblyai.com/lenny。
品牌认知广告的误区
Lenny (00:32:12): 欢迎回来。说到播客广告,我觉得这类广告有一个直接转化的层面——就像我们播这种广告,会带来线索——同时也有一个品牌认知、品牌建设的层面。我知道你对品牌认知类广告和营销活动不太感冒,尤其是在早期。我很想听听你的看法——为什么不看好,以及你怎么看待这类投资?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:32:36): 对于 B2B 企业,我确实不太推荐在早期做品牌认知活动。如果你是消费品创始人,可以跳过这段。我之所以不喜欢在早期做品牌认知,是因为要做好一次像样的品牌认知活动,需要时间。你需要有团队去做策略、做创意,而且不是每次都能命中。你不知道它们是否真的能引起共鸣。等你回头一看,你在上面花了一整个月,结果没有引起共鸣,一个月就浪费了。
先吃透漏斗底层的转化人群
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:33:07): B2B 企业的独特之处在于,它们之所以被创立,是因为存在非常真实的需求,而且有大量人群已经准备好转化。所以先吃透漏斗底部,然后再走出去面向更广泛的大众。但我可以向你保证,至少需要六到八个月的时间,才能把那些当下就准备转化的漏斗底部人群充分挖掘出来,之后你才不得不开始在外面做品牌认知广告。这不是说永远不要做品牌认知广告,但它往往是那个闪亮的、很酷的、你想去做的事情,结果在早期只是浪费时间。因为人们甚至还不了解你在做什么,你自己也还没有真正搞清楚什么样的信息能引起共鸣,但你已经做了这个创意活动,然后人们会说:“看起来挺酷的,不过我还是继续去找我自己问题的解决方案吧。”
Lenny (00:33:53): 你有没有想到某个营销活动或品牌认知活动的例子,让你觉得”好吧,如果这样做的话,也许值得做”?
Notion 的户外广告
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:34:01): 我觉得 Notion 在户外广告方面做得非常出色。他们早期并没有做,而是在发展到了后期才开始——那时候所有在科技行业工作的人都知道 Notion 是什么,这些广告的目的是持续强化这个信息,而不是向世界介绍自己。所以到了那个阶段,当你在广告牌上看到那个界面布局时,它是有意义的,你会说:“哦,我知道他们在说什么。”
Lenny (00:34:23): 那你觉得 Notion 做得好的地方是什么?是时机,还是广告本身你觉得也很棒?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:34:30): 是的,我现在回忆起来的那些广告展示的是他们的产品界面。所以他们需要足够的时间——当然这是我的推测,如果 Notion 的人想跳出来说”我们不是因为那个原因做的”,请便——但我认为他们需要足够的时间让人们熟悉那个界面。因为 Notion 的界面非常独特,你一看就能认出来,跟其他任何产品都不一样。所以除非人们已经建立了对那个界面的认知和辨识度,否则用那个布局做户外广告没有太大意义,因为恰恰是那个布局本身就能传达他们在说什么产品。如果他们在第一天就做这个,人们会说:“我看的这个东西到底是什么?“
合作伙伴的选择
Lenny (00:35:07): 我们一直在梳理 Deel 成长的各种方式,聊了 SEO、社区,你也提到了合作伙伴关系。关于合作伙伴到底发挥了什么作用,有什么有意思的可以分享吗?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:35:18): 有的。我觉得非常重要的一点是,你要知道应该跟谁合作。合作伙伴其实分两类。人们往往会跟任何有共同受众的公司合作,这是一个还不错的起点。但仅仅因为你们有共同受众,并不意味着你的受众会在遇到这个问题时去找你的合作伙伴寻求建议。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:35:35): 在我们的案例中,风险投资合作伙伴是一个非常重要的方向,因为当你从一家新 VC 那里拿到钱的时候,他们会问你:“好的,谢谢你们给我们这笔钱,现在我们想用这笔钱扩充团队。你们的其他被投企业在用什么?你们信任并会推荐哪个平台?“所以人们会就这类问题去问他们的 VC。但可能存在另一家科技公司,切入的受众跟我们完全一样,但人们从来不会去找他们问这个问题。所以我们跟他们的合作很可能不会有同样的效果。所以重要的不仅是认识到受众重叠的价值,还要看这些人是否被视为你所提供的解决方案的值得信赖的资源。
Lenny (00:36:16): 我非常喜欢你不斷回到的这个思路——人们在哪里问这个问题,你能帮他们回答。为了让这一点对大家来说更具体,你能不能再举一些人们会问的、Deel 能帮他们解答的问题的例子?这样可以帮助大家思考,好吧,也许我们的产品能帮他们回答这些其他类型的问题。
人们真正在问的问题
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:36:35): 从早期到现在,合规一直是一个被大量提及的问题。当你是一家公司的 HR 负责人、财务负责人或法务负责人,公司在美国运营,但你想在另一个国家招人,你不知道自己不知道什么。所以拥有既了解你所在国家、又了解你试图招聘的目标国家的专业人士是非常重要的。合规一直是我们所做的很重要的一部分,也是我们一直在为人们解答的。这就是为什么我们有内部专家来回答这些问题,并持续提供更新——如果那个问题的答案随着时间发生了变化,毕竟法规在不断变化。我们一周前给出的答案可能会变,你需要非常主动地把这些变化传达给用户。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:37:18): 税务是另一个大类,尤其是在我们所处的领域——薪酬、招聘。各国的税法不同。你需要知道什么时候该交什么税、什么时候不用交、以及人们从事的工作类型对应什么税务规定。这些都是人们会问的问题。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:37:34): 对我们来说,这些问题都非常具体、非常细化到使用场景。一名全职工程师所需缴纳的税款,和一名设计师作为独立承包商的情况可能截然不同。这些就是我们会跟人们深入讨论的具体细节。
Lenny (00:37:50): 明白了。所以就是类似”我要在土耳其招一名工程师,该怎么处理税务?“然后你们给出答案:“这是解答。“接着就是”如果你希望我们直接帮你处理,那就看看 Deel。”
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:37:59): 没错。很少有人直接问”最好的薪酬解决方案是什么?“那种问题——好吧,确认一下你倾向的选择不太差、而且其他人也认同你,这没问题。但归根结底,你需要最好的薪酬解决方案,是因为你需要确保不出问题。
被 IRS 引用的那篇博客
Lenny (00:38:15): 说到通过内容来回答问题,你之前跟我说过,你写过一篇博客文章,结果被 IRS 链接为某个问题的权威答案。我觉得这不是在 Deel 期间的事——能分享一下这个故事吗?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:38:28): 对,实际上是在我上一份工作中。而写那篇文章的人现在就在 Deel。所以他也跟过来加入了我们。但没错,那正好是 Covid 刚爆发的时候,美国政府推出了 PPP 项目。当时有大量问题:我符合资格吗?如果符合,怎么申请?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:38:51): 当时我所在的公司有很多客户在说:“我该怎么办?我需要申请这个,但我不知道该怎么做。“所以团队花了时间去真正理解这个系统怎么运作、你是否符合资格、以及该怎么做。然后我们为自家客户做了这个资源,纯粹是想帮助他们。结果这个资源做得太好了,以至于 IRS 的网站直接链接了过来,说”如果你有疑问,去看看这篇文章。“那是一个令人非常骄傲的时刻。这也证明了,当你尽最大努力去回答问题,而其他人没有时间去做这件事的时候——不管对方是谁——他们都会把人引向你。而那恰好也成了一个重要的增长时刻。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:39:33): 那是一个非常不幸的事件,我们宁愿那段经历从未发生、那篇文章也从未需要写。但没错,这就是 IRS 链接到公司资源页的故事。
Lenny (00:39:44): 这就是”问题已被彻底解答”的终极标志——IRS 都决定链接到你。所以你是说,IRS 的流量实际上是一个重要的增长驱动因素。我很好奇到底有多少人真正去读了那篇文章?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:39:57): 在人们集中申请 PPP 的那几周短时间窗口里,效果非常显著。然后它就消退了,PPP 本身也是如此。
付费增长的经验
Lenny (00:40:05): 合理。关于付费(增长)最后一个问题,然后我想转到另一个话题。根据你在 Deel 的经验,对于做好付费增长有什么心得?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:40:15): 好,有几件事。我们的付费团队在信息传达和优化两方面都投入了大量时间。优化指的是你出价设置的技术方式,确保不超预算,以及你是否负担得起那些出价。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:40:31): 而信息传达则要确保,当有人看到你的广告——不管是在 Instagram、Twitter 还是 Google 上——内容对他们来说是合理的。创意疲劳是真实存在的。你投放一个广告,前三周效果很好,但人们看腻了,你需要不断更新。所以我们的付费团队实际上每月都会更新投放的广告,只有少数 Google 广告例外,那些需要直截了当。所以要始终走在创意疲劳前面。同时确保你的信息传达也跟上产品演进的步伐——即使广告效果很好,你也要确保随着产品迭代,广告信息也在同步更新。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:41:07): 还有就是不要只看一场活动产生了多少线索,而要看其中有多少真正转化成了客户,以及你从这些客户身上实际赚了多少钱,这样才能理解回本周期。因为营销人员往往倾向于想,“哦,这是一个很好的线索渠道,我从中获得了好多线索。“但你拿这个问题去问销售团队,他们会说,“是啊,我很忙,但这些线索一个都转化不了。“所以真的很重要的一点是,不要只看你引入的量,还要看这些量在你业务中一年下来的完整旅程——你实际从他们身上赚了多少钱——这样才能合理地决定,我愿意花多少钱来赢得这个客户。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:41:44): 我们的做法是和数据团队合作,搭建了一个实时追踪的仪表盘。我们知道一个来自 Facebook 广告的平均客户,从线索到合格商机到成交的转化率是多少。然后我们平均从那个客户身上一年能赚多少钱。这样我们就能判断,这个渠道值不值得我们投入、我们是否不应该在那里投资,或者我们是否已经到了峰值、无法继续追加投入。
产品是增长的核心
Lenny (00:42:11): 在我们聊这些的过程中,有一件事我应该提一下:我们在讨论各种增长产品的方式,但这一切的核心是一个好产品——人们真正觉得有价值、愿意持续使用的产品。所以一个相关的问题就是,产品本身如何融入整体增长策略——让产品成为人们真正想要的东西,与所有这些获客渠道之间的关系是怎样的?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:42:29): 如果你的产品达不到预期,获客渠道根本就不会奏效。我个人觉得非常幸运也很被惯坏了,因为从我加入 Deel 的第一天起,产品就是一流的。作为加入一家早期公司的人——我在 A 轮之后加入——我本来预期后台会有一些用胶带粘起来的东西,这很正常。但结果我发现,工程师和产品团队——如果他们说产品能做到某件事,它就真的能做到,甚至做得更多。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:42:59): 所以在我团队早期推介 Deel 的时候,人们的反应是:“我觉得你们不可能做到所有这些,我不信。“我们甚至不得不调低我们的宣传口径,好让人们愿意相信我们。但即使你是世界上最厉害的营销人员,即使人们来到你的产品面前,即使你的销售团队成功说服他们成为客户——这确实可以做到——但如果产品达不到预期,尤其是在 B2B 领域,人们不会容忍糟糕的产品,他们会离开。消息会传出去,大家会知道这不是一个值得用的产品。所以产品确实是我们所做一切的核心。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:43:35): 我觉得当你身处一家产品很棒的公司时,很容易把这当作理所当然——你会觉得”情况一直都会是这样”。但我想鼓励每一个考虑加入年轻公司的人:问问他们团队构成是什么样的。当我加入 Deel 的时候,团队的大部分人是产品和工程师。这告诉我,这家公司的根基是稳固的。然后我们才围绕产品搭建了营销、销售、数据这些支撑性的团队。但如果你在和一家做 B2B 产品的早期公司谈,而他们有六个销售、两个工程师,那他们的产品大概率撑不了多久。
Lenny (00:44:12): 尤其是如果产品是外包开发团队做的,他们会说:“哦,他们会搞定产品的,我们只管卖。“另外一件我觉得很重要的事——Covid 是你们增长中一个重要因素。所以第一个问题,这确实如此吗?第二个,在 Covid 期间,你们在增长方面分别加大了哪些投入、缩减了哪些投入,来帮助人们在最需要的时候发现 Deel——基本上就是大量公司转向远程办公的那段时间?
Covid 与全球工作
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:44:39): 关于 Covid,实际上很多人以为 Deel 是作为对疫情的响应而创立的,我们其实在疫情之前就成立了,然后疫情发生了。所以虽然很令人难过,但它确实迫使人们进入了我们愿景的一次试点——它迫使人们远程工作,不管这意味着你和住在隔壁街区的人远程协作,还是你和在德国的人远程协作。所以我们确实从中受益——每个人至少被迫验证了这个假设:不跟同事待在同一个房间里,协作是否可行?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:45:17): 而在 Covid 走向尾声时,我们经常被问到的一个问题是:“Covid 快结束了,你们不担心人们不再用 Deel 吗?“我们对此的回答一直是:我们不是一家远程工作平台,我们是一家全球工作平台。很多企业已经回到了办公室。我们有很多客户要求员工回到办公室,但现在他们的办公室分布在德国、加拿大、美国和法国。所以我们从来不是一家远程工作公司,我们一直是一家全球工作公司。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:45:49): 而远程工作这件事,因为当时围绕它的新闻报道非常多,我们就这样变成了它的代名词。所以我确实认为早期我们从中受益了,能够提供那样的解决方案。很多人看到了现实:“嘿,我和这个人协作的效果,跟以前在办公室里一样好。那我正在找的最合适的人选,这个岗位可能并不在我所在地区,所以不管他们在哪里,我就直接雇了。“人们对此越来越习以为常,越来越多的公司也开始朝这个方向转变。
增长渠道
Lenny (00:46:20): 在帮助 Deel 在那段时间实现增长方面,有没有什么最终被证明特别重要的东西?比如某个渠道让你觉得”我们要在这个渠道上大力投入,因为看起来效果非常好”?还是说基本上就是口碑传播,大家就是觉得”糟了,我真得解决这个问题,火烧眉毛了,市面上有什么方案?让我去找找”?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:46:36): 我不会说是口碑传播,也许在最早期确实是口碑传播,但在我们运营的头几个月内就不是了。或者至少口碑传播在人们发现我们的方式中所占的比例很快就不再是最大的了。但始终不变的是,人们需要薪酬解决方案,他们需要一种方式来雇佣海外独立承包商,而我们恰好就是答案。所以我们持续地把自己推到他们面前说:“嘿,如果你正在做这件事,或者你已经在做了但方式不合规,我们可以帮你合法地完成。“
团队建设与招聘
Lenny (00:47:10): 我想聊聊团队建设,听说这是你非常擅长的事情。我的第一个问题是,早期你搭建团队的时候,具体来说是增长团队,你觉得哪些技能最重要、一定要看?又有哪些技能和经验你发现早期没那么重要,可以先牺牲、等以后再说?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:47:30): 早期我会问候选人的第一个问题就是:你愿意承诺哪些 KPI?如果一个人只愿意承诺线索数量,那不够好。他们需要能够承诺成交收入的 KPI,才能真正表明他们关心公司的底线。所以我们找的是那些愿意对整个漏斗负责的人。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:47:53): 而且很多时候,人们倾向于从自己想成为的那种大公司挖人,因为品牌名很诱人。但如果你是一个 35 人的团队,却想从一家大公司招一个什么什么总监,你需要问的问题是:这个人是什么时候加入那家大公司的?他们是公司已经 5000 人的时候才进去的,从第一天起就拥有所有资源?还是他们确实是较早加入的员工,真正参与推动了那波增长?因为我常常看到人们犯的错误是——他们会从一家了不起的公司招来一个人,这个人完成过了不起的成就,但他们不习惯只用原来 10% 的资源来做事。所以他们不愿意弯下腰去做那些脏活累活。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:48:35): 在 Deel 我们有一个概念叫 “小手”(little hands)。我觉得这大概是法语翻译过来的,有人可以纠正我。它的基本意思是,不管你是谁,在组织中身处什么位置,你都必须愿意深入到最小的细节里去做那些琐碎的工作,而不是回避它。这一点非常重要——无论我们在什么层级招聘什么人,就是问:“你愿意做最小的工作吗?“如果答案是肯定的,那很好。有些人会说:“我会为此建一个团队。“当然未来也许你应该建,但这不应该成为你的第一反应。你的第一反应应该是:“当然,我愿意做。“如果有人对此不兴奋,那他们至少不适合我们现阶段的公司。
Lenny (00:49:18): 这个说法真棒,小手。你提到你会考察人们是否愿意承诺收入目标。这是在面试中进行的吗,还是……你怎么做的?因为难道不是每个人都会说”没问题,你要我承诺什么我就承诺什么,我会搞定的”吗?你怎么判断一个人是不是真正会这么做?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:49:38): 这在面试过程中就能体现。一种方法是看他们在过去的岗位上曾经承诺过哪些 KPI。如果他们从来没有承诺过收入目标或漏斗底部相关的目标,却说自己愿意承诺,那大概率不是真的。我总是会问:如果他们确实没有过,我会说:“你现在的 KPI 是什么?你觉得你应该是哪些 KPI?“因为有时候只是公司没有给他们那些指标,但他们自己仍然认为应该被赋予更靠近漏斗底部的目标。这是我在面试过程中会留意的东西。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:50:06): 还有一个很好的测试方法,这更多是在案例分析环节,但可以让候选人在 0 美元、10,000 美元,也许还有 100,000 美元的预算下各出一套策略,看看他们是否能够跟你一起成长。看看在不同投入水平下他们的思维方式有什么不同,在不同投入水平下他们愿意承诺什么。因为如果有人两手一摊说:“0 美元的话,我只能做社交媒体监测,不会有太多效果,因为这就是现实。“那你大概就知道,在你给他们所有需要的资源之前,他们不会愿意承诺那些漏斗底部的指标。
增长团队的目标与结构
Lenny (00:50:46): 听起来你在 Deel 内部给团队定目标的方式也是收入——增长团队基本上背着收入目标。不是像你说的线索量或流量之类的。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:50:55): 是的。这就是为什么我们叫增长而不是营销,我们关心的是收入增长。当然我们也会追踪线索和 SQL(销售合格线索)。这些是先导指标,帮助我们判断最终能否达成我们所有人都关心的那个终极数字。但归根结底,那不是我们定义成功的方式。
Lenny (00:51:12): 在团队结构方面,你是怎么思考早期增长团队的架构的?当时是什么样的,汇报线和投入的板块分别是什么?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:51:21): 好的,在很早期的时候,我们总是会先引入一位负责人来管理组织的某个部分,然后让他们逐步扩展自己的团队。我们不太喜欢基于”某个假设会奏效”就去招一批人这种方式。那是一种很容易导致裁员的方式,因为你原以为会奏效的计划没有奏效。所以我们总是先招一个人,验证一个理论,然后让他们扩展团队。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:51:43): 所以我们招到团队的第一人其实是一位产品营销人员。到今天她仍在负责我们的产品营销团队,她就是那个坐在产品团队和上市团队之间、真正设定信息传递框架的人。很快我们意识到这个人需要更多帮助来设定信息传递的基调和风格,于是我们招的第二个角色是一个非常出色的文案。这个人现在负责我们的整个创意团队。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:52:08): 然后我们招到增长团队的第三个人其实是一位数据分析师,因为我们的理念是——如果我们不知道钱花到哪里去、不知道它在为我们做什么,我们就不愿意花哪怕一块钱。很多人会觉得这个招聘太早了……数据分析师作为第三号员工确实太早了。但我至今仍然觉得我们当时的决定是对的。现在我们有了一整个数据团队,但那时候还没有。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:52:32): 这就是我们最初在顶层搭建的三个团队。而内容方面的同事在我加入 Deel 的时候就已经在了,就是我之前提到的那个早期员工。我们最初就是这样搭建起来的。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:52:45): 现在团队结构已经变了。我们目前有了一个不同的结构,略有不同,分为区域团队和职能团队。职能团队基本上是各个领域的专业人才。他们擅长自己做的事,我们不在乎他们在世界哪个角落。这些团队包括产品营销、内容、社区、活动、付费广告、品牌。如果我们在寻找世界上最优秀的平面设计师,我不在乎他在哪里,他可以坐在世界上任何地方。这就是职能团队。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:53:16): 然后我们有区域团队。因为我们在很多不同地区开展业务,需要确保我们也有本地化的专业能力。所以我们为不同的重点区域配备了市场经理,他们再与我们的职能团队协作,把策略落地。我们就是这么搭建的。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:53:33): 我见过一些企业搭建区域团队时,每个区域都有自己的付费广告团队、自己的内容团队。但我们发现,当你把人从他们的专业群体中抽离出来——比如你有一支付费广告团队,五个付费广告的人,你把他们拆开分配到不同区域,而不是让他们坐在一起形成一个紧密的团队——最佳实践的学习和技能提升的速度,远不如让所有技术岗位的人坐在一起来得快。所以我们继续坚持职能加区域的架构。
区域与职能团队的资源分配
Lenny (00:54:09): 所以假设土耳其团队想投放付费广告,他们要去说服付费增长团队在土耳其投入资源?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:54:16): 没错。他们会与中央付费广告团队合作,说我想在土耳其投放付费广告,这是我要瞄准的受众。然后他们一起协作来执行这个策略。
Lenny (00:54:28): 那个职能团队怎么决定谁优先获得他们的时间?有没有一个大致的分配方法?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:54:32): 这取决于一个区域的总可触达市场规模(total addressable market),我们看到的机会有哪些,竞争格局如何。所以如果一个市场被我们视为一级行场(tier one),而且我们已经在那里看到了不错的增长,我们就会向其投入资源。然后在这个过程中我们不断学习,决定是继续加码还是稍微收缩。
Deel 的文化
Lenny (00:54:53): 很好。我想聊聊文化,聊聊 Deel 的文化。我们之前请过 Ramp 的 Jeff 来做节目,他们公司的文化可以用一个词来概括——“velocity”(速度)。你们也是史上增长最快的企业之一,我很好奇你会怎么对比你们的文化,以及更广泛地说,你怎么看待初创公司的文化、怎么帮助塑造 Deel 的文化?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:55:12): 好的,我觉得文化由两个部分组成。一是你作为团队成员给公司带来了什么,二是公司回馈给你什么。我们对团队成员的期望——我们对”速度”的版本,是我们称之为”Deel speed”的东西——就是我们要确保以紧迫感行事。不管团队已经发展到多大,我们都要以紧迫感为客户服务。如果一个客户有问题,他们不会等两周才得到答复。他们会在 24 小时内得到答案。如果我们需要开发一个产品,因为很多客户都在提这个需求,那个产品的开发速度大概是任何竞争对手的十倍。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:55:51): 所以”Deel speed”对我们来说非常重要。这也是我们对团队成员的期望——承诺这一点,去想:我能用什么最快的方式妥善解决这个问题?并且不断地逼迫自己以紧迫感行事。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:56:06): 我们也很在意保持积极。我们有默认的乐观主义,因为我们身处一个全新的领域,所以如果有人来到 Deel、抱着悲观的态度说”我觉得这个行不通,因为某某原因”,他们只会拖慢节奏。我们需要的是人们提出这样的问题:“我觉得这个行得通,理由有这四个,现在让我们看看有哪些风险,然后去想办法解决那些风险。“这也是我们对团队成员的期望。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:56:31): 然后第三点——不是最后一点,但第三个重要的是——真正地在乎你的客户。说到底,我们的产品面对的是人,关乎他们的生计,他们拿到薪酬的方式,关乎企业如何招聘。如果有人没有按时拿到工资,或者有人因为合同没有正确设置而陷入法律麻烦,这是极其个人的事情。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:56:57): 所以要认识到,我们不仅仅是在努力做一个最好的软件和平台——不是的,这是一家企业试图向一个人支付报酬,让他能过好自己的生活,同时企业能继续增长。这种关切是我们需要人们带到工作中的。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:57:14): 那么作为对这些付出的回报,公司给予的——除了薪酬和福利待遇等显而易见的之外——是给予人们灵活性来选择如何、何时完成自己的工作,他们可以自己决定在哪里工作、什么时间工作。我们基本上给予人们全部的自由来按照自己的意愿安排生活,前提是他们能给出我们需要的东西。所以我会说我们的文化确实很紧张,这一点我们毫不隐瞒,与人们公开分享。但归根结底,这也是我们区别于他人的地方。
核心价值观的形成
Lenny (00:57:48): 我很喜欢这个”Deel speed”。这些基本上就是 Deel 内部的核心价值观吧?你们会不断回到这些价值观上?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:57:54): 是的,没错。而且这些价值观我们也是公开分享的。
Lenny (00:57:58): 在公司生命周期的多早阶段,你们确定了这些价值观?很多初创公司都在思考一个问题:我们到底应该什么时候把这些价值观固化下来?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:58:06): 我记得我们大概是在公司成立一年左右的时候确定的,但我们并没有围坐在桌边讨论”我们的价值观该叫什么名字”。“Deel speed”是我们 CEO 会跟人说的话。他会说:“好,我想让你做这件事,但我希望你以’Deel speed’来完成。“早期有个玩笑是,我们做公司周边产品,做 Deel speedo(Deel 速度泳裤)之类的。反正这个词大家已经用得非常频繁了,我们就觉得,“好吧,我们一直在说这个词,那我们干脆正式定义一下它对我们来说意味着什么,把它固定下来,分享给大家。“所以我们确实做了这个梳理工作,大概是在公司成立一年左右的时候,但文化本身在那之前早就形成了。
Lenny (00:58:49): 让我想到,在 Airbnb,有一个团队负责制定核心价值观,大概是在公司成立四年的时候,一共有六条。然后几年后他们发现其中两条其实并不真实——它们只是愿望。于是大家意识到,价值观应该是”你是谁”,而不是”你希望成为谁”,否则就是搭不上的。所以他们真的砍掉了那两条,最后只剩下四条价值观。也许有一天他们会再拿回来。所以我觉得这是一个很好的教训——你要看清自己已经是怎样的,然后用一种有趣、有创意的方式把它们表达出来。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:59:22): 是的,没错。
Lenny (00:59:23): 有一种说法——你刚才叫什么来着,默认乐观(default optimism)。Airbnb 版本的那个叫”拥抱冒险(embrace the adventure)“,意思就是:这肯定会很疯狂,放手去做吧,拥抱它,这就是事情该有的样子。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (00:59:38): 没错。而且要试着去想”我怎么解决这个问题""这事怎么才能做成”,而不是去想”为什么这事行不通”。
Lenny (00:59:43): 对,我很喜欢这一点。而”紧迫感”这个话题在我做的这些访谈中反复出现。我想到的是 Frank Slootman——Snowflake 的创始人,他写了一本书叫 Amp It Up,讲的就是他们是怎么把 Snowflake 做起来的。他反复提到的一点就是,你需要始终保持紧迫感,因为一旦没有紧迫感,人们就会觉得无聊,实际上反而会更不喜欢自己的工作——就是那种”我也不知道自己在干嘛,事情就在慢慢推着走”的感觉。而快速推进其实有很大的价值。Jeff 也谈到过这一点,他说,当人们感觉事情在推进、在落地的时候,反而更不容易倦怠。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:00:18): 是的,那种感觉非常有成就感。我回想起来,有时候,比如当 SVB 出事的那段时间——他们遇到了那些问题——整个团队不得不在一个周日加班,跟我们的客户沟通,“没事的,我们没问题,别担心。“但我记得那个周日,我不得不放弃一场我特别期待的话剧。但当时就是觉得,天哪,我们在干一件大事,就像作战室一样,我们在解决问题。那种感觉很好。我周一上班的时候并没有觉得自己已经快被掏空了,反而是一种——对,我感到自己活着。而且我觉得,对的人就是会有这种感觉。
Lenny (01:01:00): 对,前提是不是经年累月地无穷无尽地加班熬夜、搭上周末。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:01:01): 不可能永远是战时状态。
Lenny (01:01:01): 我发现,那些最终最令人难忘、最有意义的时刻,恰恰就是你为了自己热爱的事情拼命工作的时候。而且这件事必须是你真的为之兴奋、为之自豪的。
熨衣板与远程工作
Lenny (01:01:10): 最后一个问题。我在 Twitter 上看到你分享了一张你家庭办公室的照片——窗外风景美极了,然后你把镜头转向书桌那边——居然是一个熨衣板。这里有两个问题。第一,这是怎么回事?第二,我记得你在某处提到过,你加入 Deel 之后一年半都没见过很多同事,公司非常远程优先。所以我也很好奇,你在那种环境下是怎么让远程工作运转起来的?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:01:36): 好,那我先解释一下熨衣板的事。那是因为我当时在伊斯坦布尔看望家人,我们的住处只有一张桌子。所以我和我丈夫就石头剪刀布,看谁用桌子,另一个人得自己想办法。他赢了,所以我就得想一个替代方案。而我背后的风景特别漂亮,能看到博斯普鲁斯海峡,每次开会大家都会说,“哇,好喜欢你的窗外风景,太棒了。“我就说,“不不不,各位,我现在坐在一个熨衣板上。“对我来说,这既好笑,又想给大家一个现实检验——“拜托,没有看起来那么光鲜。“但与此同时,那一刻我真的在想,“这也太棒了吧,我在 Deel 工作。”
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:02:22): 以前我想去伊斯坦布尔看家人的时候——我住在加拿大——我得用我的假期去。所以对我来说,能在任何地方照常工作,意义很大。那天我有满满一天的工作和会议,所有事情都照常进行,同时我还能陪在家人身边。所以那一刻,Deel 的承诺以一种非常真实的方式在我自己的生活中兑现了。而且我觉得特别搞笑。我爸觉得我把这个发到公开平台上太不专业了——他到现在还没完全理解创业公司的世界。所以那只是这样一个时刻:分享一个真实的画面——是的,工作可以是远程的,可以是任何你想要的样子。这就是熨衣板背后的故事。不过我现在录这期播客的时候,已经有了一个正式的家庭办公室,有桌子、有靠背椅子。情况一直在变。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:03:16): 至于回到你的第二个问题——早期没见过团队成员这件事。正如我说的,我是在 2020 年 7 月加入 Deel 的,当时疫情正处于高峰,我在加拿大,加拿大的出入境限制非常严格——不能出境,出去了就不让回来。所以我只能待在原地。我在 Deel 工作了一年半,第一次见到团队成员是在里斯本的一场会议上。我到的时候,那种感觉非常不真实——因为我和他们已经一起工作了一年半,我们完成了那么多事情,收入早就过了 5000 万美元,但我却是第一次见到这些人。所以那真的很有意思。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:03:58): 但如果回头看 Deel 的早期,有很多类似这样的小故事。比如我们忘了做公司周边,一直做到市值十亿美元的时候才想起来。其实是因为我们的照片要登上 NASDAQ 的大屏幕了,我们想拍一张团队合影,这才意识到,“兄弟们,我们得有 T 恤啊。能不能有人在纽约找个店把我们的 logo 印点什么出来?“很多事情只是因为我们是疫情期间的公司,所以来得晚了一些。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:04:25): 但我觉得让我在 Deel 能够早期就建立起文化的原因是——我们都是从家里办公的,从第一天起就是这样。我们也可以选择去 WeWork 或联合办公空间,如果你愿意的话。但每个人都能以非常真实的自我出现。所以我的同事们在很早的时候就认识了我的宠物和我的伴侣——比如果我在办公室上班的话会早得多。正因为你是进入某人的家里,所以有一种真诚感,我们在早期非常依赖这一点。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:04:56): 而作为公司,我从来没感受到必须以某种方式出现、或者为了会议穿正装的压力。所以就是能够做你自己——不管你是一个从不爱开摄像头的内向者,还是一个会说”来,见见我的狗”的人——这些都自然而然地在我们还不能线下见面之前,就建立起了团队文化和同袍情谊。
Lenny (01:05:20): 显然这招很奏效。Meltem,在我们进入非常令人期待的闪电问答环节之前,你还有什么想分享的吗?
增长没有想象中那么难
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:05:26): 我们聊得很好。我想告诉大家的一件事是,大多数人觉得增长非常困难。我不一定说它简单,但当你回到第一性原理——弄清楚用户在哪里?我如何为他们提供价值?——只要你的产品确实能带来价值,增长其实是相对直接的。所以我想说,大家应该认识到,它比你们想象的要简单得多,只是需要很大的纪律性去执行,它不是什么火箭科学。
Lenny (01:06:01): 非常鼓舞人心,我很喜欢。说到这里,我们已经到了非常令人期待的闪电问答环节。你准备好了吗?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:06:07): 我准备好了,来吧。
闪电问答(lightning round)
Lenny (01:06:09): 你推荐给别人的两三本书是什么?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:06:13): 非虚构类的话,我会推荐 Clay Christensen 的《How Will You Measure Your Life》。他把自己在商业领域的心得应用到了人生中。这本书很短,很容易读完。除此之外,我经常推荐虚构类作品。我觉得曾经有一段时间,读虚构作品变得不酷了——好像你每一刻都必须是高效的,都必须学点什么。我不管你读什么虚构作品,你读 Judy Blume 都行,就是去读虚构作品,发挥创造力,让你的大脑做点别的事情,不要总是在读非虚构、不停地学东西。
Lenny (01:06:48): 我自己也做了这个转变,感觉非常好,但我还是会不自觉地被非虚构吸引。不过这是个好提醒。你最近喜欢的电影或电视剧有哪些?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:06:58): 最近最喜欢的电影,跟大多数人一样,是《奥本海默》。我觉得它很棒。我确实希望他们能多探讨一下为什么他是那个驱使所有人追求卓越的人。但总体上很喜欢这部电影。我本来不觉得自己能坐着三小时不上厕所,但我做到了。最近最喜欢的电视剧是《The Summer I Turned Pretty》。我超级喜欢。我才不管它其实是给青少年看的,我每一秒都很享受。
Lenny (01:07:28): 你面试候选人时最喜欢问的一个面试问题是什么?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:07:28): 你的兄弟姐妹会怎么评价你?这个问题非常有揭示性。如果他们有兄弟姐妹的话;如果没有,我会问,你的父母会怎么评价你?但”你认为别人怎么看你”这件事本身就非常有信息量。
Lenny (01:07:41): 你在他们的回答中寻找什么,来判断他们是不是一个好的候选人?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:07:45): 我寻找真诚和自我觉察。你的兄弟姐妹永远不会……我是说,我爱我姐姐,但她可能会损我损得很厉害。意识到这一点非常重要。如果有人说,“我的兄弟姐妹会说我非常有条理,而且我是把整个家庭凝聚在一起的那个人。“那大概是一句废话。但如果他们说,“哦对,他们会说我这些奇怪的地方,“这展现了一定的自我觉察和谦逊,而这是我希望在一个人身上看到的。
Lenny (01:08:11): 你最近发现的、非常喜欢的产品是什么?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:08:14): 哦,这是个危险的问题。两个。一个是 NuStrips,咖啡因条。我觉得咖啡因药片什么的,或者喝咖啡的时候,一不小心就摄入 300 毫克,然后整个人都在亢奋。但这些每片只有 50 毫克,所以很容易控制自己。而且味道不差。所以当我只需要一点小提振的时候,我很喜欢用它们。
Lenny (01:08:32): 所以它们就是放在嘴里的条状物,然后给你咖啡因?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:08:32): 像 LISTERINE 的那些条一样。
Lenny (01:08:36): 什么?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:08:37): 你把它放在舌头上,它不会让你心慌手抖,而且只有 50 毫克,相当于一杯很淡的咖啡。
Lenny (01:08:45): 微量服用咖啡因。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:08:46): 没错。
Lenny (01:08:47): 太棒了。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:08:48): 第二个是,我最近收到了一份礼物——一个个人藏书章,我非常喜欢。因为我喜欢把书送给别人,所以我会在上面盖上我的藏书章。而且我喜欢想象有一天,在一家二手书店里我会偶遇它。
Lenny (01:09:03): 太棒了。Burning Man 有一个营地是一个图书馆,你可以借书,然后在一年后、你下一次回到 Burning Man 时归还。这太棒了。然后有一个人拿着扩音器,他就喊:“一本书被归还了!“把整个事情搞得很有仪式感。你经常回到的、或者分享给别人的人生座右铭是什么?不管是工作中还是生活中。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:09:27): 世界是由缺乏安全感的高成就者运转的。我以前觉得自己的不安全感是一个缺陷,我就会把它藏起来,假装它不存在。后来一个我非常敬重的人告诉了我这句话。我就想,“好吧,原来不是只有我一个人这样。“我确实认为世界是由一群有东西需要证明的人运转的——无论理由好坏——但拥抱它比假装你信心满满、做这些只是因为你天赋异禀要好得多。
Lenny (01:09:54): 天哪,说得太好了。最后一个问题,你最喜欢的加拿大食物是什么?你住在加拿大,所以才问这个。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:10:02): 好吧,不完全是食物,但是 Caesar——基本上就是加了蛤蜊汁的 Bloody Mary。
Lenny (01:10:08): 哦,Bloody Caesar,是这么叫的吗?还是就叫 Caesar?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:10:10): 就叫 Caesar。
Lenny (01:10:11): 就叫 Caesar。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:10:12): 但美国对应的版本就是 Bloody Mary。它比 Bloody Mary 好喝多了。它不是素的。然后我之所以把它算作食物,是因为在加拿大点这个的时候,里面会放意大利辣香肠条和腌芦笋,他们基本上把整顿饭都塞进去了。就是非常棒,美国真的应该引进这个。
Lenny (01:10:28): 我想我喝过一次,我觉得我还是更喜欢 Bloody Mary,但 Caesar 确实是个很好的推介。Meltem,非常感谢你来做客。我们聊了增长策略、团队建设、Deel speed、默认乐观(default optimism),还有很多其他话题。真的很感谢你抽出时间。最后两个问题,大家如果想联系你,可以在哪里找到你?听众怎样才能帮到你?
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:10:49): 他们可以在 Twitter 上通过 @MeltemK 联系我,我在那里回复最快。请不要在 LinkedIn 上联系我,我从来不回。听众帮到我的方式,一是我们一直在寻求关于 Deel 的反馈。如果你发现有什么可以改进的地方,请告诉我,我会确保传达给团队,不管是什么方面的。另外,如果有人有觉得我会受益的建议,或者好的虚构类书籍推荐,我随时欢迎。
Lenny (01:11:19): 太棒了。Meltem,再次非常感谢你来。
Meltem Kuran Berkowitz (01:11:23): 非常感谢你邀请我。
Lenny (01:11:25): 大家再见。非常感谢收听。如果你觉得这期节目有价值,可以在 Apple Podcasts、Spotify 或你最喜欢的播客应用上订阅。也请考虑给我们评分或留下评论,因为这真的能帮助其他听众找到这个播客。你可以在 lennyspodcast.com 找到所有往期节目或了解更多关于这个节目的信息。下期再见。
术语表
| 原文 | 中文 |
|---|---|
| A/B test | A/B 测试 |
| ARR | ARR(年度经常性收入,Annual Recurring Revenue) |
| awareness campaign | 品牌认知活动 |
| Bench Accounting | Bench Accounting(在线记账服务平台) |
| bottom of the funnel | 漏斗底部 |
| brief | 需求简报 |
| Burning Man | Burning Man(内华达州年度艺术节) |
| Clearscope | Clearscope(SEO 内容优化工具) |
| closed won | 成交 |
| comradery | 同袍情谊(comradery) |
| contractor | 独立承包商 |
| copywriter | 文案 |
| creative | 创意 |
| Deel | Deel(跨境用工与薪酬平台) |
| Deel speed | Deel speed(Deel 公司文化中的核心概念,指以紧迫感行事的工作节奏) |
| default optimism | 默认乐观(default optimism) |
| direct response | 直接转化 |
| duct taped | 用胶带粘起来的(指临时拼凑的解决方案) |
| EBITDA | EBITDA(息税折旧摊销前利润) |
| Employer of Record | 名义雇主(Employer of Record) |
| enhanced oil recovery | 强化采油(enhanced oil recovery) |
| fact checking | 事实核查 |
| first principles | 第一性原理 |
| freelancer | 自由撰稿人 |
| go-to-market | 上市 |
| Head of Growth | 增长负责人 |
| influencer | influencer(意见领袖/网红) |
| KPI | KPI(关键绩效指标,Key Performance Indicator) |
| lead flow | 线索来源 |
| Lenny’s Podcast | Lenny’s Podcast(播客名称) |
| lightning round | 闪电问答(lightning round) |
| little hands | 小手(little hands,源自法语,指不拒细务的工作态度) |
| LMNT | LMNT(电解质冲饮品牌) |
| long tail | 长尾(渠道) |
| meritocracy | meritocracy(优胜劣汰/以能力为衡量标准) |
| Miro | Miro(在线协作白板工具) |
| Miro-verse | Miro-verse(Miro 模板社区) |
| Navy SEAL | 海豹突击队(Navy SEAL) |
| net new | 净新增 |
| newsletter | newsletter(电子邮件通讯) |
| one-liner | 一句话介绍(one-liner) |
| out-of-home ads | 户外广告 |
| payback | 回本周期 |
| portfolio companies | 被投企业 |
| PPP program | PPP 项目(Paycheck Protection Program,薪资保护计划) |
| product marketing | 产品营销 |
| qualified opportunity | 合格商机 |
| Ramp | Ramp(企业支出管理平台) |
| rocket science | 火箭科学(比喻极其复杂的事物) |
| SaaS | SaaS(软件即服务) |
| SEO | SEO(搜索引擎优化) |
| SQL | SQL(销售合格线索,Sales Qualified Lead) |
| swag | 公司周边(swag) |
| Team USA Weightlifting | Team USA Weightlifting(美国举重队) |
| tier one | 一级行场(tier one) |
| total addressable market | 总可触达市场规模(total addressable market) |
| value proposition | 价值主张 |
| war room | 作战室(war room) |
| Watermelon Salt | Watermelon Salt(西瓜盐味) |
此文档由 AI 分片翻译(translate_long_document)