管理紧张、焦虑与倦怠 | Jonny Miller(Nervous Systems Mastery)
Managing nerves, anxiety, and burnout | Jonny Miller (Nervous Systems Mastery)
Jonny Miller: I have this idea that I call the feather brick dump truck phenomenon, and basically what that means is when we are showing early signs of burnout, our body will give us feedback usually in subtle ways in the beginning. So the feather might be waking up in the morning and feeling a little bit tired, maybe a little bit exhausted. The brick, maybe you ignore that or you don’t notice it, and then three or four weeks later, you have a fight with someone or an argument, or you just feel frustrated and terrible and you lose your cool. And then maybe the dump truck is a month later, or even a year later, there’s a full-blown health crisis, or you develop type two diabetes or there’s a whole range of things, or maybe you get fired. Ideally, you want to notice when it’s the feather and then make adjustments or shift then and not have to wait until you experience the full-blown pain of the dump truck, which unfortunately is what happens to a lot of people, especially when they experience burnout for the first time.
Meet the Guest
Lenny: Today, my guest is Jonny Miller. Jonny teaches courses and does one-on-one coaching with tech professionals helping them with something he calls Nervous System Mastery, which is essentially a set of tools and techniques for cultivating calm, upgrading your resilience, and increasing your aliveness. If you can get better at dealing with stressful situations, avoiding burnout and being more confident in meetings and big presentations, it becomes a superpower and a huge advantage in both business and in life. I actually read a post by Jonny about a year ago, and it totally changed the way that I think about nervousness and stress, and I still apply many of his lessons today.
Jonny, thank you so much for being here. Welcome to the podcast.
Jonny Miller: It’s great to be here, Lenny.
Why Study the Nervous System
Lenny: So I read this post that you wrote, I think it was over a year ago at this point. It was called The Operating Manual for Your Nervous System, and first of all, blew my mind when I read it. Second of all, I always think about it when I get nervous or anxious in a situation, it’s really stuck with me. And I know that people in the workplace often get nervous and anxious doing all hand presentations, meetings, performance reviews, all the things. So I thought it’d be awesome just to dive into the stuff that you’ve uncovered about how we can become less nervous and less anxious. Before we get into the meat of it, I’d love to just spend a couple minutes just getting a sense of why you got into this stuff. What actually got you to spend so much of your energy and life force trying to understand how the nervous system works, how to get people to be less nervous and anxious.
Top-Down vs. Bottom-Up Approaches
Jonny Miller: My story starts in I kind of have a background in tech. I had a startup, we went through Techstars back in 2012. About five and a half years into that experience, I went through burnout, which is pretty common in the startup world, but that actually wasn’t the trigger for me. I find that usually people that get into this type of work, there’s some kind of catalyst or some kind of challenging life event. And for me, that was October 23rd, 2017, and my fiance at the time had an anxiety attack and she took her own life. And that completely just destroyed me at the time. And I realized that I’d been so disconnected from my body and my emotions, and it sent me on this five plus year journey to discover all of this inner landscape that I’d been numb from the neck down, and I went into breathwork meditation retreats, did hundreds of breathwork journeys, researched with a breath lab over in Bali, and basically just kind of directed all of my focus and attention onto understanding this inner landscape that I’d been pretty much oblivious to. And since then, I’ve been working with founders, executives, running courses and teaching what I’m learning and hopefully still researching at the same time as well.
Lenny: Wow. And I imagine the thinking was that if your wife had these skills, she would’ve had another path.
How Breathing Shifts Your State
Jonny Miller: Yeah, that was definitely part of it, yeah. And also just since realizing how many people are struggling with anxiety, depression, all of this kind of constellation of mental health challenges both in the workplace and at home as well. And yeah, it’s been a very rewarding journey.
Why Breathing Is So Effective
Lenny: All right, this episode’s already gotten very heavy and I’m sucked in. I’m excited to learn all these things that you’ve uncovered. So let’s just get into the meat of it. Just talk about this kind of general method that you’ve found for how to help people become less nervous and anxious.
Jonny Miller: So I find this top down, bottom up distinction to be incredibly helpful. Most people when they try to calm down, they use tactical reframes or maybe mindfulness or maybe reframing the situation in a positive light. There’s lots of different practices that people use which do have some effect. But in my experience, working with the physiology, using what’s known as a bottom up approach, primarily using the breath, although there’s also other approaches that you can use, it’s just such a rapidly more effective way of shifting your state.
And to give a little bit of context and maybe some science as well, we have what’s known as afferent and efferent neurons going up and down our body, and there’s four times more afferent neurons going from the body to the brain as from the brain to the body. So you can almost imagine there’s a super highway of traffic of information going up to the brain and four times less going from the brain to the body. And so by learning how to pull on the levers of our physiology, we can rapidly change our state. And then from there, by changing our state, that impacts the thoughts and feelings that we have. So instead of trying to change the story or trying to fix something or trying to solve something, which is what most people do by default, myself included in the past, if you change your state first, then there’s a cascading effect which changes your thoughts and your feelings.
State Before Narrative
Lenny: Okay, amazing. Yeah, and just to share how I felt when I was reading this and try to understand this approach is whenever I get nervous, there’s always this like, oh, my body’s starting to feel anxious. And then I think of a reason. Oftentimes, I don’t know why it gets nervous, why my body’s starting to create this feeling of anxiety. And then I often realize I’m just now trying to just explain why it happened, “Oh, I have this big meeting coming up, or I have this podcast episode I’m nervous about, or I’m not going to make a deadline for my newsletter.” I often experience this where it’s just like, “Oh, something feels nervous.” And then, “Okay, here’s the explanation.” So maybe just along those lines, what else is there that might be helpful for people to think about in this context?
Live Practice: The 4-4-8 Breath
Jonny Miller: I mean, I think it’s helpful to understand the process by which, by changing the way that we breathe, for example, it shifts our physiological state and changes our nervous system. So if you’re listening to this, maybe you, Lenny, you can try this as well. If you start breathing into your upper chest and shallow fairly, fairly rapid, maybe even through the mouth, that will then there’s a part of your brain called the insular cortex, which is basically constantly spying on the way that we’re breathing and it will register that change, it will then send information to activate the endocrine system, which then creates shift in our blood chemistry. The sympathetic nervous system gets activated and that increase in adrenaline and cortisol starts to flood your body. Everyone’s probably very familiar with that feeling. And then that will then have a cascading impact on the thoughts that you’re having and the way that you feel. And so you just shared, we have a tendency to kind of confabulate or make up stories that match the state that we are in. And so that’s kind of what happens when we’re breathing in that way. And then you can also consciously change your breath to breathe in a different way, which has the reverse effects, which I can go into, but I’ll pause there.
Building Your Personal Breath Toolkit
Lenny: Yeah. So I think one of the big actionable takeaways here is that instead of trying to convince yourself, “No, this talk is going to go great, I don’t need to worry about how I’m going to look in this meeting.” Basically instead of going top down, trying to calm your body through thought, your advice is calm your body first because then your mind will notice, “Hey, I’m actually not as nervous as I thought. Maybe things are going to be okay.” Is that right?
Physiological Sighs and Up-Regulation
Jonny Miller: Yeah, precisely. And I mean I’ve used this myself many times before presentations. I gave a TEDx talk a few years ago and I was like my entire body, I was just terrified. And I did in 15 minutes of this breathing practice before and walked on stage almost cool as a cucumber. It’s very effective.
Lenny: Sounds too good to be true. But we’re going to do some of these exercises for people. Before we get into, why is it that breath specifically so powerful? It feels like such a strange thing to work so well, just this idea of breathing in a different way. You talked a bit about this, I forget what you called it, that kind of watches how you’re breathing. But I guess what else can you share about just why is breath so effective in changing our state?
The Espresso Breathing Technique
Jonny Miller: Sure. Well, it’s one of the few things which happens automatically, but we can also control it consciously. And so what scientists have discovered that when the exhale is twice as long as the inhale, it has a calming effect. And when the inhale is either more intense or twice as long as the exhale, it has an activating effect. So you can kind of think of this as an up or down lever on the nervous system.
An On-the-Go Breath Toolkit
Lenny: You also have this really clever way of describing this system. You call it state over story, essentially focusing on the state of your body versus the story you’re telling yourself. Is that the way to think about it? And can you just talk about that concept?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, so it’s basically a shorthand for what we’ve just been talking about, which is most people tend to approach the problem or try to solve things on the level of story. So there’s multiple ways you can do that through the breath as we just talked about. You can also defocus your gaze and kind of relax your eyes, and that has a similar effect. It can expand your awareness and kind of bring your awareness to behind you and the sides of you and below you, or you can breathe in these ways which emphasize the exhale. And so when we breathe in a way with say the exhale twice as long as the inhale, that part of the brain, the insular cortex then sends signals to the parasympathetic nervous system, which then has the cascading effect on our endocrine system and calms us down. And what I usually find as well is that the kind of reactive thoughts and feelings that we have when we are in that kind of anxious loop, they can be self-reinforcing. And so if someone has a thought of like, “Oh no, I’m nervous before this important presentation.” Then that exacerbates the breathing pattern and then the whole thing just goes into this spiral, which can end up in full-blown panic attacks if there’s not an intervention of some sorts.
Interoception: Your Sixth Sense
Lenny: Yeah, that’s what I find with my nerves. I hate talking on stage. I get nervous before every podcast. This is not my natural state.
Jonny Miller: Interesting.
Applying APE in Daily Life
Lenny: Yeah, and I hide it well.
Interoception and Its Link to Burnout
Jonny Miller: Is that still the case with podcast today?
What Is Emotional Debt?
Lenny: Absolutely. And it’s like different levels of nervousness, but it’s always just like, “Oh, there we go.” I’m not a performer person. Even I kind of push myself to do this podcast as a way to get better at this, to be honest. So it’s still a thing that I think about. And what I find is the nervousness comes from exactly what you described is the nervousness of being nervous. I don’t know, there’s no reason specifically to be anxious, but I don’t know how I’ll be once I do the thing. So it’s nervous of what it might look like or end up being like. So that’s exactly what I ran into.
Jonny Miller: Yeah. And there’s obviously people say mindfulness, meditation, things like that, that can increase the psychological space between stimulus and response. And that is something that obviously does help over the long term, but it’s in my opinion, nowhere near as rapid and effective and efficient as just changing the way that you’re breathing.
The Role of Somatic Therapy
Lenny: Awesome. So let’s get into it. I know you have a couple exercises specifically for this, and then we’ll go from there.
Jonny Miller: We can stack a few of the exercises and I’ll try and keep it to a minute or so. So yeah, if you want to get comfy in your chair and sit up straight, feel your butt on the seat, and I find it helpful to kind of be aware of the space behind you and above you as well, kind of expanding your awareness so that you are aware of the space behind to the sides and above.
Signs of Accumulating Emotional Debt
Lenny: And should we close your eyes?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, and close your eyes down. If you’re listening and driving, obviously don’t do that. But yeah, closing the eyes down for sure helps. And now we’re just going to do simple breath. We’re going to inhale in through the nose for four. We’re going to hold the breath at the top for four, and we’re going to exhale for eight, and then we’re going to repeat. So let the breath go and inhaling through the nose. Inhale, 2, 3, 4, hold the breath, 2, 3, 4. And exhale, 8, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. Inhale, 2, 3, 4, hold the breath, 2, 3, 4, and exhale, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. And now you can let go of the breath completely and we’ll end with one round of humming, which is surprisingly effect of it calming as well. So take a full breath in and humming through the nose all the way to the end of exhale. Let out a sigh if that feels good and open up your eyes.
Emotions and Decision-Making Ability
Lenny: I feel extremely calm. I should do this every podcast episode before we start.
The Cost of Emotional Buffering
Jonny Miller: A note on the humming. It also releases nitric oxide, which is a vasodilator, and that helps to create that kind of calming effect and it also reduces eye tension as well. So I’ll do it if I’ve been looking to screen for too long. It’s really good for kind of reducing eye fatigue as well.
Lenny: And there’s also a vagus nerve component to it because your body’s vibrating, is that true?
Non-Sleep Deep Rest (NSDR)
Jonny Miller: Yeah, precisely. So it kind of tones or stimulates the vagus nerve, which stimulates the parasympathetic nervous system.
The Minimum Viable Daily Practice
Lenny: What’s your advice for doing this? Is this before you go into a big meeting or a presentation? How do you apply this?
Jonny Miller: I kind of like to share building a toolkit of different practices that are appropriate for different contexts. So something like the 4, 4, 8 breathing, you could do pretty much anywhere without anyone necessarily noticing. Humming is slightly more obvious, but if you’re about to jump on a zoom or something, you can totally do it with your eyes closed. Things like expanding your awareness or bringing your awareness down to your feet and your hands, which creates a kind of grounding calming effect that also you can do if you’re in a busy room. Maybe you have social anxiety, even orienting and labeling things that you are hearing and feeling, kind of bringing the awareness and attention back into the body that also has an effect. And then there’s longer practices for say, non-sleep deep rests, belly breathing, things that you can do if you have 10, 20 minutes and you’re at home and you want a downshift.
So I like to kind of give people a big toolkit to see what works for them and then cherry-pick which ones are suitable to different situations. And another way that I think about this is, I call it, if this, then breathe. So it’s like if I feel overwhelmed, then I do the humming. If I feel anxious, then I do 4, 4, 8 breathing or alternate nostril breathing and kind of having my own little recipe set that I have for different context is really helpful and I work with people to kind of build those toolkits themselves.
Understanding Meditation and NSDR
Lenny: This sounds like it needs to be a website where people can go with these lists of if this, then that is there a place that we could send people in the show notes and if not, you should make one before we go live.
Jonny Miller: There is not currently. It’s part of the curriculum in the course that I have, but-
The Body Keeps the Score
Lenny: Okay, great.
Jonny Miller: … I can maybe see if I can spin one up as well, but yeah.
Some Counterintuitive Viewpoints
Lenny: Okay, cool. We’ll link to the course if nothing else. Amazing.
Jonny Miller: Okay.
Lightning Round Q&A
Lenny: Along this line of calming breath exercise, Huberman also has a different version, which I’ve tried and I’m going to do both now. You breathe in fully and then you breathe in a little bit more. I imagine you’ve seen that piece of advice?
Jonny Miller: That’s also fantastic. He calls it the physiological sigh, and it’s both very effective, especially if you just have five seconds and you just take a full sigh, it’s great. I’d also add that the sigh happens naturally as a result of doing these downshifting practices. So if you notice after you do let’s say the 4, 4, 8 breathing, at the end, you might naturally just want to let out a sigh, and that’s a signal that your body is naturally downshifting. Or if you are with a friend and you feel just comfortable and relaxed, then your body might sigh. And it’s something that we do a lot and as you say, you can consciously do it and that will help as well. That’s another one of the practices.
Favorite Products and Tools
Lenny: Awesome. So link to that. And I think throughout this episode, as you said, we’re going to give people a bunch of tools that they can use, and it feels like some are in the moment, “I need to feel calmer right now. Here’s a thing you could do.” And then there’s things you can do ongoing that build… I guess another way to think about it’s just make your body more calm as a baseline of practice to work on there.
Jonny Miller: Yeah, precisely.
Words to Live By
Lenny: Awesome, okay. I think the other breathing exercise we’re going to do is the opposite. Gets you all excited, is that right?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, sure. We can do that as well. I call this espresso breath. So this is the opposite. This is very activating. I would only recommend this if you’re feeling lethargic or maybe instead of drinking a coffee in the afternoon, you could do this for a minute or so. In the scientific literature, it’s bellows breath or breath of fire, and it basically looks like a series of rapid exhales through the nose. I like to keep it through the nose only if you do it through the mouth, it can be very too activating and it can kind of overwhelm people. Obviously, there’s the Wim Hof practice that I’m sure many people are familiar with. So this is a more gentle version of… If Wim Hof is like Red Bull, this is kind of like a small coffee.
What Makes Jonny Uneasy
Lenny: I like that. And you call it the espresso breath, espresso breath.
Jonny Miller: Espresso breath, yeah.
Where to Find Jonny Online
Lenny: So yeah, that’s a good metaphor there.
Jonny Miller: Yeah, yeah. So yeah, let’s do it. So again, kind of sit up straight, and this time you want to be pumping the breath from your lower belly and you pump the breath on the exhale. So I’ll demonstrate it briefly. It’s like breathe in.
Okay. So yeah, take a full breath in and begin.
And let go. And full breath in. And sigh on the exhale. I already feel a little bit tingly.
Lenny: I’m energized. Let’s do this. Go, go, go, go. That was great. Okay, look at that. We’re back to where we started with the full circle of energy. That was great.
Jonny Miller: Up and down.
Lenny: And then how long do you recommend doing that one for?
Jonny Miller: So it kind of depends on how activating you find it, but I usually find 30 breaths per round and then take a breath, have a long pause on the exhale, and then if you want to do another round or two.
Lenny: Amazing. And the cases where this might be helpful is maybe you’re about to give a big talk, I guess in a talk you both want energy and want calm, so that’s kind of complicated.
Jonny Miller: Especially if you are meetings early in the morning and you haven’t quite got going yet, you can do the espresso breath to begin with and that activates you. And then do some of the downshifting practices to kind of ground and stabilize that aliveness.
Lenny: Are there any other tactical breathing exercises that are worth doing real quick? I know we’ll get into some longer practices and deeper stuff, but is there anything else that would be helpful here?
Jonny Miller: No, I think we’ve covered the bases. I don’t want to overwhelm people too much.
Lenny: Just as a takeaway, there’s these two techniques. One to help you get more calm when you need to be calm in the moment. The other is to get energy. And then I guess are these things that you recommend doing ongoing to build this muscle in your body or are these mostly for you need this now in the moment and it’s not worth just doing a few times a day even when you’re fine?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, great question. So I like to recommend both a morning practice, particularly to build the muscle of just doing it and getting used to it. So maybe five minutes in the morning before you start work, before breakfast, something like that. And then you are more likely to remember that you have access to that in the moment because usually the challenge is that when someone is in that flustered state, remembering to do the practice is often the last thing that comes to mind. So by having a deliberate practice for at least 7 to 10 days and so that you get the hang of it, then it feels much more natural to do it when you’re feeling. That’s kind of like playing the game on hard mode when you are really stressed and anxious, that’s when you need it the most, but it’s also when you’re least likely to remember to do it.
Lenny: Awesome. Okay, so the first exercise to calm you down is essentially breathe in four seconds, hold it for four seconds, breathe out slowly for eight seconds and do that for about 30 seconds, is that right? Or for a minute?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, I’d say for at least a minute or two. We kind of did a shorter version. I’ll also add that the important thing is that the exhale is twice as long as the inhale. So if exhaling for eight is too long, you could do 3, 3, 6 or even 2, 2, 4 or even 5, 5, 10 depending on your lung capacity essentially and your CO2 tolerance.
Lenny: Okay, good to know. And then the espresso breath, when you need energy or you just kind of pump air out of your belly through your nose and you do that for how long would you recommend?
Jonny Miller: Two to three rounds of 30 pumps, yeah.
Lenny: And again, the reason this is effective and powerful is coming back to your original big insight that our state is driven by what our body is doing and our mind often explains what we’re feeling based on what our body’s doing. So that if you can change the state of your body and become less nervous in your body, your mind will be like, “All right, everything’s fine.”
Jonny Miller: Yeah. And maybe something that we haven’t touched on yet, but I think is important to add in is this idea of interoception or somatic awareness. And the reason I bring it in is because if you do this practice but you’re not really aware of your body and how you feel, then it’ll be less compelling to you. But if you’re kind of tuned into like sensations in your body, what’s going on, you’re more likely to notice the difference in the shifts.
Lenny: Great. So let’s get into that. That was something I definitely wanted to touch on here. This awesome acronym to help you with this process of interoception. So talk about what that is and then how to actually go about becoming better at being aware of what your body’s doing.
Jonny Miller: Yeah. So it’s this idea of interoception, which is known as our sixth sense, and basically it’s our ability to sense, track and feel our internal landscape. And I like to use the metaphor of a chef in the same way that you train your flavor palette for kind of sweet, spicy, umami, things like that. You can also train your interoceptive palette and become more aware of the internal sensations, whether that’s your breath, whether it’s tension, whether it’s moods and emotions, whether it’s the quality of your awareness, the quality of your thoughts. And the more kind of in tune with that you are, the more likely you are to notice the kind of early warning signs of something like anxiety. Because usually, certainly a panic attack doesn’t come out of nowhere. There will be a kind of cascade of subtle things that happen in your body that eventually result in anxiety. And so if you can catch those things early and kind of nip them in the bud and do one of these practices, then you can avoid the kind of 10 out of 10 worst case scenarios.
Lenny: Okay, awesome. So I know that there’s also specific things you recommend people pay attention to, to understand what their body is doing in this process of inter…
Jonny Miller: Interoception, yeah,
Lenny: Interra… Okay. What is it?
Jonny Miller: Interoception.
Lenny: Interoception.
Jonny Miller: As opposed to exteroception, which is awareness of all the external stimuli.
Lenny: Got it. I guess before we even get to that, so you mentioned that it’s another sense we have, and I think that’s a really important point that I think maybe people didn’t catch. So we have these five senses, obviously taste and smell and vision and touch. But you’re finding and research showed basically this is another sense people don’t really know we have.
Jonny Miller: Yeah, exactly. And it has been studies quite a lot, especially in the last decade or so. And there’s a number of interesting findings from the research that I found. One being that ADHD tends to correlate with low levels of interoception, as does if people have PTSD or trauma. Again, interoception is lowered. And I’d certainly say for myself, for the first 25 years of my life, I was fairly numb from the neck down. I was not very aware to what was happening in my body in real time. I was also reading a book recently called The Hour Between Dog and Wolf, which looked at Wall Street traders and they correlated higher degrees of interception with basically making more money and making better decisions. And I think the thesis was that by tuning into what their body was doing in certain moments, they could pick up on things more intuitive decision making essentially.
Lenny: So I think there’s a specific list of things that you recommend people pay attention to, their posture, their breath, things like that. What is that list and then how do we actually do this better?
Jonny Miller: Yeah. So I simplify this to APE, which basically is an acronym which stands for awareness, posture, and emotion. So to kind of go through each one by one. Awareness is, to give an example, I could narrow my awareness and become really focused and just you kind of tense up and it also is quite activating sometimes or you can relax and expand your awareness and be aware of the space above me, the space behind me, the space below me. And that is generally a calming thing. Posture is fairly self-explanatory. But again, our posture affects how we feel. You’re shifting there now. And then emotion, which I include somatic or body-based sensations which arise. So both kind of what is the overall mood and the flavor or the texture that I’m feeling. Like right now, maybe it’s excitement, maybe there’s some joy. I’m noticing there’s some heat in my belly probably from the breathing. Yeah, there’s a little bit of tightness in my lower back from working out yesterday. So just sense kind of mapping that landscape of sensation. And for most people it’s almost like it’s like a [inaudible 00:30:22]. You have those maps of [inaudible 00:30:25] and for a lot of people there’s just these big kind blind spots in their body.
Lenny: And the advice here is, so there’s this acronym APE and the advice is think about these three things when you’re feeling something that you may not, basically something’s going on slash just often come back to this. I imagine just whenever you can think of, “Oh, APE: awareness, posture, emotion.” Is that how to use this?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, exactly. So again, it can be something that you do before you start your day, maybe with a cup of tea. I like to drink tea and just do a body scan essentially and just check each of those three areas. And it’s really valuable, particularly if you are having racing thoughts or something doesn’t feel quite right. Instead of just tackling the problem on the level of the mind dropping down into the body and bringing that into the picture as well, I find to be really helpful.
Lenny: Basically, as often as you can. And generally when things are feeling all off, just remember APE, where’s my awareness? How’s my posture? And then what am I feeling? Am I feeling sad? Am I feeling happy, excited, angry? Things like that. I think you also talk about breath, like you have a list you wrote about this of other things that you might want to pay attention to. Actually finding paying attention to what my breath is doing is really powerful too. So I’m going to try a BAPE version of this or I’m going to try to think about where’s my breath coming from, what am I feeling there?
Jonny Miller: Yeah. So the breath and sensations are two other ones that are really helpful. The breath in particular, often people will… There’s an idea of email apnea when people are checking their emails, they will, without noticing it, start to hold their breath, which is generally a very activating thing to do. Or as I mentioned earlier, if your breath is through the mouth and shallow and into the upper chest, that will also be very activating versus is your breath through the nose? Is it kind of into the belly and into the sides of the rib cage and does it feel easeful? Basically, breathing without tension is ideal.
Lenny: What I think about using this practice is if I were sitting in a meeting and just not feeling amazingly confident, I just come back to this acronym, BAPE or APE, whichever one you want to choose, just like how am I feeling right now? Oh wow, my whole stomach is clenched. I’m maybe nervous about what might happen or I’m not breathing at all, or my posture is really bad. So I think in a meeting would be really helpful Here, maybe you’re about to get on a zoom or an important call or something like that. Maybe a one-on-one. Is there anything else, any other moments that kind of triggers for people of like, “Oh, I should really be aware of what’s happening right now. Let me do an APE exercise.”
Jonny Miller: Yeah, well, just to kind of piggyback on what you just said, if you are about to jump on a meeting and you’re noticing that your stomach is clenched, that’s actually really useful data to be like, “Why is this happening?” Is it your intuition kind of saying that maybe you shouldn’t do this deal with someone or maybe something is off and so it’s a sign to explore that more. Or it could be that you’ve been triggered by something or something that someone said and you’ve only just realized it and then that’s again, more information or something that you can reflect on or go into.
Lenny: Is there anything in your life recently that is an example of this where you’re feeling unsure and maybe you realize, “Oh, here’s what my body’s doing, maybe I should pay more attention to this.”
Jonny Miller: Actually, last week I did a podcast conversation, so I have a podcast myself, and I got off the call and I remember I felt or got off the podcast and I felt pretty exhausted and I felt like there was this kind of tension in my chest. And again, my breath was kind of all over the place and I realized that I had very much over committed myself for that week. I’d scheduled back to back podcast interviews. The podcast wasn’t even the priority for what I’m focusing on in this quarter, so I then made the decision to just push back all my episodes until the summer basically.
Lenny: I love that example. I know that feeling very well.
Jonny Miller: I’m sure.
Lenny: When you wrote about this idea of interoception, you connected it to burnout, and I think you talked about how this is one of the best tools to avoid burnout. Is that right? Am I remembering that right? And if so, how do you think about this burnout and avoiding burnout in general, something a lot of people experience?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, so I have this idea that I call the feather brick dump truck phenomenon. And basically what that means is when we are showing early signs of burnout, our body will give us feedback usually in subtle ways in the beginning. So the feather might be waking up in the morning and feeling a little bit tired, maybe a little bit exhausted. The brick, maybe you ignore that or you don’t notice it, and then three or four weeks later you have a fight with someone or an argument or you just feel frustrated and terrible and you lose your cool. And then maybe the dump truck is a month later or even a year later, there’s a full-blown health crisis, or you develop type two diabetes or there’s a whole range of things, or maybe you get fired. There’s a bunch of different things that can happen, but normally depending on how attuned or depending on someone’s interoceptive capacity, ideally, you want to notice when it’s the feather and then make adjustments or shift then and not have to wait until you experience the full-blown pain of the dump truck, which unfortunately is what happens to a lot of people, especially when they experience burnout for the first time.
Lenny: This is such an important point and such a good way of thinking about it. It reminds me of Andy Johns and the episode we had there of just how long and willing to the episode there of just how all these little things came up along the way and then eventually just became incredibly unsustainable to live the life that he was living.
What are some examples of this feather? So your advice here is just pay attention to these little signs that you’re not living a sustainable life right now. What are some examples of these kind of feathery signs of like maybe I need to change something?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, so I’ll tie this in with a concept that I call emotional debt, which is basically when our nervous system experiences stress, there’s known as a mobilization cycle, and if that cycle isn’t completed or we don’t get to downshift or relax on the other side, that gets stored in the body as allostatic load, which I call emotional debt. And over time, that creates fragility in the nervous system. And so what that fragility can look like is anything from being impacted by small things in a kind of disproportionate way. So noticing that you are more reactive than normal, maybe you’re a little bit more snappy, maybe you get frustrated by little things, maybe your sleep isn’t as good, maybe you wake up not feeling fully rested. Maybe relationships are often, especially intimate relationships are usually a place that this shows up or relationships at work. So those are the classic early warning signs. And then as that emotional debt threshold increases in the same way that say with technical debt, if you’re building a product in the beginning, it’s fine, and in fact it’s even necessary in the beginning. It’s great that our body can buffer the stress response because it allows us to function. But if we don’t pay off that technical debt or emotional debt, then over time it accumulates and it can also come out through health crises, health challenges. It just gets basically progressively worse until that debt is paid off.
Lenny: I feel like a lot of people listening are like, “Yes, I know exactly what you mean.” How does one notice that you’re building emotional debt and then how do you start to release this debt and pay off this debt?
Jonny Miller: What I’ve seen with some of my founder clients and in the research that we did where we interviewed 260 leaders, what can often happen is that emotional debt will increase and increase and increase until it gets to a point where we are well outside what’s known as a window of tolerance. And at that point there’s like a crash. It’s almost like the fuse switch blows and there’s exhaustion. Maybe there’s complete inability to get up off the couch. And for some people, people with large nervous system capacity, they can keep going for five years, maybe 10 years, and they can keep building this up, and it becomes normalized to live in a way where you are always on and never really relaxing or coming down. Or one really key sign actually is if you are not able to naturally downshift or down regulate your nervous system at the end of the day without something like wine or CBD or some kind of external substance, that’s a sign that you kind of reached a certain threshold of emotional debt.
Lenny: And then how does one start to pay off this debt if you’ve spent years just working way too hard, you’ve had a relationship that just isn’t working great, I don’t know. I imagine most people go to therapy and just talk through all these things and try to work through the challenges. What do you recommend if you’re just like, “Man, I feel like I have this, what should I do?”
Jonny Miller: Yeah, well, I mean that’s a big question. I’ll probably get some pushback for this, but I’m not a big fan of talk therapy alone or at least therapy that doesn’t have a somatic or body-based component. And from my understanding of the nervous system and how we store this stress, just talking about things and keeping things on the level of the intellect doesn’t actually address the root of the challenge. What we need to do is create a certain sense of safety to kind of go into those buffered emotional responses and feel them all the way through and allow that mobilization reflex to complete.
And so to kind of give a personal example, when I was living in Bali, I did several hundred breathwork journeys where you breathe in a certain way to get into an altered state, and then in that place, these memories would arise of these things that happened 5, 10 years ago. And my body, it would either move a certain way or the anger would come through. Sometimes there would be sadness or grief. Often there’s a lot of stored emotion that’s held in our body that just needs permission to kind of be felt through and be released. And so for me, it was a journey of coming into right relationship with my anger and my grief, and honestly my shame as well, giving myself permission to feel this gunk that had been stored in my pelvis.
So I’m not saying you have to go to Bali and do 200 breathwork journeys. That’s definitely not… I mean, that’s a path. But first it begins with, as I said, cultivating interoception and even being aware that there is this tension, there are these things in your body. Secondly, having the practices of self-regulation so that if these things come up, you don’t get overwhelmed. You’re able to downshift and ground. And then thirdly, it’s the practice of what I call emotional fluidity, which is basically creating the conditions of welcoming the full spectrum of emotions as they arise. And often it’s very helpful to have a guide or a somatic practitioner, I like somatic experiencing, hakomi, the two modalities I’m a big fan of. And yeah, that’s the journey and a process and it depends how many years you’ve been operating in a slightly numbed way, and it’s different for everyone. But it begins by tuning into and listening to the body and then having honestly curiosity about what is there and just following that curiosity and the body starts to show you what is ready to be seen.
Lenny: I love that it always comes back to the original place we started which is that the way we feel is a very bottom up body-based system, it’s not we feel something and our body gets nervous. It’s our body gets nervous, and they’re like, “Oh, here’s why I’m nervous.” And your advice is just focus a lot on helping your body release the stuff that you’ve built up this debt. And then also just when you’re nervous in the moment, focus on getting your body to a state versus trying to convince your mind now everything’s going to be okay.
Jonny Miller: Exactly.
Lenny: And specifically on the therapy route, just to touch on that, so your advice there is if you were to work with a therapist and you feel a lot of this stuff that we’re talking about is focused on a somatic oriented therapy where it’s body oriented, not just thinking about it and talking through stuff, it’s actually convincing your body, “Here’s a way to helping your body release this debt, essentially.”
Jonny Miller: Yeah. I mean, you can understand in precise detail about whatever the challenge was from 5, 10 and 15 years ago, but if you’re unable to connect it to the correlating sensations in the body… Usually if say, I don’t know, if I was to imagine someone shouted at me yesterday and I think about that, there’s usually a correlating kind of sematic sensation. The neuroscientist Damasio calls it a somatic marker. So by tracking the somatic markers and then either on your own just kind of following that sensation and allowing whatever emotion was present at the time to complete that is the way that we kind of slowly pay off that emotional debt by one process at a time.
Lenny: So maybe coming back to this question of say someone is listening and wondering, am I building emotional debt? Am I ignoring things that are these feathers? What are signs and just, I don’t know, examples of emotional debt being built up of this trauma, whatever you want to call it, being built up in the body? I don’t know, is it just like anytime you feel really nervous, that’s emotional debt? Is it anytime you push something down that you are pretty sure you should deal with in the moment, that’s emotional debt? What are just some examples of what that feels like and looks like?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, so it’s typically different forms of nervous system dysregulation and that shows up as it could be someone’s breathing pattern if they’re constantly in this sympathetic or hypervigilant state, if they’re always tracking for things, looking for the worst case scenario. Another common one, and this is particularly true in the tech sector, is being very much in the head and living in the thoughts and the mind the entire time. And there’s a form of disassociation that happens as a kind of protection mechanism essentially because it’s uncomfortable to be with the sensations in the body. And because our society tends to reward people for solving problems and being in their mind, that is a pattern that continues for many, many years or even decades.
Other ones are, I think the most obvious one for people is emotional reactivity, where your response to a certain situation is disproportionate to what’s happened. So for example, if you said something to me of that doesn’t make any sense, and I was like, I freeze maybe… And this is another important point that most people have two versions of reactivity. Some people will freeze, withdraw, shut down and disconnect, and other people will become more aggressive, become bigger and attack and fight back. And knowing which way you tend to orient, for me, it’s usually shrink and freeze and shut down, knowing what your pattern is and also knowing what the sensations are when this happens, it’s really helpful for you to be like, “Oh, that thing’s happening.” My priority now is to downshift and kind of find a sense of safety basically in the body and then interact, then make the decision, then have the conversation. Because if you can keep going from that place of reactivity, nothing good happens from that place. No great decisions were made from that place. So again, that’s a place where having the interoceptive awareness to know, “Oh, this is what’s going on.” Being able to then downshift your system, kind of access a sense of, “Oh, I’m okay, actually this isn’t so bad.” And then moving on from there is a profoundly practical and just useful skill.
Lenny: Kind of along these same lines, you wrote somewhere this idea that you have a big competitive advantage if you feel the feels is the way you described it. Does that ring a bell? And if so, what can you share around that, just why this is so powerful, especially in the workplace?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, so I think I wrote about this in one of the Every essays. I think the title was The Best Decision-Making Is Emotional. And I basically wanted to kind of poke at the phrase, I think I saw someone on Twitter say, “Fact over feelings, like don’t let emotions ruin good decision making.” And yeah, there’s so much that I can say about this. But basically there was a landmark study by this guy, Damasio, this kind of famous neuroscientist, and he studied a patient called Elliot. And Elliot had a tumor in his brain that was removed and it basically meant that he was unable to feel emotions. So his entire emotional capacity was removed. And Elliot went from being a successful married businessman to divorced, broke and unable to choose what he could have for lunch. He was unable to make the most basic life decisions, and it’s because he didn’t have access to that emotional sense in his brain.
And so our brain is like a prediction making machine, and as I mentioned earlier, there’s this highway of sensory data that’s coming up through the body. And if we don’t listen to that when we are making decisions, then we’re losing out on a lot of information. And what tends to happen, I see this in clients that I work with, is if they are avoiding feeling a certain way, let’s say, that they don’t enjoy feeling conflict or anger, then they will make decisions subconsciously to avoid feeling that way. And it becomes a huge bias and a huge problem because people make decisions because they’re afraid of feeling a certain way. And if you are on the other hand able to just welcome and be with whatever emotions would arise on the other side of a decision, you’re able to decide clearly instead of being skewed one way or the other.
Lenny: Easier said than done.
Jonny Miller: Yeah.
Lenny: Do you find there’s ever a downside to being too in touch with what you’re feeling? I actually not a feeler of what I’m feeling kind of person. I’m pretty stable, partly because I’m not super in tune with what I’m feeling a lot of times, and maybe this is a huge problem that I need to deal with. But I don’t know, it’s worked out okay so far. I guess, do you ever find that sometimes it’s okay, sometimes you don’t need to know exactly every moment anything that’s hurting you or causing you pain?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, it’s a good question. And some people do have a very high interoceptive capacity, and that can be overwhelming. In which case I would recommend focusing on the breathing practices to build that capacity to downshift, so you’re able to just function. And there’s definitely people who are overwhelmed by the stimuli of day-to-day life being out in traffic, like they’re very easily overwhelmed. And for those people working on increasing nervous system capacity to kind of hold that amount of stress, maybe it’s through sauna and cold plunge, maybe it’s through gentle titration of stresses and then downshifting, that’s actually really valuable.
I’d also say that the ability to function well, this applies to a lot of high functioning people, which is probably honestly a lot of your audience. It’s very helpful in the moment to, let’s say something comes up, you want to be able to buffer intense emotions and say, get through the meeting, get through whatever it is. It’s a very helpful skill. But if you don’t, then give yourself spaciousness afterwards to downshift and allow yourself to feel whatever was brought up by that experience, you are going to be adding to this emotional debt over time. And as I mentioned, some people, it might be a year before there’s some kind of breakdown, burnout. Other people, it might be longer. And usually it’s more unfortunate in the longer case because it creates a long-term health crisis and then lower amount of money or time is able to repair the damage that’s been done, which can be really tragic.
Lenny: My chat with Andy Johns is a great example of that happening.
Jonny Miller: Yeah. And Andy’s a superb example, and I love his vulnerability and honesty in what he’s been through.
Lenny: Yeah, I think if you’re interested in this topic, definitely watch that episode. Another exercise that you talk a lot about is this idea, it’s called NSDR, I think. Talk about that and when that might be useful, how to go about using this tool.
Jonny Miller: Yeah, so NSDR was a practice coined by Andrew Huberman, who you mentioned earlier. And it basically, it’s a more scientific lens on the practice of yoga nidra, which is an ancient yoga practice. But I am a huge fan of it, and I do it myself most days for 15 to 20 minutes. Basically what it looks like is you lie down, put on an eye mask or a blindfold, and you listen to a guided audio. I’ve recorded some myself, so I can share these in the show note links.
Lenny: Your voice would be so good for these, by the way. You found your calling.
Jonny Miller: Nice, yeah. It’s really fun for me to do. But basically what it involves is a guided body scan. So this is also a great way to practice interoception. It’s something that I didn’t mention earlier was that when there’s cortisol present in our body, the cortisol basically acts as a numbing agent, so it’s much harder to kind of tune into those sensations. But using this, I think it’s a 14-minute guided NSDR practice, you’re basically lying down, there’s a guided body scan, there’s relaxing music in the background. And by the end of it, you feel like you’ve had a two-hour nap. It feels incredible.
And particularly for people who myself tend to get tired in the afternoons, if you space this out, usually between 1 and 3:00 PM for me, that will give you a second wind in the afternoon and it’ll mean you won’t end the day collapse on the sofa. So I think it’s great for improving interoception, it’s good for allowing your body to downshift and relax instead of being in that kind of high tone sympathetic state all throughout the day. So it gives your body a break, and it just feels really good. Honestly, it’s probably my most played practice of everything that I teach, just people listen to it every day. So I’ll share that in the show notes as well.
Lenny: And I imagine if you feel like you’ve built this emotional debt, this would be a really good exercise to start to do, is that right?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, it is fantastic. I mean, there’s some people who struggle with having enough energy to kind of get out of bed and function. But again, I imagine listeners to your show, people that live in Silicon Valley, their challenge is the downshifting without external substances. And so NSDR is a really great way of strengthening that ventral vagal tone, which is our body’s capacity to go from on kind of go, go, go to then relaxing. There’s a quote from Kevin Kelly that I interviewed recently, and he said, “If you have a great work ethic that needs to be matched with a great rest ethic.” And I think that kind of piece of actually training our capacity to downshift after stress is just completely missing from most people’s playbooks.
Lenny: I think with a lot of the sort of advice, if you listen, Tim Ferriss and Huberman and everyone’s got this stuff you should be doing every day list and it ends up being so long and there’s so many things to do, cold plunge, sauna. What is it that you practice or come back to slash what would you recommend people try to do daily that is most impactful of all this stuff we’ve talked about?
Jonny Miller: First experiment with a bunch of different practices and see which you enjoy and notice how you feel before and then how you feel afterwards. That’s kind of the key because once you know that it feels good, you’re not going to have to force yourself or motivate yourself to do it. You’ll just do it naturally because you know you’ll feel great afterwards. I would recommend starting really simple, so starting with the 4, 4, 8 breathing or humming, doing that in the morning for just two minutes, two minutes in the beginning is enough. And I would also recommend listening to the NSDR practice at least once or twice. If you work from home, it’s pretty easy after a lunch break, something like that could also be in the evening when you get home as well. Some people use it to help fall asleep.
And then the final thing that I would recommend is if you have the resources and you have access, finding a somatic practitioner or somatic therapist is so [inaudible 00:57:03]. I mean, I emerged a completely different human on the other side of the 200 breathwork journeys. I have a different experience of life basically released so much time. Even my voice sounds different. If you listen to the podcast episodes I recorded four or five years ago, my voice is higher pitched. It just sounds different. It has a different resonant quality to it.
Lenny: Wow. Okay, awesome. So you’ve kind of summarized, I was going to try to summarize all the advice you’ve given, but if you were to do the bare minimum next steps based on this advice, try this 4, 4, 8/3, 3, 6/2, 2, 4. Does 2, 2, 4 work too if you just go real fast I guess?
Jonny Miller: Yeah.
Lenny: Yeah.
Jonny Miller: Okay.
Lenny: Okay, perfect. Okay, so do that for a couple mornings. See how that does try this NSDR practice. We’ll link to a recording of how to do that and then was there something else you recommended? Oh, somatic worker, basically maybe a therapist, maybe not someone that helps you with your body.
Jonny Miller: Yeah, and I’d add in the eight practice for even 15 seconds before the breathing in the morning and after, just so that you notice the difference. And if you do the NSDR, that is basically a 15-minute interoception practice as well. So you’re kind of getting two birds with one stone with that practice.
Lenny: What’s your perspective on meditation? Does that fit into this? Do you find the NSDR replaces the need for meditation?
Jonny Miller: That is a big topic. I am an avid meditator as what I’ve done many 10 day silent retreats. I was in a dark room for 10 days.
Lenny: Wow.
Jonny Miller: With meditation, I think it really depends on what you are training. It’s like saying what’s your opinion on exercise? Well, are you training mobility or stamina or strength? It’s the same with meditation. You could be training loving kindness. You could be training your focus and attention. You could be training spacious awareness. So I’m a big fan of embodied meditation practices. So this is often the classic vipassana body scan is a good example. Again, I mean that’s basically interoceptive practice where you are just moving your attention through different parts of your body over and over and over again for days on end.
In the case of vipassana retreat, meditation is helpful for the specific skill of increasing the psychological space between a stimulus and your response. So if you have some degree of meditation practice instead of getting wrapped up in a certain emotion or we’re even believing a certain thought pattern, there’s usually an ability to kind of step back a little bit and see if what it’s, so there definitely is a place for meditation. But my viewpoint is that we’ve kind of over-indexed for mindfulness and meditation in over the last 20 years. There’s so many apps, there’s so there’s much talk about it and we’ve completely forgotten the body-based approaches. So I’m not saying don’t meditate. I think meditation for sure has its place, especially if your goal is more of the traditional waking up and seeing through the nature of the self, that’s a different kind of path in my opinion. But if you’re looking to function more effectively and be more in tune with your body, then there’s a whole different category of practices in this bottom up variety that we’ve touched on today.
Lenny: On the topic of bottom up, I imagine you’re a big fan of this book that everyone always talks about, The Body Keeps Score, I think it’s called. Would you recommend that book? Is it connected in a large part to the stuff you talk about? What do you think of that book specifically? Because I hear about it all with him.
Jonny Miller: Yeah, it’s a good book. It’s by Bessal van der Kolk and there’s another writer I think Peter Levine says, “The issues are in the tissues.” Is basically the concept. And this is the idea that we have these incomplete mobilization reflexes that are stored in our body and often held as tension. It’s not strictly true to say that the trauma is in the body. It is actually a cortical map in the brain which kind of tracks these things. But for kind of practical purposes, it looks and feels as if there is stored grief in my right hip or anger in my solar plexus, that’s the experience that we have. And the more that you become aware of these sensations and start to develop emotional fluidity essentially, the more that tension is released and the less reactive you become and the more emotional debt you pay off. So I think The Body Keeps The Score, I think a more accurate way would be the body is the scorecard in a way. I think that’s kind a slight reframe. And if you’re interested in this, the work of Peter Levine, Waking the Tiger is the seminal book on this mobilization reflex stuff that I’m describing.
Lenny: I never need that part of it. And basically it’s actually kept in the brain, but it comes across as somewhere in the body.
Jonny Miller: Yeah, exactly.
Lenny: Fascinating. I want to spend a little time on a new segment that we have in this podcast that I call Contrarian Corner. So let’s visit Contrarian Corner, I feel like you’ll have something interesting here. So the question is there something that you have a very contrarian opinion about, something that you believe that a lot of other people really don’t believe?
Jonny Miller: We’ve already touched on I’m not a big fan of talk based meditation, which will probably get me some comments I would imagine. I’d say the other one that’s worth mentioning is I think that we vastly underestimate the impact of burnout, particularly from a bottom line perspective. There was a research report that I did a couple of years ago where we interviewed these leaders and they’d all experienced burnout of some degree. And we said, if you were to estimate how much this costs your startup or business, what would you say? And the median response was a hundred thousand dollars, which I imagine is more than most people would think.
And most people aren’t actively investing in burnout insurance. Like it’s not something that’s on many people’s radar besides meditation practices and things like that. And I think part of the reason that the cost is higher is because there are these second and third order consequences of talent attrition, of opportunity costs, lost productivity, you lose great leaders, make shitty decisions in the run up to the burnout itself. There’s also this idea of emotional contagion, which there’s some research from Wharton I believe, and they show that the leader or the CEO has a disproportionate impact or their emotional state has a disproportionate impact on the people in their team. So something I’d like to say is the nervous system of an organization is a reflection of the nervous system of the CEO. And so I think that’s just something which I would like to see talked about more.
Lenny: Just on this idea of burnout, I don’t think you’re saying don’t work really hard If you want to work really hard, it’s that you need to maintain your body and mind and nervous system if you’re working insanely hard. If you’re working long hours, feel free, but just know there’s debt you’re building up and you need to be doing things to pay off that debt as you’re doing that.
Jonny Miller: Precisely. It is very much like building technical debt in the early days of a startup. It’s worth doing, but just do it intentionally. Know that you’re doing that and that. So let’s say you work really hard for eight months, you give yourself a month or two off to really downshift. And it’s also really worth building that nervous system capacity. It’s great to be able to push it really hard and focus and then combine it with that rest ethic as well. So do NSDRs, kind of find a way to downshift so that way of working can be sustainable.
Lenny: Jonny, we reached our very exciting lightning round. Are you ready?
Jonny Miller: Let’s do it.
Lenny: First question, what are two or three books that you’ve recommended most to other people?
Jonny Miller: I actually had a sense this question was coming and I have the books with me here. The first book is Constellations by David White. This is the book that I’ve gifted most to friends, I think more than any other book. And he basically has 52 definitions of words like ambition is I think the first word. And his writing, it just blows me away. I open this to a random page, read the definition, and it’s probably affected me more than any other book. So that’s one that I love. 15 Commitments of Conscious Leadership, which is I imagine has come up before in your podcast. This is by Jim Dethmer and Diana Chapman. They have the Conscious Leadership Group. And this is basically, in my opinion, it’s the best leadership book that I’ve come across and it combines practicality with a lot of great theory. So this is awesome. And then finally, this is a bit out there, but Recapture the Rapture by Jamie Wheal, big fan of Jamie’s work, Jamie’s writing. This is kind of three books in one. The beginning is addressing the meta-crisis and a lot of the craziness that we’re seeing in the world. The second chapter is very related to what we’ve been talking about, he calls it Hedonic Engineering and it’s basically practices for shifting your state of consciousness. And the third is Ethical Cult Building, which I’ll leave that there. [inaudible 01:06:22].
Lenny: Do you have a favorite recent movie or TV show you really enjoyed?
Jonny Miller: My wife and I love animations and we saw Kubo and the Two Strings recently, which was fantastic. Just so, so great. That and also Wolf Walkers, which was an Apple TV series. Yeah, those have been my two favorite movies I’ve seen recently.
Lenny: If you like animated content, check out the Scavengers Reign on HBO. I’ve mentioned it on this podcast before, but it’s incredible. It’s a TV show on HBO. So I usually ask, do you have a favorite question you like to ask candidates you’re interviewing? But I know you coach people, so to kind of turn this question a little bit around, do you have a favorite question you like to ask executive coaching clients that you work with?
Jonny Miller: I stole this question from a guy Jerry Colonna who’s here in Boulder, and the question is amazing. It is so good. It’s basically, how are you complicit in creating the conditions that you say you don’t want? And so the word complicit there is key because it’s not saying in what ways is it your fault, but it’s like in what ways were you complicit in creating the conditions for anxiety, for building up emotional debt? And just the question kind of opens up the door to ways in which you are an active participant in creating these challenges in your life. And it’s a really rich journal question or a question to explore with a friend, co-founder colleague.
Lenny: I remember him sharing that on the Tim Ferriss podcast many years ago and it stuck with me and I often think of it, but I never am complicit of anything that goes wrong. It’s never my fault. He has nothing on me. Just kidding.
Jonny Miller: Excellent.
Lenny: Do you have a favorite product you’ve recently discovered that you really like?
Jonny Miller: One is these blue blocking glasses. These are raw optics, blue blocker glasses. They block out a hundred percent of blue light and they are a lifesaver if I’m ever going out of the house basically after dark, I’ll wear these to drive. I’ll wear these to even dinners with friends sometimes. And it basically means that I’m able to then sleep well that evening. So that’s one.
And then the other thing I’ll briefly share, this came through the other day, you mentioned the vagus nerve earlier and that device, I have three devices here that are all vagus nerve stimulation devices. This one is called Neuro Sim. This one I believe is Pulsetto, and I think this is a Apollo Strap. I haven’t used them that much yet, but they basically work by sending low level electrical stimulation directly to your vagus nerve. So this clips on your ear because the vagus nerve goes through the right side of the neck. Same with Pulsetto. And I’m really curious to compare the effect of these versus say breathwork, humming, the other body-based practices. Obviously, you can do both at the same time, but I am just interested in playing. So I wouldn’t recommend them yet, but I think it’s interesting that they exist.
Lenny: How cool would that be? We just put these things on, we don’t have to do anything else. We just get up, slap on our device and life is amazing. Don’t have to meditate, don’t have to breathe in a different way. I’m going to need to do this while I’m on the podcast just wear all these devices, see how that goes. Awesome. Well, I guess somehow report back to us how these go because that feels really great. Next question, do you have a favorite life motto that you often come back to share with friends, either in work or in life?
Jonny Miller: State over story would be one which we’ve touched on.
Lenny: State over story.
Jonny Miller: And then I think the other one, which I think about often is I like to say, “Make generous assumptions.” And by that I mean in any situation, what is the most generous story that I can tell of this person, of this situation? Not kind of naively fabricating something, but usually there’s a spectrum of I can assume that they’re a bad person and they did this thing out of spite, or maybe they had a bad day, maybe they have a lot of emotional debt. There’s there’s many stories that can be told. And I usually try to have a practice of telling the most generous story that I can.
Lenny: I like that a lot. Another way of describing that is just assume good intentions, which I often think about.
Jonny Miller: Exactly.
Lenny: Final question. You seem extremely calm always, and very centered and stable. What still gets you rilled up and unsettled, and what do you do when that happens?
Jonny Miller: Well, I was nervous before this podcast, so I did some breathing practices and some stretching and some humming before jumping on here. I still at times notice ways in which I’m conflict avoidant. I’ve been working on it actively for a while, but there’s a part of me that can sometimes avoid conflict. And so I’ve actually noticed how there’s a relationship between that and having a healthy relationship to anger. So basically giving myself permission to express frustration, not at someone, but just allow it to be there. And then from that place set better boundaries with my time with what I’m doing, saying no to certain things. I think that’s the practice that’s most alive for me right now.
Lenny: Jonny, you are awesome. Two final questions. Where can folks find you online and explore the things that you offer? I think you teach a course, whatever else you offer, talk about that and then how can listeners be useful to you?
Jonny Miller: Yeah, well, this has been so much fun. I am very active on Twitter or X. My handle is Jonny Miller. It’s J-O-N-N-Y-M-1-L-L-E-R. And yeah, if this was interesting or listeners would like to dive deeper, I teach a course. Our next cohort is running in the spring, the end of March. Applications are now open, and the website is nsmastery.com/lenny. I’ve created a custom page and there’s a $250 juicy discount for listeners if they want to sign up.
Lenny: I got to sign up for this myself. I didn’t know you’re going to do that. That’s awesome. And NS Mastery stands for Nervous System Mastery.
Jonny Miller: Exactly.
Lenny: Amazing. Anything else? And then the second question of how listeners can be useful to you.
Jonny Miller: Well, firstly, if any of this resonates, I’d love to hear from you on Twitter or email me as well. I can pass over my email and I would just love it if you experiment with this stuff. I love this idea of just being a scientist of life. So if anything that we’ve talked about resonates or any of the practices you want to try, just go out and try it and see how it feels and then tell me about it. That would be the greatest gift I think.
Lenny: And the best way to tell you about it is tweet at you or is there something else?
Jonny Miller: Tweet at me or my email is jonny@curioushumans.com. So feel free to email me as well.
Lenny: All right, I’m going to use all these things. Jonny, thank you so much for being here. You’re awesome. I am excited for the show notes we’re going to have to give people actual tools to use to become less anxious and nervous in their work and life. Thank you again for being here.
Jonny Miller: Amazing. Thanks so much, Lenny. This was super fun.
Lenny: Same for me. Bye everyone.
Thank you so much for listening. If you found this valuable, you can subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast app. Also, please consider giving us a rating or leaving a review as that really helps other listeners find the podcast. You can find all past episodes or learn more about the show at lennyspodcast.com. See you in the next episode.
Glossary
| English | 中文 |
|---|---|
| afferent neurons | 传入神经元 |
| allostatic load | 稳态负荷 |
| alternate nostril breathing | 交替鼻孔呼吸 |
| Andrew Huberman | 人名保留原文 |
| Andy Johns | 人名保留原文 |
| APE (Awareness, Posture, Emotions) | APE(觉察、姿势、情绪) |
| Apollo Strap | Apollo Strap(设备名,保留原文) |
| assume good intentions | 假设善意 |
| bellows breath | 风箱呼吸 |
| Bessel van der Kolk | 人名保留原文 |
| blue blocking glasses | 蓝光阻隔眼镜 |
| body scan | 身体扫描 |
| breath of fire | 火的呼吸 |
| breathwork | 呼吸法 |
| burnout | 倦怠 |
| confabulate | 虚构(心理学用语) |
| conflict avoidant | 回避冲突 |
| cortisol | 皮质醇 |
| Damasio | Damasio(神经科学家,人名保留原文) |
| David Whyte | 人名保留原文 |
| Diana Chapman | 人名保留原文 |
| disassociation | 解离 |
| efferent neurons | 传出神经元 |
| Elliot | Elliot(Damasio 的研究患者,人名保留原文) |
| email apnea | 邮件呼吸暂停 |
| emotional contagion | 情绪传染 |
| emotional debt | 情绪债务 |
| emotional fluidity | 情绪流动性 |
| endocrine system | 内分泌系统 |
| espresso breath | 浓缩咖啡呼吸 |
| Every | Every(出版物名,保留原文) |
| feather brick dump truck phenomenon | 羽毛、砖块、自卸卡车现象 |
| generous assumptions | 慷慨的假设 |
| Hakomi | Hakomi(疗法名,保留原文) |
| insular cortex | 岛叶皮层 |
| interoception | 内感受 |
| interoceptive awareness | 内感受觉知 |
| interoceptive capacity | 内感受能力 |
| Jamie Wheal | 人名保留原文 |
| Jerry Colonna | 人名保留原文 |
| Jim Dethmer | 人名保留原文 |
| Jonny Miller | 人名保留原文 |
| Kevin Kelly | 人名保留原文 |
| Lenny | 人名保留原文 |
| mobilization cycle | 动员周期 |
| Nervous Systems Mastery | 神经系统精通(课程名,保留原文) |
| Neuro Sim | Neuro Sim(设备名,保留原文) |
| nitric oxide | 一氧化氮 |
| non-sleep deep rest | 非睡眠深度休息 |
| parasympathetic nervous system | 副交感神经 |
| Peter Levine | 人名保留原文 |
| physiological sigh | 生理性叹息 |
| Pulsetto | Pulsetto(设备名,保留原文) |
| Raw Optics | Raw Optics(品牌名,保留原文) |
| somatic | 躯体的 |
| somatic experiencing | 躯体体验疗法 |
| somatic marker | 躯体标记 |
| state over story | 状态优先于叙事 |
| sympathetic nervous system | 交感神经 |
| Techstars | Techstars(孵化器名,保留原文) |
| TEDx talk | TEDx演讲 |
| Tim Ferriss | 人名保留原文 |
| vagus nerve | 迷走神经 |
| vagus nerve stimulation device | 迷走神经刺激设备 |
| vasodilator | 血管扩张剂 |
| ventral vagal tone | 腹侧迷走神经张力 |
| vipassana | 内观 |
| Wim Hof | 人名保留原文 |
| window of tolerance | 容忍窗口 |
| yoga nidra | 瑜伽休息术 |
Reformatted by reformat_english.py
管理紧张、焦虑与倦怠 | Jonny Miller(Nervous Systems Mastery)
管理紧张、焦虑与倦怠 | Jonny Miller(Nervous Systems Mastery)
访谈记录
Jonny Miller: 我有一个想法,称之为”羽毛、砖块、自卸卡车”现象。它的基本含义是:当我们出现倦怠的早期征兆时,身体通常会以微妙的方式给出反馈。一开始可能是”羽毛”——比如早上醒来觉得有点疲惫,也许有点精疲力竭。如果你忽略了这个信号或者没有注意到,三四周后可能就会迎来”砖块”——你跟某人吵架或争执,或者你感到沮丧、难受、情绪失控。然后也许一个月后,甚至一年后,“自卸卡车”就来了——一场全面的健康危机,或者你患上了二型糖尿病,或者其他各种问题,又或者你被解雇了。理想情况下,你希望在”羽毛”阶段就有所察觉,然后做出调整或转变,而不必等到承受”自卸卡车”那样的全面痛苦——不幸的是,很多人都是这样,尤其是第一次经历倦怠的时候。
嘉宾介绍
Lenny: 今天的嘉宾是 Jonny Miller。Jonny 为科技从业者开设课程并提供一对一辅导,帮助他们掌握他称之为”神经系统精通”的方法——本质上是一套培养平静、提升韧性、增强活力的工具和技术。如果你能更善于应对压力情境、避免倦怠,并在会议和大型演讲中更加自信,这就会成为一项超能力,在事业和生活中都是巨大的优势。大约一年前我读了 Jonny 的一篇文章,它彻底改变了我对紧张和压力的认知方式,至今我仍在运用他的许多心得。
在这次对话中,我们深入探讨了 Jonny 的核心洞见。我们谈到为什么在压力情境下保持冷静的最佳方式是关注身体状态而非心理状态;如何通过呼吸改变身体状态来创造平静与自信。Jonny 分享了一些非常具体的呼吸练习,既有用于创造平静的,也有用于激发能量的,我们甚至在播客中实际尝试了一下。我们还讨论了如何辨别倦怠的早期征兆、如何释放你可能感受到的情绪债务,以及为什么”感受你的感受”在商业中会带来竞争优势。还有一个叫做 APE 的练习,提醒你关注自己的觉察、姿势和情绪——自从这次对话后我就开始实践了。以及更多的内容。如果你喜欢这次对话,一定要去看看 Jonny 的完整课程,网址是 nsmastery.com/lenny。使用这个链接,你可以享受 250 美元的优惠。接下来,欢迎 Jonny Miller。
Lenny: Jonny,非常感谢你来做客。欢迎来到播客。
Jonny Miller: 很高兴来到这里,Lenny。
缘起:为什么研究神经系统
Lenny: 我读了你写的那篇文章,应该是一年多以前了。标题是《你的神经系统操作手册》,首先,读完之后让我大开眼界。其次,每当我在某个情境中感到紧张或焦虑时,我总会想起它,它真的深深印在我脑海里了。我知道职场中人们经常在做全员演示、开会、绩效评估等各种事情时感到紧张和焦虑。所以我觉得深入探讨你发现的这些关于如何减少紧张和焦虑的方法会非常有价值。在进入正题之前,我想先花几分钟了解一下你为什么投身于这个领域。是什么让你投入如此多的精力和心血去研究神经系统的工作原理,去帮助人们减少紧张和焦虑。
Jonny Miller: 我的故事要从……我算是技术背景出身。我创过业,2012 年进了 Techstars 孵化器。在那段经历进行到大约五年半的时候,我经历了倦怠——这在创业圈很常见,但那其实并不是我真正的转折点。我发现通常进入这个领域的人,都会经历某种催化剂或某种艰难的生活事件。对我来说,那是 2017 年 10 月 23 日,我当时的未婚妻经历了一场焦虑发作,然后结束了自己的生命。那件事在当时彻底击垮了我。我意识到自己一直与身体和情感如此脱节,这把我推上了一段五年多的旅程,去探索这片我从未关注的内在版图——我从脖子以下一直是麻木的。我参加了呼吸法冥想静修营,进行了数百次呼吸法体验,在巴厘岛的一个呼吸实验室做过研究,基本上把所有的注意力和精力都投入到理解这片内在版图上——而此前我对此几乎一无所知。从那以后,我一直在与创始人、高管合作,开设课程,教授我所学到的东西,同时也希望继续研究。
Lenny: ……我想你的想法是,如果你的妻子当时拥有这些技能,她也许会有另一条路可走。
Jonny Miller: 是的,这确实是其中一部分原因。同时也因为我意识到有多少人正在与焦虑、抑郁以及各种心理健康问题作斗争——无论是在职场还是在家里。是的,这是一段非常有意义的旅程。
Lenny: 好,这一期一开始就变得很沉重了,而我已经完全被吸引了。我很期待学习你发现的所有这些东西。那我们就直接进入正题吧,来谈谈你发现的这套帮助人们减少紧张和焦虑的通用方法。
自上而下与自下而上的方法
Jonny Miller: 我发现自上而下和自下而上这个区分非常有帮助。大多数人试图让自己平静下来时,会使用策略性的认知重构,或者正念,或者用积极的方式重新解读情境。人们会使用各种不同的方法,确实也有一定效果。但根据我的经验,从生理层面入手,采用所谓的自下而上的方法——主要通过呼吸,当然也有其他途径——改变状态的速度要快得多,效果也显著得多。
稍微补充一些背景和科学依据。我们的身体中有所谓的传入(afferent)和传出(efferent)神经元,在身体中上下传递信息,而从身体传向大脑的传入神经元数量是从大脑传向身体的传出神经元的四倍。所以你几乎可以想象,有一条信息超级高速公路直通大脑,而反方向的流量只有四分之一。因此,学会拨动我们生理的杠杆,就能迅速改变自身状态。状态改变之后,又会进一步影响我们的想法和感受。所以,与其试图改变叙事、试图修补什么、试图解决什么——这是大多数人包括过去的我的默认做法——不如先改变状态,然后就会产生连锁反应,改变你的想法和感受。
Lenny: 好的,太棒了。我在读这些内容、试图理解这个方法的时候,有一种感受——每当我紧张的时候,总是先有”哦,我的身体开始焦虑了”这种感觉,然后我才去找一个原因。很多时候我根本不知道为什么会紧张,为什么身体开始产生这种焦虑感。然后我往往意识到自己只是在事后解释为什么会这样——“哦,我有一个重要的会议要来了”,或者”我要录一期播客,有点紧张”,或者”我的newsletter要赶不上截止日期了”。我经常经历这种情况,就是”哦,感觉有些紧张”,然后”好吧,这是解释”。沿着这个思路,在这个语境下还有什么对大家有帮助的思考角度吗?
呼吸如何改变状态
Jonny Miller: 我觉得了解这个过程很有帮助——比如,通过改变呼吸方式,它如何改变我们的生理状态和神经系统。如果你正在听这期节目,也许你,Lenny,也可以试试。如果你开始用上胸部呼吸,浅而快,甚至用嘴呼吸,那么你大脑中有一个部分叫岛叶皮层(insular cortex),它基本上一直在监视我们的呼吸方式,它会捕捉到这个变化,然后将信息传递给内分泌系统,引发血液化学成分的变化。交感神经(sympathetic nervous system)被激活,肾上腺素和皮质醇开始涌遍全身。大家可能对那种感觉非常熟悉。然后这又会连锁影响你的想法和感受。你刚才提到的,我们有一种倾向,会去编造或虚构故事来匹配我们当下的状态。这就是当我们以那种方式呼吸时发生的事情。反过来,你也可以有意识地改变呼吸方式,产生相反的效果,我可以进一步展开,不过先说到这里。
Lenny: 所以我觉得这里一个很重要的实操要点是,与其试图说服自己”不,这次演讲会很顺利的,我不需要担心在会议上会表现成什么样”——基本上就是不要走自上而下的路线,试图通过想法来让身体平静下来——你的建议是先让身体平静下来,因为这样大脑就会注意到,“嘿,我其实没那么紧张,也许事情没那么糟。“是这样吗?
Jonny Miller: 没错,正是如此。我自己在做演讲之前就用过这个方法很多次。几年前我做了一次TEDx演讲,当时整个身体都在发抖,简直吓坏了。我在上台前做了15分钟的呼吸练习,然后走上台时几乎镇定自若。效果非常显著。
为什么呼吸如此有效
Lenny: 听起来好得不太真实。不过我们待会儿会带大家做一些练习。在此之前,我想问,为什么呼吸特别有效?感觉这是一件很奇怪的事情——仅仅是换个方式呼吸就能这么管用。你之前谈到过一点,我忘了你叫它什么了,就是那个监视你呼吸方式的东西。除此之外,关于呼吸为什么在改变状态方面如此有效,你还能分享些什么?
Jonny Miller: 好的。呼吸是少数既能自动进行、又能被我们有意识控制的事情之一。科学家发现,当呼气时长是吸气的两倍时,会产生镇定效果;当吸气更强烈,或吸气时长是呼气的两倍时,则会产生激活效果。所以你可以把它看作神经系统上的”加速”或”减速”杠杆。
状态优先于叙事
Lenny: 你还有一个很巧妙的方式来描述这套系统。你称之为”状态优先于叙事”(state over story),本质上就是关注身体的状态,而不是你对自己讲的故事。应该这样理解吗?你能谈谈这个概念吗?
Jonny Miller: 是的,这基本上就是我们刚才讨论内容的简写版——大多数人倾向于在叙事层面去处理问题或试图解决问题。而我们刚才谈到,有多种方式可以从状态层面入手——通过呼吸;你也可以散焦目光、放松眼睛,这也有类似的效果;你可以将觉察扩展到身后、两侧和脚下;或者用那些强调呼气的方式来呼吸。当我们以呼气时长为吸气两倍的方式呼吸时,大脑中那个部分——岛叶皮层——就会向副交感神经(parasympathetic nervous system)发送信号,进而对我们的内分泌系统产生连锁效应,让我们平静下来。我还经常发现,当我们处于那种焦虑的循环中时,那些反应性的想法和感受会自我强化。如果一个人产生了”糟糕,这个重要演讲前我好紧张”这样的想法,那会加剧那种呼吸模式,然后整个事情就进入一个螺旋,如果没有某种干预,最终可能演变成全面的恐慌发作。
Lenny: 是的,这正是我在紧张时遇到的情况。我讨厌在台上讲话,每次录播客之前都会紧张。这不是我的自然状态。
Jonny Miller: 有意思。
Lenny: 是的,只是我掩饰得很好。
Jonny Miller: 今天的播客也是这样吗?
Lenny: 当然。而且紧张的程度每次不同,但总是那种”哦,又来了”的感觉。我不是一个天生适合表演的人。说实话,我做这个播客某种程度上也是在逼自己,以此锻炼这方面的能力。所以这仍然是我会去想的事情。而我发现紧张感正是来源于你所描述的那种情况——对紧张的紧张。我不知道,其实没有什么具体的理由要焦虑,但我不知道自己做那件事的时候会是什么状态。所以是对事情可能变成什么样、最终结果如何的紧张。这就是我遇到的情况。
Jonny Miller: 当然,人们常说正念、冥想之类的练习可以增加刺激与反应之间的心理空间。这确实在长期内有所帮助,但在我看来,它远不如改变呼吸方式来得迅速、有效和高效。
Lenny: 太好了。那我们开始吧。我知道你有几个专门针对这方面的练习,然后我们再接着往下聊。
现场呼吸练习:4-4-8 呼吸法
Jonny Miller: 我们可以把几个练习叠加起来做,我会尽量控制在一分钟左右。好,你可以先在椅子上坐舒服,坐直,感受臀部坐在座位上的感觉。我觉得同时觉察身后和头顶的空间也很有帮助——扩展你的觉知范围,让自己意识到身后、两侧和头顶的空间。
Lenny: 需要闭上眼睛吗?
Jonny Miller: 对,把眼睛闭上。如果你正在开车听节目,显然不要闭眼。但确实,闭上眼睛会有帮助。现在我们做一个简单的呼吸:用鼻子吸气 4 秒,屏息 4 秒,然后用 8 秒呼气,然后重复。先放开呼吸,然后通过鼻子吸气。吸气,2、3、4,屏住呼吸,2、3、4。呼气,8、2、3、4、5、6、7、8。吸气,2、3、4,屏住呼吸,2、3、4,呼气,2、3、4、5、6、7、8。现在可以完全放开呼吸,我们最后做一轮哼鸣,它的镇定效果出奇地好。深吸一口气,然后通过鼻子哼鸣,一直到呼气结束。如果感觉舒服的话可以叹一口气,然后睁开眼睛。
Lenny: 我感觉非常平静。我应该每期播客开始前都做一次这个练习。
Jonny Miller: 补充一点关于哼鸣的说明。它还会释放一氧化氮,这是一种血管扩张剂,有助于产生那种镇定效果,同时还能缓解眼部紧张。所以如果我盯着屏幕看太久了,就会做这个练习。它对减轻眼睛疲劳也非常有效。
Lenny: 它还跟迷走神经有关吧,因为你的身体在振动,是这样吗?
Jonny Miller: 对,没错。它可以说是在调节或刺激迷走神经,从而激活副交感神经。
构建个人呼吸工具箱
Lenny: 你对练习的时机有什么建议?是在参加重要会议或演讲之前做吗?你一般怎么应用?
Jonny Miller: 我比较倾向于帮人们构建一个工具箱,里面有适用于不同场景的不同练习。比如像 4-4-8 呼吸法,你几乎可以在任何地方做,周围的人不一定会注意到。哼鸣稍微明显一些,但如果你准备开一个视频会议之类的,完全可以闭着眼睛做。还有扩展觉知,或者把注意力带到脚和手上,这会产生一种接地、镇定的效果,在人来人往的房间里也可以做。也许你有社交焦虑,那就可以试着定向并标注你听到和感受到的东西,把觉知和注意力带回身体,这同样有效果。然后还有一些需要更长时间的练习,比如非睡眠深度休息、腹式呼吸等,适合你有 10 到 20 分钟、在家想让自己降速的时候做。
所以我喜欢给人们一个大的工具箱,让他们看看哪些对自己有效,然后从中挑选适合不同场景的练习。我思考这个问题的另一个方式是,我称之为”如果……就呼吸”。比如,如果我感到不知所措,就做哼鸣;如果我感到焦虑,就做 4-4-8 呼吸法或者交替鼻孔呼吸。拥有适用于不同场景的自己的小配方集,真的非常有帮助,我在跟人合作时也会帮他们构建自己的工具箱。
Lenny: 这听起来需要一个网站,人们可以上去看这些”如果……就……”的清单。节目介绍里有没有可以链接的地方?如果没有的话,你趁上线之前做一个吧。
Jonny Miller: 目前还没有。这是我的课程里教学内容的一部分,不过——
Lenny: 好的,明白了。
Jonny Miller: 我可以看看能不能快速做一个出来,嗯。
Lenny: 好,酷。至少我们可以在节目介绍里链接到课程。太棒了。
生理性叹息与升速练习
Jonny Miller: 好的。
Lenny: 顺着镇定呼吸练习这个话题,Huberman 也有一个不同的版本,我试过,现在我打算两个都做。就是先充分吸气,然后再多吸一点。你应该见过这个建议吧?
Jonny Miller: 那个也非常好。他称之为生理性叹息(physiological sigh),同样非常有效,特别是如果你只有五秒钟的时间,只需要做一个完整的叹息,就很好。我还想补充的是,做完这些降速练习之后,叹息会自然而然地发生。所以如果你注意到了,比如做完 4-4-8 呼吸法之后,最后你可能自然就想叹一口气,那就是你的身体在自然降速的信号。或者如果你和一个朋友在一起,感到舒适放松,身体也可能叹气。这是我们经常做的事情,正如你所说,你可以有意识地去做,也会有效果。这也是练习之一。
Lenny: 太好了。我们会在节目介绍里放链接。我觉得在这期节目中,正如你所说,我们会给大家很多可以使用的工具。感觉有些是当下可以用的——“我现在需要平静下来,这里有件事你可以做。“然后还有一些是可以持续做的,来建立一个基础……我想另一种理解方式就是让你的身体在基线水平上变得更平静。
Jonny Miller: 对,没错。
Lenny: 好。我想我们要做的另一个呼吸练习正好相反,是让你兴奋起来的那种,对吗?
浓缩咖啡呼吸法
Jonny Miller: 对,没问题,我们也可以做那个。我把这个叫做浓缩咖啡呼吸(espresso breath)。这个正好相反,非常有激活作用。我只建议在感到昏昏沉沉的时候做,或者下午想喝咖啡的时候,可以做一分钟来代替。在科学文献中它叫做风箱呼吸(bellows breath)或火的呼吸(breath of fire),基本上就是通过鼻子做一系列快速呼气。我建议只通过鼻子来做,如果用嘴巴的话,激活作用会太强,可能会让人受不了。当然,很多人可能都熟悉 Wim Hof 的呼吸法。所以这个算是更温和的版本——如果 Wim Hof 呼吸法像红牛,那这个就像一小杯咖啡。
Lenny: 我喜欢这个比喻。你叫它浓缩咖啡呼吸,espresso breath。
Jonny Miller: 浓缩咖啡呼吸,对。
Lenny: 很棒的比喻。
Jonny Miller: 嗯,好,那我们来做吧。同样,坐直,这次你要从下腹部泵气,在呼气的时候泵气。我先示范一下。就像这样,吸气。好,深吸一口气,开始。(练习中)好,放开。再深吸一口气。呼气的时候叹气。我已经觉得有点麻麻的了。
Lenny: 我感觉精力充沛了。开始吧开始吧开始吧。太好了。看吧,我们又回到了起点,完成了一个能量的闭环。太棒了。
Jonny Miller: 上上下下。
Lenny: 那这个你建议做多长时间?
Jonny Miller: 这取决于你觉得它的激活程度有多强,但我通常建议每轮做 30 次呼吸,然后深吸一口气,在呼气后做一次长时间的屏息,之后如果需要,可以再做一到两轮。
Lenny: 太棒了。那什么情况下这个会比较有用呢?也许是你即将做一场重要演讲的时候——我想演讲时你既需要能量又需要冷静,所以还挺复杂的。
Jonny Miller: 特别是当你早上有会议但还没完全进入状态的时候,可以先做浓缩咖啡呼吸来激活自己。然后再做一些降档练习,把那份活力稳定下来、扎根下来。
Lenny: 还有没有其他实用的呼吸练习值得快速提一下?我知道我们后面会深入一些更长的练习和更深的内容,但这里还有什么值得分享的吗?
Jonny Miller: 没有了,我觉得已经覆盖了基本的。我不想给大家太多信息过载。
随时可用的呼吸工具箱
Lenny: 总结一下,就是这两种技巧。一种帮助你在需要冷静的时候让自己平静下来;另一种帮助你在需要的时候获得能量。那我想问,你是建议持续练习这些来锻炼身体这方面的能力,还是说这些主要是针对当下需要的应急工具,平时没事的时候没必要每天做几次?
Jonny Miller: 好问题。我建议两者兼顾。我特别推荐一个晨间练习,主要是为了养成习惯、让身体熟悉这种感觉。比如在早上开始工作之前、吃早餐之前,花五分钟做一下。这样你在需要的时候就更容易想起来自己有这个工具可用,因为通常的挑战是——当一个人处于慌乱状态时,想起要做练习往往是最后才会想到的事。所以至少坚持 7 到 10 天的有意识练习,等你上手之后,在需要的时候做起来就会自然得多。这就像在困难模式下玩游戏——当你真正紧张焦虑的时候,恰恰是最需要它的时候,但同时也是你最不可能想起来去做的时候。
Lenny: 明白了。好的,那第一个让你平静下来的练习,基本就是吸气四秒,屏息四秒,缓慢呼气八秒,大概做 30 秒,对吗?还是说做一分钟?
Jonny Miller: 对,我建议至少做一到两分钟。我们刚才做的算是缩短版的。我还要补充一点,关键在于呼气的时长要是吸气的两倍。所以如果呼气八秒太长,你可以做 3-3-6,甚至 2-2-4,或者 5-5-10,基本上取决于你的肺活量和 CO₂ 耐受度。
Lenny: 好的,了解。那浓缩咖啡呼吸呢,当你需要能量的时候,就是用鼻子从腹部用力把气泵出来,你建议做多久?
Jonny Miller: 两到三轮,每轮 30 次泵气。
**Lenny:**再说一下,这个之所以有效和强大的原因,回到你最初的核心洞察——我们的状态是由身体在做什么驱动的,而大脑往往会根据身体的状态来解释我们的感受。所以如果你能改变身体的状态,让身体不再那么紧张,你的大脑就会说:“好的,一切正常。”
Jonny Miller: 是的。还有一点我们还没提到,但我觉得很重要,就是内感受(interoception)或者说躯体觉察(somatic awareness)这个概念。我之所以提这个,是因为如果你做了这些练习但对身体的感觉和状态并不敏感,那它的效果就会大打折扣。但如果你能感知到身体里的各种感觉、正在发生什么,你就更容易注意到练习带来的变化和转换。
内感受:第六感
Lenny: 很好。那我们来聊聊这个。这也是我非常想涉及的话题。你有一个很棒的缩写来帮助人们进行内感受的过程。来谈谈它是什么,以及如何实际提升对身体状态的觉察力。
Jonny Miller: 好。内感受这个概念,被称为我们的第六感,基本上就是我们感知、追踪和感受内在状态的能力。我喜欢用厨师来打比方——就像你可以训练自己的味觉去分辨甜、辣、鲜等味道一样,你也可以训练自己的内感受”味觉”,对身体内部的各种感觉变得更加敏锐——不管是呼吸、紧张感、情绪和心情,还是觉察的品质、思维的品质。你对这些越敏感,就越容易注意到像焦虑这类情况的早期预警信号。因为通常来说,恐慌发作绝对不是凭空而来的。你的身体会先经历一连串微妙的变化,最终才导致焦虑。所以如果你能及早捕捉到这些信号、把它们掐灭在萌芽状态、做其中一个练习,就能避免那种 10 分满格的最坏情况。
Lenny: 好的,太好了。我知道你还有一份具体的清单,建议人们关注哪些方面来理解自己的身体在这个过程中的状态……
Jonny Miller: 内感受(interoception),对。
Lenny: 内感……好,这个词怎么说来着?
Jonny Miller: Interoception。
Lenny: Intero……好的。
Jonny Miller: Interoception。
Lenny: Interoception。
Jonny Miller: 与外感受(exteroception)相对,后者是对所有外部刺激的感知。
Lenny: 明白了。在进入那个清单之前,你提到这是我们拥有的另一个感官,我觉得这是一个非常重要的点,可能有些人没注意到。我们 obviously 有五种感官——味觉、嗅觉、视觉、触觉等。但你发现研究表明,这基本上是人们不太了解的另一个感官。
Jonny Miller: 对,没错。在过去十年左右,这方面的研究已经相当多了。我从研究中发现了一些有趣的结论。其一是 ADHD 往往与较低的内感受水平相关,PTSD 或创伤也是如此——内感受水平同样会降低。就我自己来说,在人生的前 25 年里,我从脖子往下基本是麻木的,我对身体里正在发生什么并不太有实时的觉察。我最近还在读一本叫《狗与狼之间的时刻》的书,研究的是华尔街交易员,他们发现内感受程度更高的交易员基本上赚的钱更多、做的决策更好。书中的论点是,通过关注自己在特定时刻身体的反应,交易员能够捕捉到一些东西,做出更直觉化的决策。
Lenny: 我记得你有一个具体的清单,建议人们关注自己的姿势、呼吸等等。那个清单是什么?我们如何才能真正提升这种能力?
Jonny Miller: 对,我把它简化为 APE,基本上是一个缩写,代表觉察(Awareness)、姿势(Posture)和情绪(Emotion)。逐一来讲。觉察,举个例子,我可以收窄注意力,变得非常专注,你会不自觉地紧张起来,而且这有时也会带来激活作用;或者你也可以放松下来,扩展觉察,感知头顶的空间、身后的空间、身下的空间。这通常是一种让人平静的做法。姿势比较好理解,但同样,我们的姿势会影响我们的感受——你现在就在调整姿势。然后是情绪,我把身体层面的、躯体层面的感受也归入其中。包括整体的情绪状态,以及我正在感受到的基调或质感。比如现在,可能是兴奋,可能有一些喜悦。我注意到腹部有些发热,大概是之前呼吸法练习带来的。还有下背部有一点紧绷,大概是昨天锻炼留下的。就是在描绘那片感觉的版图。对大多数人来说,这几乎就像——有一种那种地图,很多人的身体上存在大片大片的盲区。
Lenny: 这里的建议是——APE 这个缩写——建议是在你感觉到什么不太对劲的时候,或者仅仅是在日常中经常回到这个练习。我想就是只要你能想起来的时刻:“哦,APE:觉察、姿势、情绪。“是这样用的吗?
Jonny Miller: 对,完全正确。它可以是你每天开始工作前做的事情,也许是泡一杯茶的时候。我喜欢一边喝茶一边做一次身体扫描,逐项检查那三个区域。这非常有价值,尤其是当你思绪纷飞或者感觉哪里不太对的时候。与其只在思维层面去解决问题,不如沉入身体,把身体的信息也纳入考量,我觉得这非常有帮助。
在日常场景中运用 APE
Lenny: 基本上就是尽可能频繁地练习。当你感觉一切都不太对劲的时候,就记住 APE——我的注意力在哪里?我的姿势怎么样?然后我感受到什么?我感到悲伤吗?感到快乐、兴奋、愤怒?诸如此类。我记得你还谈到呼吸,你有一篇文章列出了其他值得关注的要素。我发现关注呼吸正在做什么也非常有效。所以我打算试一个 BAPE 版本——把呼吸也加进去——关注我的呼吸从哪里来,在那个部位我感受到什么。
Jonny Miller: 对,呼吸和躯体感觉是另外两个非常有用的维度。呼吸尤其如此——人们常常会有一种所谓”邮件呼吸暂停”的现象,就是查看邮件时,人们会不知不觉地开始屏住呼吸,这通常是一种非常激活状态的行为。或者如我之前提到的,如果你是用嘴呼吸,浅浅地吸到上胸部,那也会非常激活;反之,如果你用鼻子呼吸,气息深入腹部、扩展到肋骨两侧,感觉轻松自如——基本上,没有紧张感的呼吸是最理想的。
Lenny: 我在想怎么运用这个练习。比如我坐在一个会议里,感觉不是特别自信,我就回到这个缩写——BAPE 或者 APE,随你选哪个——就是问问自己:我现在感觉如何?哦,我整个胃都是紧缩的。也许我在担心接下来会发生什么,或者我根本没有在呼吸,或者我的姿势很差。所以在会议中运用会非常有帮助。也许你马上要上 Zoom 开一个重要的通话,或者一对一的会议。还有没有其他场景,其他触发时刻,让人意识到”我现在真的应该觉察一下正在发生什么,让我做一个 APE 练习”?
Jonny Miller: 对,在你刚才说的基础上补充一下——如果你准备进入一个会议,注意到胃部是紧缩的,那其实是很有用的信息,可以问自己:“为什么会这样?“是你的直觉在告诉你也许不应该和这个人做这笔交易?也许哪里有什么不对?这是一个值得深入探索的信号。也可能是你被什么触发了,或者某人说了什么话,而你才刚刚意识到——这同样是更多的信息,可以用来反思或深入探究。
Lenny: 你最近生活中有没有什么例子,你感到不太确定,然后意识到”哦,我的身体在这样反应,也许我应该多关注一下”?
内感受与倦怠的关联
Jonny Miller: 实际上,上周我做了一期播客对话——我自己也有一档播客——下了播之后,我记得我感觉——下了播之后感到相当疲惫,胸口有一种紧张感,呼吸也是乱糟糟的。然后我意识到,那周我确实过度承诺了,排了密集的连轴播客录制。播客甚至不是我这个季度的优先事项,所以我随后做了一个决定,把所有节目的录制都推迟到了夏天。
Lenny: 我很喜欢这个例子。那种感觉我非常熟悉。
Jonny Miller: 肯定的。
Lenny: 你在写内感受这个概念的时候,把它和倦怠联系了起来,我记得你谈到这是避免倦怠最好的工具之一。对吗?我没记错吧?如果是的话,你怎么看待倦怠和避免倦怠这件事?很多人都有这样的经历。
Jonny Miller: 对,我有一个概念,叫做羽毛、砖块、自卸卡车现象。基本上意思是,当我们出现倦怠的早期征兆时,身体会给我们反馈,通常一开始以微妙的方式呈现。羽毛,可能是早上醒来感觉有点累,有点疲惫。砖块,也许你忽略了那个信号,或者没有注意到,三四个月后你和某人发生争吵或争执,或者你就是感到沮丧、糟糕,失控了。然后自卸卡车,可能再过一个月甚至一年后,出现全面的健康危机,或者得了二型糖尿病,或者有一系列其他问题,或者被解雇了。有很多不同的事情可能发生。但通常来说,取决于你的内感受能力有多敏锐——理想情况下,你希望在它还是羽毛的时候就注意到它,然后做出调整或改变,而不必等到承受自卸卡车那样全面的痛苦。不幸的是,很多人都是这样的,尤其是第一次经历倦怠的时候。
Lenny: 这一点太重要了,这种思考方式非常好。这让我想起 Andy Johns 那一期节目,就是那些细微的信号一路上不断出现,最终变得完全无法维持他所过的那种生活。
情绪债务
Lenny: 这些羽毛信号有哪些例子?所以你的建议就是留意那些表明你目前的生活方式不可持续的细微迹象。这种羽毛般的信号有哪些例子,提示也许我需要做出改变?
Jonny Miller: 对,我把它和一个叫做情绪债务(emotional debt)的概念联系起来。基本上,当我们的神经系统经历压力时,会有一个被称为动员周期(mobilization cycle)的过程,如果这个周期没有被完成,或者我们没有在另一侧得以降速或放松,它就会作为稳态负荷(allostatic load)储存在身体中,我称之为情绪债务。随着时间的推移,这会在神经系统中造成脆弱性。这种脆弱性可能表现为对小事产生不成比例的反应。比如发现自己比平时更容易反应过度,可能更容易发脾气,可能对小事感到烦躁,可能睡眠不太好,醒来时没有完全恢复精力。人际关系往往,尤其是亲密关系,通常是这种信号显现的地方,或者工作中的关系也是如此。这些都是典型的早期预警信号。然后随着情绪债务阈值的增加,就像技术债务一样,如果你在做一个产品,一开始是没问题的,实际上在初期甚至是必要的。我们身体能够缓冲压力反应,这很好,因为它让我们得以正常运作。但如果我们不去偿还这些技术债务或情绪债务,它就会随时间积累,也可能通过健康危机、健康问题爆发出来。基本上会持续恶化,直到这笔债务被偿还。
Lenny: 我觉得很多听众会说,“对,我完全明白你的意思。“一个人如何注意到自己在积累情绪债务,然后又该如何开始释放这些债务、偿还这些债务?
Jonny Miller: 我在一些创始人客户身上看到的,以及在我们采访了260位领导者所做的研究中,经常发生的情况是,情绪债务会不断增加、增加、增加,直到达到一个点,我们已经远超所谓的容忍窗口(window of tolerance)。到了那个点就会出现崩溃。几乎就像保险丝跳闸一样,伴随着彻底的疲惫。可能完全无法从沙发上爬起来。对于一些人,那些神经系统容量大的人来说,他们可以持续五年甚至十年,不断积累,并且把这种总是处于开启状态、从未真正放松或平静下来的生活方式视为常态。还有一个很关键的迹象是,如果你在一天结束时无法自然地降速或下调你的神经系统,而需要借助葡萄酒、CBD或某种外部物质,那就是你已经达到了一定程度的情绪债务阈值的信号。
Lenny: 那如果一个人已经这样了很多年,工作过度,有一段不太好的关系……我不知道。我想大多数人会去心理咨询,通过谈话来梳理这些事情,试图解决这些问题。如果你觉得”天哪,我觉得我有这个问题,我该怎么办”,你会怎么建议?
Jonny Miller: 对,嗯,这是一个很大的问题。我说这个可能会招来一些反对意见,但我不是太认同仅靠谈话疗法,或者至少是没有躯体(somatic)或身体成分参与的疗法。根据我对神经系统以及我们如何储存压力的理解,仅仅谈论事情、把问题停留在智力层面,实际上并不能触及挑战的根源。我们需要做的是创造一种安全感,去进入那些被缓冲的情绪反应,把它们完整地感受一遍,让那个动员反射得以完成。举一个个人的例子,当我在巴厘岛生活的时候,我做了几百次呼吸法的深度旅程,以特定的方式呼吸进入一种 altered state(改变的状态),然后在那种状态下,这些记忆会浮现出来,是那些发生在5年、10年前的事情。我的身体会以某种方式动作,或者愤怒会涌出来,有时是悲伤或哀恸。我们身体里经常储存着大量被压抑的情绪,它们只是需要被允许去完整地感受和释放。对我来说,这是一段与自己的愤怒和哀恸——老实说还有羞耻感——建立正确关系的旅程,允许自己去感受这些积压在骨盆区域的污浊之物。
所以我不是说你必须去巴厘岛做200次呼吸法旅程。那确实不是……我的意思是,那是一条路。但首先,正如我所说,从培养内感受开始,甚至要意识到存在着这种紧张,身体里有这些东西。其次,要有自我调节的练习,这样如果这些东西浮现出来,你不会被淹没。你能够降速并扎根。然后第三,是我所说的情绪流动性(emotional fluidity)的练习,基本上就是创造条件,迎接情绪的完整谱系在它们出现时被感受。通常,有一位向导或躯体从业者会很有帮助,我喜欢躯体体验疗法(somatic experiencing)、Hakomi,这是我很推崇的两种方法。是的,这是一段旅程,一个过程,取决于你有多少年一直在一种略显麻木的状态下运作,每个人的情况都不同。但它始于关注身体、倾听身体,然后诚实地对其中存在的东西保持好奇,跟随那份好奇心,身体会开始向你展示什么已经准备好被看见。
Lenny: 我很喜欢它总是回到我们最初出发的地方——我们的感受方式是一个自下而上的、基于身体的系统,不是我们先感受到什么然后身体变得紧张,而是身体先紧张,然后我们才想”哦,这就是我紧张的原因”。而你的建议就是,把大量精力放在帮助身体释放你积累的那些债务上。同时,当你在某个时刻感到紧张时,专注于让身体进入某种状态,而不是试图说服你的大脑一切都会好起来的。
Jonny Miller: 完全正确。
躯体导向疗法的作用
Lenny: 具体说到治疗这条路径,简单提一下——你的建议是,如果要找心理咨询师,而且觉得自己有很多我们正在讨论的这些问题,应该聚焦于躯体导向疗法,也就是以身体为取向的,不只是去思考、谈论问题,而是真正帮助你的身体——本质上就是帮助身体释放这些债务。
Jonny Miller: 是的。你可以在精确的细节上理解五年、十年、十五年前所经历的那个挑战到底是什么,但如果你无法将它与身体中对应的感受连接起来……通常,假如——我也不知道——如果我想象昨天有人对我大吼,我一想到这件事,通常会有一个对应的躯体感受。神经科学家 Damasio 将其称为躯体标记(somatic marker)。所以通过追踪这些躯体标记,然后独自跟随那种感受,允许当时存在的任何情绪完成它的过程——这就是我们慢慢偿还情绪债务的方式,一次处理一个。
情绪债务积累的迹象
Lenny: 那也许回到这个问题——假如有人在听,并且在想,我是不是在积累情绪债务?我是不是在忽视那些”羽毛”?有哪些迹象,有没有什么例子能说明情绪债务正在积累,这种创伤——不管你怎么称呼它——正在身体里堆积?是不是每次你感到非常紧张,那就是情绪债务?是不是每次你压抑了一些你直觉上知道当下应该处理的东西,那就是情绪债务?有没有什么具体的例子,说说那是什么感觉、看起来是什么样子?
Jonny Miller: 好的。它通常表现为不同形式的神经系统失调,可以体现在一个人的呼吸模式上——如果他们一直处于交感神经或过度警觉的状态,总是在扫描周围、寻找最坏的情况。另一个常见的情况,尤其是在科技行业,就是非常沉浸在头脑中,整天生活在思想和心智里。这会产生一种解离(disassociation),本质上是一种保护机制,因为待在身体的感受里是不舒服的。而因为我们的社会倾向于奖励那些善于解决问题、活在头脑中的人,这种模式会持续很多年甚至几十年。
其他的表现,我觉得最明显的一个就是情绪反应性——你对某个情境的反应与实际发生的事情不成比例。比如,如果你对我说了一句毫无道理的话,然后我……僵住了。这又引出一个重要的点:大多数人有两种反应模式。有些人会僵住、退缩、封闭、断开连接;另一些人会变得更具攻击性、膨胀起来、反击。了解自己倾向于哪种取向——对我来说,通常是缩小、僵住、封闭——了解自己的模式,以及这种发生时伴随的身体感受是什么,这对你会非常有帮助,你会意识到”哦,那个模式又在发生了”。此时我的首要任务是降档,在身体中找到一种安全感,然后再去互动、做决定、进行对话。因为如果你一直从反应性的状态出发,那种状态下不会有什么好结果。没有哪个好的决定是在那种状态下做出的。所以,这就是拥有内感受觉知(interoceptive awareness)的价值所在——知道”哦,正在发生什么”,然后能够给你的系统降档,获得一种”哦,我没事,其实这没那么糟”的感觉,然后从这里继续前进——这是一个极其实用的、非常有用的技能。
情绪与决策力
Lenny: 沿着类似的思路,你曾在某处写过这样一个观点——如果你能”感受那些感受”(feel the feels),你就拥有了巨大的竞争优势。这话你有印象吗?如果有,能分享一下吗——为什么这一点如此强大,尤其是在职场中?
Jonny Miller: 是的,我想我是在 Every 的一篇文章里写到这个的。标题大概是《最好的决策是情绪化的》。我当时基本想反驳一句话——我想是在 Twitter 上看到有人说的——“事实高于感受,别让情绪毁了好决策”。是的,关于这点有很多可以说的。但基本上,有这样一个里程碑式的研究,是这个叫 Damasio 的人做的,一位著名的神经科学家。他研究了一位叫 Elliot 的患者。Elliot 的脑部有一颗肿瘤被切除了,这导致他失去了感受情绪的能力。他整个情绪功能都被移除了。Elliot 从一个成功的、已婚的商人,变成了离异、破产,甚至连午餐吃什么都无法选择。他无法做出最基本的生活决策,原因就是他的大脑失去了那个情绪感官。
所以我们的大脑就像一台预测机器,而且正如我之前提到的,有一条来自身体的感觉数据的高速公路在持续上传。如果我们在做决策时不倾听这些信息,就会丢失大量数据。我经常在我服务的客户身上看到这种情况——如果他们在回避某种感受,比如他们不喜欢感受冲突或愤怒,那他们就会在潜意识中做出决策来避免感受到那些。这会变成一个巨大的偏见和一个巨大的问题,因为人们之所以做出某些决定,是因为他们害怕感受某种感觉。而另一方面,如果你能够欢迎并接纳决策之后可能出现的任何情绪,你就能清晰地做决定,而不是被偏向某一方。
Lenny: 说起来容易做起来难。
Jonny Miller: 是的。
Lenny: 你觉得过于敏锐地感受自己的情绪,会不会有什么弊端?我其实不是一个能敏锐感知自己感受的人。我比较稳定,部分原因是我很多时候不太关注自己的感受——也许这是一个需要处理的巨大问题。但不知道,到目前为止还行吧。我想问的是,你是不是也会觉得有时候没关系——有时候你不需要每时每刻都清楚什么在伤害你、什么在让你痛苦?
Jonny Miller: 好问题。有些人确实有很高的内感受能力,这可能会让人不堪重负。在这种情况下,我会建议专注于呼吸练习来培养降档的能力,这样你才能正常运作。确实有些人会被日常生活的刺激所淹没——出门走在车流中,他们非常容易过度负荷。对这些人来说,提升神经系统的承载能力来承受那部分压力是很有价值的——也许是蒸桑拿加冰水浸泡,也许是通过温和的、循序渐进的压力暴露然后降档——这确实很有帮助。
情绪缓冲的代价
Jonny Miller: 我还想说,良好的运作能力——这适用于很多高绩效的人,坦白说可能也是你大部分听众的画像——在当下是非常有用的。比如有些情绪冒出来了,你需要能够缓冲这些强烈的情绪,先把会议撑过去,先把眼前的事情处理完。这是一项非常有用的技能。但如果你不在事后给自己留出空间去降档,允许自己去感受那段经历所唤起的情绪,你就是在日积月累地增加情绪债务。正如我提到的,有些人可能一年之内就会出现某种崩溃、倦怠。另一些人可能更久。而通常拖得越久情况越不幸,因为它会造成长期的健康危机,到那时再多的金钱和时间也难以修复已经造成的损伤,这确实令人痛心。
Lenny: 我和 Andy Johns 的那次对话就是一个很好的例子。
Jonny Miller: 是的,Andy 是一个极好的例子,我很欣赏他在自己经历中的脆弱与坦诚。
Lenny: 嗯,如果你对这个话题感兴趣,一定要去看那一期。你经常提到的另一个练习,叫做 NSDR,对吧。聊聊它是什么,什么时候有用,以及怎么使用这个工具。
非睡眠深度休息(NSDR)
Jonny Miller: 好的,NSDR 是由 Andrew Huberman 创造的一个术语,你之前提到过他。它基本上是以更科学的视角来审视瑜伽休息术(yoga nidra)这一古老的瑜伽练习。我非常推崇它,自己大部分日子都会做 15 到 20 分钟。具体做法是:你躺下来,戴上眼罩或蒙眼布,然后听一段引导音频。我自己也录制了一些,可以在节目备注里分享链接。
Lenny: 顺便说一句,你的声音特别适合做这种引导。你找到了自己的天职。
Jonny Miller: 谢谢,是的。录这些对我来说真的很享受。它基本上包含一段引导式身体扫描,所以这也是练习内感受的一个很好的方式。我之前没有提到的一点是,当体内存在皮质醇时,皮质醇基本上起着一种麻醉剂的作用,因此更难感知到那些感受。但通过这个——我想是一段 14 分钟的引导式 NSDR 练习——你躺着,有引导式身体扫描,背景有放松的音乐。结束后你会觉得自己像睡了两小时的午觉,感觉非常棒。
尤其是对像我这样下午容易犯困的人来说,如果你安排好时间——对我来说通常是下午 1 点到 3 点之间——它会给你一个下午的第二波精力,让你不至于在一天结束时瘫倒在沙发上。所以我认为它对提升内感受很有帮助,也有助于让身体降档放松,而不是一整天都处于那种高张力的交感神经状态。它给了身体一个休息的机会,而且感觉真的很好。说实话,这大概是我教的所有练习中被使用最多的一个,很多人每天都听。我也会把链接分享在节目备注里。
Lenny: 我猜如果你觉得自己已经积累了情绪债务,这个练习应该是一个很好的起点,对吗?
Jonny Miller: 是的,非常棒。我的意思是,有些人确实缺乏足够的精力从床上起来正常运作。但同样地,我想你的听众——住在硅谷的人——他们面临的挑战是不借助外部物质来实现降档。而 NSDR 是增强腹侧迷走神经张力的极好方式,腹侧迷走神经张力就是身体从”冲冲冲”的状态切换到放松状态的能力。我最近采访了 Kevin Kelly,他说了一句话:“如果你拥有出色的工作伦理,就需要配以同样出色的休息伦理。“而主动训练自己在压力后降档的能力,这部分在大多数人的工具箱里是完全缺失的。
最小可行的日常练习
Lenny: 我觉得很多这类建议,如果你听 Tim Ferriss、Huberman 等人的内容,每个人都有一个”每天应该做的事”的清单,最后变得越来越长,有太多事情要做——冷水浸泡、桑拿等等。你自己实践的是哪些?或者你会推荐人们从我们讨论的这些内容中每天做什么,哪些最有影响力?
Jonny Miller: 首先,尝试一系列不同的练习,看看你喜欢哪些,注意练习前后的感受。这是关键,因为一旦你知道它让你感觉良好,你就不需要强迫或激励自己去做了。你会自然而然地去做,因为你知道做完之后感觉很棒。我建议从非常简单的开始,比如从 4-4-8 呼吸或哼鸣开始,早上做两分钟就够了,一开始两分钟就足够了。同时我也建议至少听一到两次 NSDR 练习。如果你在家办公,午休后做很容易,或者在晚上回家后也可以。有些人用它来帮助入睡。
最后我建议的一件事是,如果你有条件和途径,找一位躯体从业者或躯体治疗师——这真的太有价值了。我的意思是,200 次呼吸法旅程之后,我变成了一个完全不同的人。我对生活的体验不同了,基本上释放了大量时间。甚至我的声音都不一样了。如果你听我四五前录制的播客节目,我的声音音调更高,听起来就是不一样,有一种不同的共鸣质感。
Lenny: 哇,好的,太棒了。你基本上已经总结了——我本来想试着总结你给的所有建议——但如果要基于这些建议做最起码的下一步:试试这个 4-4-8 / 3-3-6 / 2-2-4。如果做得很快的话,2-2-4 也可以吗?
Jonny Miller: 可以的。
Lenny: 好的,完美。那就早上做几天试试看效果。试试这个 NSDR 练习,我们会链接到一个引导录音。还有你推荐的别的什么吗?哦,躯体工作者,基本上可能是一位治疗师,也可能不是,是一位帮助你处理身体的人。
Jonny Miller: 对,我还要加上 APE 练习,甚至只需 15 秒,在早上呼吸练习之前和之后各做一次,这样你就能注意到差异。如果你做 NSDR,那基本上也是一段 15 分钟的内感受练习,所以一石二鸟。
冥想与 NSDR
Lenny: 你对冥想怎么看?它适合放在这个框架里吗?你觉得 NSDR 是否可以替代冥想的需求?
Jonny Miller: 这是一个很大的话题。我是一个热忱的冥想者,参加过很多次十日内观静修,还在暗室里待过十天。
Lenny: 哇。
Jonny Miller: 关于冥想,我认为关键取决于你在训练什么。这就像问”你对运动怎么看”——你在训练灵活性、耐力还是力量?冥想也是一样的。你可能在训练慈心,可能在训练专注力,也可能在训练开阔的觉知。所以我非常推崇具身化的冥想练习。经典的内观身体扫描就是一个很好的例子。同样,那基本上就是一个内感受练习,你只是将注意力反复移动到身体的不同部位,日复一日地持续进行。
Jonny Miller: 以内观禅修营为例,冥想有助于培养一项特定技能——增加刺激与反应之间的心理空间。如果你有一定的冥想练习基础,就不会轻易被某种情绪裹挟,或者盲目相信某种思维模式,通常能够稍微后退一步,观察正在发生什么。所以冥想确实有其位置。但我的观点是,过去二十年我们对正念和冥想有些过度偏重了。各种应用层出不穷,相关讨论铺天盖地,而基于身体的方法却被我们完全遗忘了。我不是说不要冥想。冥想当然有它的价值,特别是如果你的目标更偏向传统的”觉醒”——看透自我的本质,那在我看来是一条不同的路径。但如果你想要更有效地运作、与身体更协调,那么我们今天谈到的这类自下而上的练习则属于一个完全不同的类别。
《身体从未忘记》
Lenny: 说到自下而上的方法,我猜你一定很喜欢大家经常提起的那本书,叫 The Body Keeps Score(《身体从未忘记》)对吧?你会推荐那本书吗?它和你讲的内容关联大吗?你对那本书具体怎么看?因为我总是听到别人提起它。
Jonny Miller: 是的,那是一本好书。作者是 Bessel van der Kolk。还有一位作者 Peter Levine 说过一句话:“问题藏在组织中(The issues are in the tissues)。“基本上就是这个概念。它的核心观点是,我们体内储存着那些未完成的动员反射,通常以紧张的形式被保持下来。严格来说,说创伤存在于身体中并不完全准确。它实际上是大脑中的一个皮层映射在追踪这些东西。但从实用角度来看,它看起来和感觉上就像悲伤储存在我的右髋、愤怒储存在我的太阳神经丛一样——这正是我们的体验。而且你越是觉察这些感觉,开始发展情绪流动性,那些紧张就越能得到释放,你的反应性就越低,你偿还的情绪债务就越多。所以我认为 The Body Keeps Score(《身体从未忘记》)这个书名,更准确的说法可能是”身体是记分卡”。我觉得这算是一个小小的重新框定。如果你对此感兴趣,Peter Levine 的 Waking the Tiger(《唤醒老虎》)是关于我所描述的这种动员反射的开创性著作。
Lenny: 我之前一直没意识到那部分。基本上它实际上是储存在大脑中的,但表现出来好像是在身体的某个部位。
Jonny Miller: 对,没错。
反直觉观点
Lenny: 很有意思。我想花点时间聊聊这个播客中的一个新环节,我叫它”反直觉观点”。让我们进入”反直觉观点”环节——我觉得你在这里会有一些有趣的看法。问题是:你有没有什么非常反直觉的观点,即你相信但大多数人并不相信的事情?
Jonny Miller: 我们已经提到过,我不太看好以谈话为基础的冥想,这大概会招来一些评论。另一个值得一提的观点是,我认为我们严重低估了倦怠的影响,尤其是从底线角度来看的代价。几年前我做过一份研究报告,采访了一些领导者,他们都经历过某种程度的倦怠。我们问他们:如果估算一下倦怠给你的创业公司或企业带来的成本,你会说是多少?回答的中位数是十万美元,我猜这比大多数人想象的要高得多。而且大多数人并没有在积极投资”倦怠保险”。这不在大多数人的视野之内,除了冥想练习之类的事情。我认为成本之所以更高,部分原因是存在二阶和三阶后果——人才流失、机会成本、生产力损失,优秀的领导者在走向倦怠的过程中做出糟糕的决定。还有一个概念叫做情绪传染(emotional contagion),Wharton 有一些相关研究,他们表明领导者或 CEO 的情绪状态对团队成员有着不成比例的影响。所以我喜欢说的一句话是:一个组织的神经系统是 CEO 神经系统的映射。我认为这是一个我希望看到更多人讨论的话题。
Lenny: 关于倦怠这个话题,我想你并不是说不要努力工作——如果你想拼命工作的话完全可以。你需要做的是在拼命工作的同时维护好自己的身体、心智和神经系统。如果你长时间高强度工作,尽管去做,但要知道你在积累债务,而你在这个过程中需要做一些事情来偿还这些债务。
Jonny Miller: 完全正确。这非常像创业早期积累技术债务。它是值得做的,但要带着意识去做。要知道自己在做什么。比如说你拼命工作了八个月,那就给自己一两个月真正地减速休息。同时,建立神经系统容量也非常值得。能够拼命推进、高度专注,再配合休息伦理——这很棒。做非睡眠深度休息,找到减速的方法,这样那种工作方式才能持续。
闪电问答
Lenny: Jonny,我们到了非常激动人心的闪电问答环节。准备好了吗?
Jonny Miller: 来吧。
Lenny: 第一个问题:你有两三本最常推荐给别人的书吗?
Jonny Miller: 其实我预感这个问题会来,我把书都带在身边了。第一本是 David Whyte 的 Consolations(《慰藉》)。这是我送给朋友最多的书,比其他任何一本都多。他基本上对 52 个词给出了定义,比如”野心(ambition)“好像是第一个词。他的文字真的让我惊叹。我随便翻开一页,读一个定义,就深受触动——这本书对我的影响可能超过其他任何书。所以这是我非常喜欢的一本。第二本是 The 15 Commitments of Conscious Leadership(《有意识领导的十五项承诺》),我想你的播客里应该有人提到过。作者是 Jim Dethmer 和 Diana Chapman,他们创办了 Conscious Leadership Group。在我看来,这是我所见过的最好的领导力书籍,它将实用性与大量优秀的理论结合在一起。非常棒。最后一本有点另类——Jamie Wheal 的 Recapture the Rapture(《重获狂喜》)。我很喜欢 Jamie 的作品和文字。这本书 essentially 是三合一。第一部分探讨元危机和我们在世界上看到的种种疯狂。第二章与我们今天谈的话题密切相关,他称之为”快乐工程(Hedonic Engineering)“,基本上就是改变意识状态的练习。第三部分是”伦理性社群构建(Ethical Cult Building)“,这个我就不多说了。
Lenny: 你有最近最喜欢的电影或电视剧吗?
Jonny Miller: 我和我妻子都很喜欢动画,我们最近看了 Kubo and the Two Strings(《久保与二弦琴》),非常精彩。真的好极了。还有 Wolf Walkers(《狼行者》),是 Apple TV 上的动画。这两部是我最近看过的最喜欢的电影。
Lenny: 如果你喜欢动画作品,可以去看看 HBO 的 Scavengers Reign(《拾荒者统治》)。我之前在这个播客里提到过,但真的太棒了,是 HBO 上的一个剧集。我通常会问:你有没有一个最喜欢用来问面试候选人的问题?但我知道你做的是教练工作,所以我想把这个问题稍微转一下——你有没有一个最喜欢用来问你所指导的高管教练客户的问题?
Jonny Miller: 这个问题我是从一个叫 Jerry Colonna 的人那里偷来的,他在 Boulder 这边,这个问题非常厉害,真的好极了。基本上就是:你如何共谋创造了你所说的你不想要的处境? 这里”共谋”这个词是关键,因为它不是在说”哪些方面是你的错”,而是说——在哪些方面,你参与共谋创造了焦虑的条件,积累了情绪债务?这个问题基本上为你打开了一扇门,让你看到自己是怎样主动参与了生活中这些挑战的创造。这是一个非常好的日记问题,也很适合和朋友、联合创始人、同事一起探讨。
Lenny: 我记得很多年前他在 Tim Ferriss 的播客上分享过这个问题,一直记在心里,我经常想起它。不过我从来不共谋任何事情出问题,从来不是我的错。他拿我没办法。开玩笑的。
Jonny Miller: 很好。
最喜欢的产品
Lenny: 你最近有没有发现一个特别喜欢的产品?
Jonny Miller: 一个是这些蓝光阻隔眼镜。这是 Raw Optics 的蓝光阻隔镜片,能百分之百阻挡蓝光。天黑之后只要出门我基本都会戴,开车戴,有时候甚至和朋友吃晚饭也戴。基本上就能保证那天晚上睡得好。这是一个。
另外一个,前几天刚拿到的,你之前提到了迷走神经和那个设备,我这里有三个都是迷走神经刺激设备。这个叫 Neuro Sim,这个应该是 Pulsetto,我觉得这个是 Apollo Strap。我还没怎么用过,但它们基本上都是通过向迷走神经发送低强度电刺激来起作用的。这个夹在耳朵上,因为迷走神经经过脖子右侧。Pulsetto 也是类似的。我很好奇想比较一下这些设备和呼吸法、哼鸣以及其他基于身体的练习的效果。显然你可以同时做两件事,但我就是对这种探索很感兴趣。所以我还不能推荐它们,但我觉得它们的存在很有意思。
Lenny: 那该多酷啊?我们只要把这些东西戴上,什么都不用做了。起床,啪地贴上设备,生活就美好了。不用冥想,不用换种方式呼吸。我做播客的时候得把这些全戴上试试,看看效果如何。太好了。你到时候可得告诉我们这些设备用得怎么样,感觉真的很不错。
人生箴言
Lenny: 下一个问题,你有没有一个经常想起、会和朋友分享的人生箴言,无论工作还是生活中的?
Jonny Miller: “状态优先于叙事”算一个,我们之前已经聊过了。
Lenny: 状态优先于叙事。
Jonny Miller: 然后另一个我经常想到的,是我喜欢说的一句话:“做慷慨的假设。“我的意思是——在任何情境下,我能对这个人、这个处境讲出的最慷慨的故事是什么?不是天真地编造什么,通常这里有一个光谱:我可以假设他们是个坏人,出于恶意做了这件事;或者也许他们今天运气不好,也许他们背负了很多情绪债务。可以讲的故事有很多。我通常会练习去讲我能讲的最慷慨的那个版本。
Lenny: 我很喜欢这个说法。另一种描述方式就是”假设善意”,我也经常想到这一点。
Jonny Miller: 没错。
什么会让你不安
Lenny: 最后一个问题。你看起来总是非常平静,非常沉稳、稳定。什么还会让你情绪激动、心神不宁?那种时候你会怎么做?
Jonny Miller: 其实做这期播客之前我很紧张,所以在上线之前我做了一些呼吸练习、拉伸,还有一些哼鸣。我有时候还是会注意到自己在回避冲突。我已经在这方面主动练习了一段时间了,但我内心有一部分有时还是会回避冲突。我实际上注意到了这和与愤怒建立健康关系之间的联系。基本上就是允许自己表达沮丧——不是对某个人发泄,而是允许它存在。然后从那个状态出发,更好地为自己的时间设定界限,对正在做的事情说不。我觉得这是目前对我来说最鲜活的练习。
去哪里找到 Jonny
Lenny: Jonny,你太棒了。最后两个问题。大家在网上哪里可以找到你,了解你提供的课程和服务?我知道你教一门课程,还有什么其他的,聊聊这些,然后听众怎样能帮到你?
Jonny Miller: 好的,这真的很有趣。我在 Twitter(也就是 X)上很活跃,我的账号是 Jonny Miller,拼写是 J-O-N-N-Y-M-1-L-L-E-R。如果这些内容让你感兴趣,或者听众想更深入地了解,我教一门课程。下一期将在春季,三月底开课。申请现在已开放,网站是 nsmastery.com/lenny。我做了一个专门的页面,为听众提供了 250 美元的优惠折扣。
Lenny: 我自己都得报名了。我不知道你会做这个,太棒了。NS Mastery 就是 Nervous System Mastery 的缩写。
Jonny Miller: 没错。
Lenny: 太好了。还有什么要补充的吗?然后第二个问题,听众怎样才能帮到你。
Jonny Miller: 首先,如果这些内容引起了你的共鸣,我很希望在 Twitter 上收到你的消息,也可以给我发邮件,我可以把邮箱给你。我最希望大家做的就是去实践这些东西。我很喜欢”做生活的科学家”这个理念。如果我们聊到的任何内容让你有所触动,或者你想尝试其中任何练习,就去试一试,感受一下,然后告诉我你的体验。我觉得这就是最好的礼物了。
Lenny: 告诉你的最好方式是在 Twitter 上 @ 你,还是其他渠道?
Jonny Miller: 在 Twitter 上 @ 我,或者我的邮箱是 jonny@curioushumans.com,也可以发邮件给我。
Lenny: 好,我要把这些全都用上。Jonny,非常感谢你能来。你太棒了。我很期待节目笔记,我们会给大家提供切实可用的工具,帮助人们在工作和生活中减少焦虑和紧张。再次感谢你来。
Jonny Miller: 太好了。非常感谢,Lenny。这次超级开心。
Lenny: 我也是。大家再见。
感谢大家的收听。如果你觉得这期节目有价值,可以在 Apple Podcasts、Spotify 或你喜欢的播客应用上订阅。也请考虑给我们评分或留下评论,这真的能帮助更多听众找到这个播客。你可以在 lennyspodcast.com 找到所有往期节目或了解更多关于这个节目的信息。下期见。
术语表
| 原文 | 中文 |
|---|---|
| afferent neurons | 传入神经元 |
| allostatic load | 稳态负荷 |
| alternate nostril breathing | 交替鼻孔呼吸 |
| Andrew Huberman | 人名保留原文 |
| Andy Johns | 人名保留原文 |
| APE (Awareness, Posture, Emotions) | APE(觉察、姿势、情绪) |
| Apollo Strap | Apollo Strap(设备名,保留原文) |
| assume good intentions | 假设善意 |
| bellows breath | 风箱呼吸 |
| Bessel van der Kolk | 人名保留原文 |
| blue blocking glasses | 蓝光阻隔眼镜 |
| body scan | 身体扫描 |
| breath of fire | 火的呼吸 |
| breathwork | 呼吸法 |
| burnout | 倦怠 |
| confabulate | 虚构(心理学用语) |
| conflict avoidant | 回避冲突 |
| cortisol | 皮质醇 |
| Damasio | Damasio(神经科学家,人名保留原文) |
| David Whyte | 人名保留原文 |
| Diana Chapman | 人名保留原文 |
| disassociation | 解离 |
| efferent neurons | 传出神经元 |
| Elliot | Elliot(Damasio 的研究患者,人名保留原文) |
| email apnea | 邮件呼吸暂停 |
| emotional contagion | 情绪传染 |
| emotional debt | 情绪债务 |
| emotional fluidity | 情绪流动性 |
| endocrine system | 内分泌系统 |
| espresso breath | 浓缩咖啡呼吸 |
| Every | Every(出版物名,保留原文) |
| feather brick dump truck phenomenon | 羽毛、砖块、自卸卡车现象 |
| generous assumptions | 慷慨的假设 |
| Hakomi | Hakomi(疗法名,保留原文) |
| insular cortex | 岛叶皮层 |
| interoception | 内感受 |
| interoceptive awareness | 内感受觉知 |
| interoceptive capacity | 内感受能力 |
| Jamie Wheal | 人名保留原文 |
| Jerry Colonna | 人名保留原文 |
| Jim Dethmer | 人名保留原文 |
| Jonny Miller | 人名保留原文 |
| Kevin Kelly | 人名保留原文 |
| Lenny | 人名保留原文 |
| mobilization cycle | 动员周期 |
| Nervous Systems Mastery | 神经系统精通(课程名,保留原文) |
| Neuro Sim | Neuro Sim(设备名,保留原文) |
| nitric oxide | 一氧化氮 |
| non-sleep deep rest | 非睡眠深度休息 |
| parasympathetic nervous system | 副交感神经 |
| Peter Levine | 人名保留原文 |
| physiological sigh | 生理性叹息 |
| Pulsetto | Pulsetto(设备名,保留原文) |
| Raw Optics | Raw Optics(品牌名,保留原文) |
| somatic | 躯体的 |
| somatic experiencing | 躯体体验疗法 |
| somatic marker | 躯体标记 |
| state over story | 状态优先于叙事 |
| sympathetic nervous system | 交感神经 |
| Techstars | Techstars(孵化器名,保留原文) |
| TEDx talk | TEDx演讲 |
| Tim Ferriss | 人名保留原文 |
| vagus nerve | 迷走神经 |
| vagus nerve stimulation device | 迷走神经刺激设备 |
| vasodilator | 血管扩张剂 |
| ventral vagal tone | 腹侧迷走神经张力 |
| vipassana | 内观 |
| Wim Hof | 人名保留原文 |
| window of tolerance | 容忍窗口 |
| yoga nidra | 瑜伽休息术 |
此文档由 AI 分片翻译(translate_long_document)